to ask you if you think this makeup was done by.....

[FighterPilotsThumbs]

a) a monkey with a tremor
b) a noob
c) an untrained but knowledgeable makeup fan
d) a makeup artist
Or
e) a drag queen

Votes please!

C

I think it reflects some talent, but not what I would consider artful.

C. They would need a fair bit of training too I think.
The design is nice and but I think the application needs some work. The eye lashes are not applied in quite the right place. The eye make up looks a little patchy.
OP, assuming you are the person who applied this, be encouraged and seek some training to learn the correct application skills. Your style is good in my opinion.

C or E. At least 50% needs to come off.

It looks dated to me. Late 80s.

Brows and blush slightly off. But it might be meant to look that way. For a specific shot? Specific period?

Without any context it's hard to say if it's good.

It looks like the noob option whatever that was!
If noob means newbie.
Resembles someone who got a load of new stuff for Christmas and is trying it all out together!
The lips and eyes are both pretty but far far too much for my liking (I don't wear makeup and hate this heavy slap but think it's more attractive when only eyes or lips stand out).

It does look like its on fine but resembles my dds playing with all the colours in their makeup box only much neater

Probably b)

Either way, imo it's far too heavy and doesn't look very nice.

B or e

Ok - do we get an answer now or are you still looking for more posts?

The lack of responses leads me to think the OP is a C who wants to become a D.

B or E I'm afraid. Too much around the eyes and nor blended together well enough (to my untrained eye anyway.)

Definitely C.

But this boring now, OP.

A) The 🙈 I vote the monkey!

It looks very overdone to me, far too much IMO (but then I am not a fan of heavy makeup in general).

D, your style or not, it's been done very well

C because the eye lashes look funny and make up is a bit cakey and for that reason also possibly E.

It looks like a theatrical make up, so I'm voting for E.

Oops, just noticed I didn't actually answer the question. I would say B.

D.

Definitely C. They love to slap on a good, inch thick layer. Good luck getting it all off.

A drag queen with a tremor, new to the world of make up application.

Post your photo on the mrsgloss&thegoss beauty group on Facebook. You'll get more opinions from people who love make up (and are very kind!)

Personally I like strong eyes and lips, you've done a good job, I think C.

Am assuming it is your work, OP. There is a lot of work gone into it, but there is just way too much make up and it looks 'placed' rather than creating an effect IYSWIM. I'm not explaining myself very well. Some people can apply eyeliner so that it changes the shape of their whole eye (for example the flick at each outer corner making them look more feline), where as other people just look like they have drawn a black line over their eye. There is a difference. The blusher is sitting on the cheeks rather than enhancing, and the lips are very 1990's Rimmel collection.

I'd say it had essence of drag queen tbh. It's quite heavy and the eye shadow areas are quite defined rather than blended. And the lips are strong.

But I don't know too much about products or application to be fair and I've done the same make up on myself for the last 30years

Maybe a before/after shot. Because if, say the model is riddled with acne then it's a fucking good transformation.

D