Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be upset my DP hasn't got my DD anything for her birthday?

100 replies

Sheusedtobesomeonelse · 26/11/2015 09:21

Never braved AIBU before.. but am quite het up about this so i’d appreciate an outsiders view.

I have been with my DP for a little over a year, he knows my 2 DDs quite well and also knows that birthdays in my house are a big deal, as is Christmas and easter.
DD1 is always on about her birthday as she always thinks she’s hard done by having to wait all year (we all have summer birthdays, apart from her)and then it being close to Christmas! I can understand her reasoning, even though I don’t agree with her being hard done by!

On Monday she will be 9 – when my DDs are with their dad for occasions like this (50/50 parenting) we celebrate the Thursday before. So today was the day that she was having her birthday with me.

My DP has no money left – he had an unexpected tax bill in October which left him short – and so hasn’t got anything DD1 for her birthday (his credit card didn’t go through on Sunday trying to put petrol in his car). He is not generally tight with money but not overly generous as he can’t really afford to be.

I am actually very upset for her and know that when she has her tea party tonight with my mum she will be “expecting” a little something from him (he got DD2 rollerblades when it was her bday in July), she might ask me but probably will not say anything directly to him, which will save him the discomfort of having to reply. She is quite shy and hates confrontation and has been brought up with manners (I hope!) so she knows asking for presents is a no-no. But i know she will be thinging about it. This morning he said he felt bad and would get her something “later”. AIBU thinking when your 9, 3 weeks later isn’t quite the same. (double standards I know as she has 2 birthdays as it is). In the coming weeks she is away on a trip and then with her father, which means it wont be possible to re-do a bithday bash before then.

I start getting birthday/Christmas things in the summer and do it all through the year to avoid having to pay for it all in one go as I can’t afford much anyway (even though this year she is being spoilt enough by me as she got a kindle, a lego set and some CDs). He has no children so I can understand that forward planning regarding birthdays and things is a little abstract to him. But still. I’m so upset for her. I'm thinking what message does it send out to my DDs, caring for them etc. AIBU? A nice card would be something as DD keeps them all and often brings them out and looks at them in the year (.. helps with the waiting!!).

For the record, he earns a little more than I do and we don’t live together so still have separate mortgages and stuff.

I left my exH for many reasons. His lack of implication in the family/planning/issues with money were amongst them.

OP posts:
iwantgin · 26/11/2015 09:51

I don't know why you do separate gifts?

I have one DS. DH has two Dc.

We put both our names on their gifts from us. I generally CHOOSE my DS gifts, he does the same with his. But they are from us both.

GruntledOne · 26/11/2015 09:52

Why don't you just slip him a couple of the CDs and suggest he give them to her? And he can maybe make up for it with a bigger Christmas present?

LineyReborn · 26/11/2015 09:53

Why should he be having to buy so many expensive presents?

guajiraguantanamera · 26/11/2015 09:55

I understand explaining this to a 9yo would be difficult, they don't understand fully about taxes, bills etc..
But tbh you come across as a bit grabby in this post, and a bit annoying. Sorry. If you acted like
that with me over a birthday present I would walk away.

Iliveinalighthousewiththeghost · 26/11/2015 09:55

I don't think he's particularly set the bar too high by other little one roller blades for her bd. To children presents are presents. Even if he just went to the pound shop and spent £5. It's not the cost its the principal.

laundryeverywhere · 26/11/2015 09:55

I agree give him one of your presents to give her.

MackerelOfFact · 26/11/2015 09:56

I don't understand where you think he's supposed to get the money for a gift from and why he should prioritise it over his tax bill and petrol, which are clearly essentials. Should he start pawning his possessions to buy something for your grabby DD?

Just stick his name on something you've bought her if you think she'll be 'upset.'

And then teach your child that someone making the effort to be there for your birthday should be appreciated, and that celebrations are not just about getting presents.

Sheusedtobesomeonelse · 26/11/2015 09:57

It is totally about treating my DDs the same way, not at all about the size of the gift, just to show that he hdan't forgotten her birthday.

I totally admit that i put the bar high for high days and holidays in my family as that was how i was brought up and i shouldn't expect my DP to do the same.

Life isn't fair, my DDs know that and yes i will not make an issue out of it (only in my head!), i wont even mention it. If the money aint there, it aint there as my mum says.

I shouldn't expect too much from my DP.

OP posts:
guajiraguantanamera · 26/11/2015 09:59

Mackerel I agree. If my dp was like this with regards to his dcs' birthdays/Xmas I would feel a bit cornered like I HAD to spend a fortune on a nice gift.. When in reality, somebody getting you a gift is a bonus, it shouldn't be expected.
I would be upset if I thought what I bought my Dsc affected our relationship.

Iliveinalighthousewiththeghost · 26/11/2015 10:00

Your grabby DD.
Have you heard yourself. You're talking about a little girl. FFS.

Branleuse · 26/11/2015 10:00

and really if youve only been together a year, im not sure why its a big deal. I think he was trying to impress you with buying your dd rollerskates, but its big spend that he hasnt been able to maintain.

MooseAndSquirrel · 26/11/2015 10:00

Because he bought your other DD a present it will probably be noticeable, I don't think YABU to be upset as I would be thinking the same.however a bit U to expect him to fix it without help.
I agree a present in 3wks is pointless - birthday is over then. So if neither of you have cash atm why not just give him one of the early Christmas presents you have been buying and he can replace/pay you back for that present in three weeks and if (like me!) you've been getting bits here and there since the summer, you're bound to have a least one descent thing already in for her!

LineyReborn · 26/11/2015 10:01

Did you suggest the roller blades to him?

Catsize · 26/11/2015 10:03

Just give her a reserve Christmas present, say it is from DP and don't ask him to pay you back. Sounds like he is doing more than enough. Why is this not obvious?

Sheusedtobesomeonelse · 26/11/2015 10:04

Lolling at my "grabby" DD.
I am clearly the "grabby" one. And nowhere have i said anything about large presents. He could make a lovely card He bought some rollerblades for DD1 because he wanted to, i have never, ever, asked for anything. And i wouldn't as i know he doesnt much spare cash. He wanted to do something seperate from me for her bday in July.

I'm not expecting him to get the money anywhere, i was bemoaning his lack of foreward thinking, but i have admitted this is my issue right in my OP.

Anway, a couple of posters have understood what i meant about seeing it as a fairness issue.

Thanks everyone. The nastyness isnt perhaps necessary, though this is AIBU!

OP posts:
guajiraguantanamera · 26/11/2015 10:04

It is grabby behaviour though Ilive..
And I would definitely reconsider my future with somebody if I thought this was how it was going to be every birthday or Xmas.
If my dp couldn't get my dc (a hypothetical one not the real ds we have together) a present due to money issues I would say "no worries, do you mind if I get a wee thing and you write a card with it so he doesn't feel forgotten or whatever.." There, sorted, no big deal.
However, if he just couldn't be arsed
buying something out of laziness that would be different.

MrsJayy · 26/11/2015 10:07

If you have christmas presents bought give him something out of those btw I totally get you want him to remember their birthdays imo the rollerblade present was a bit ott from a boyfriend a few months into a relationship

nilbyname · 26/11/2015 10:08

why can't he go in on one of the gifts you have got her???!

He can pay you back. Problem
Solved Confused

Crackerjack9 · 26/11/2015 10:08

I think perhaps you are being a little over-anxious about money and this whole situation, and it's making it hard to see a way forward.

I could be wrong, it's hard to tell online. And if I'm right, it's not a criticism as I am like that.

I think I'd just put his name on one of your gifts and on the card.

Sheusedtobesomeonelse · 26/11/2015 10:10

Yes, that is what i'll do, i have things set aside for Christmas that he can give her.

It was more of the principle of thinking of my DDs birthday, tax bill or no tax bill. Lordy!

OP posts:
MajesticWhine · 26/11/2015 10:11

I think YANBU in one sense, because kids can be quite sensitive to fairness and will notice if they are being hard done by. However, there is really no point being upset about it. It would make sense to lend him the money this time, so he can get a decent present, for the sake of fairness.

80sWaistcoat · 26/11/2015 10:12

Umm, I'm a step mum and have never bought a separate present for my step children - their mum and dad buy them presents. It never occurred to me that something separate from me was expected from what their dad was buying them...

nilbyname · 26/11/2015 10:12

Your expectations are way too high for this boyfriend. Special occasions are going to be a flash point for you as it sounds like he can't win. You need to address that with yourself x

Whatthefreakinwhatnow · 26/11/2015 10:12

I'm glad you can see it's your own issue OP. You surely can't expect to prioritise a gift over being able to run his car, and presents really aren't the be all and end all of life, so this could be a good learning curve for your DD. I have a DD of a similar age and when I explain to her that we can't get/do a certain thing this month because we can't afford to, she's accepts it without and strop or drama.
If it really means this much to you, do as PPs have said and let him give her one of your gifts, simple Smile

Hope your DD has a lovely birthday Cake

KeepOnMoving1 · 26/11/2015 10:14

Goodness your poor dp! He doesn't have the money, where do you expect him to pluck it from? You don't even have to give him so what do you think should happen?
Your 9yo will probably be disappointed but that's life.
And you need to rethink how you view these types of issues and your expectations of your dp, as you are massively unreasonable.

Swipe left for the next trending thread