Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to pay

92 replies

Auroraduffy · 10/05/2016 17:41

I am most likely being very petty so feel free to tell me.

DH and I have been together for 6 years, he has his own DS12 from a previous relationship, the break up was very very messy, happened when DSS was 1.

It's been very hard trying to find my place in this family, at first I tried to be involved with DSS but according to his Mum my help was not wanted or needed, so over the years I've become more of a friend then a parental figure to DSS, we only have him for the holidays as DH and I work long hours.

The families are very much separate, DSS' Mum remarried years ago, has other kids etc her and DH only communicate through email and it's normally her complaining about me.

E.g I bought him a phone, an exact replica of the one he had after it fell into the paddling pool when he was staying with us, his mother hit the roof. He loves art so for Christmas I got him this great set of paints and brushes, she complained and demanded that I was to not spend a penny on her DS, she's been very clear over the years that my financial contribution is not needed and has accused me of trying to buy off her DS.

DSS and I aren't that close, we get along, he's a sweet kid but his Mum has made it impossible for me to be a real part of his life.

DH has been paying for DSS' prep school through the years and DSS has managed to secure a place at a Public school this September, the agreement between DH and DSS' Mum was that for senior school, she would have to contribute 20% as DH simply couldn't afford senior school on his own, the fees are massively different. They agreed on this years ago, as they had to decide on potential schools when DSS was around nine.

DSS' Mum has just informed us that she will not be contributing to school fees as her and her current DH have decided that it wouldn't be fair to pay for one child to go to a fee paying school and not the others, they have 3 DC together, she expected DH to pay the full amount, which he simply can't afford to do.

When he emailed her that he couldn't do it, she emailed that of course he could, he should give up on certain luxuries to provide for his DS etc etc and that I could always chip in!!!

She has made my position over the years very clear, and I in turn made it very clear to DH that I have no intention of paying a penny towards DSS' schooling, plenty of great State schools around, if she doesn't want to chip in.

I said that all last night and now I'm feeling very petty.

OP posts:
peggyundercrackers · 11/05/2016 11:13

yanbu or petty - she has made her bed let her lie in it.

you don't have to be the bigger person - sometimes in life these things happen. just because you go to a good school doesn't mean its best for you. it would be a shame for the DSS not to get into private school but the guilt for him not being able to isn't your to carry. the EX obviously doesn't love her child or she wouldn't play games with his life. DO NOT FEEL GUILTY OR OBLIGED - you are being played.

dowhatnow · 11/05/2016 11:17

Your stock answer to how she can't justify it, is to say she should have thought of that before sending him in the first place as she has always been aware that she will have to pay 20% at this point. It would have been fairer to him not to send him in the first place.

KateBeckett · 11/05/2016 11:29

Yadnbu!

NeedsAsockamnesty · 11/05/2016 11:30

If you do end up paying then she funds all uniform, trips etc. No more maintenance whatsoever, because she can justify paying for those basics herself

Mum can still go to the CMS and get CM.

Granted them all dad has to do is stop funding school but the end result is still the same quandary because it's only DSS who has to deal with that

dowhatnow · 11/05/2016 11:34

You can get round that though by paying her maintenance and she puts that towards the fees.

BeYourselfUnlessUCanBeAUnicorn · 11/05/2016 12:17

I wouldn't bow down to her manipulative demands. She knows exactly what she doing.

Agree with your plan, tell her you are looking at good state schools near you, DH cannot afford to pay so she either pays her 20% or he comes to live with you. Grin Just tell her what is happening. She cannot spend your money for you.

LupoLounger · 11/05/2016 14:29

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

LupoLounger · 11/05/2016 14:30

oh b*gger. Cross post. Sorry.

MiddleClassProblem · 11/05/2016 14:45

Grin Lupo (that dress was waaaaay over priced on other thread)

BoatyMcBoat · 11/05/2016 17:03

maybeebabybee I went to a private prep school, with small classes, all very similar backgrounds, secluded grounds, all very naice. Then onto the local comp. Yes, it was a shock, but you learn to get along with all types very quickly, and get on with whatever work you have. I was bullied a little bit in the first term, but it stopped very soon.

I watch my cousins struggling to get along with normal folk, and thank goodness my parents couldn't afford the fees at secondary!

grannytomine · 11/05/2016 18:28

Boaty did you start in year 7 with everyone else or in year 9? I wouldn't worry about a change in year 7 but think it is harder in year 9.

OP if you do agree I think it only needs to be for 3 years, shouldn't be a problem with going to sixth form college for A levels.

MrsLupo · 11/05/2016 18:44

YANBU at all, OP. XW is clearly being manipulative. But like others I feel reacting to her behaviour rather than DSS's needs may be a mistake in the long run. Fwiw, I disagree that having siblings in a mixture of state/private schools is necessarily divisive. It's a question of choosing (ideally!) the right school for the child and there isn't necessarily a better/worse pecking order between the two. (My DS1 went to a small private school, DS2 is at a big comp, don't know what we will do for DS3 yet, as it's a bit early to know where he'd be happiest.) But equally, where siblings don't all have the same parent, I can see that choosing different types of school has extra ramifications. Sounds like you're poised to get your ducks in a row with information about other options, which may suggest some solutions. I can't help thinking someone needs to talk to DSS about all of this sooner rather than later though! And yes, if you are to end up contributing financially, XW has to back down over the extent of your role in DSS's life, which can only be a good thing anyway. Good luck with it all. You sound like a nice stepmum.

MrsLupo · 11/05/2016 18:45

And YY to sixth form college - cheaper and also a better transition to uni than private schools imo.

LupoLounger · 11/05/2016 18:54

@MrsLupo - "This thread isn't big enough for the both of us... I mean, how will we know when we're being tagged?"

Cool handle :D

LupoLounger · 11/05/2016 18:57

And YY to sixth form college - cheaper and also a better transition to uni than private schools imo.

+1 - I went to a sixth form college totally unassociated with my school. Provided a refresher on how to meet new people. Best environment for transition IMO.

Legendofthephoenix · 11/05/2016 18:58

My cousins were homeschooled and then privately educated at a secondary school. They still live at home and they are in their 30's. My daughter was homeschooled and now goes to a comprehensive school. It was very scary for her and she was bullied a little. She gets on with it now and she has made friends and doing very well. In state schools you mix with different people how else do you learn to survive in this world.

MrsLupo · 11/05/2016 19:28

I know, LupoLounger - and gawd help us if LupoLoopy turns up. We should probably take it into a private room tbh. Grin

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread