Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

These bloody Benefits Street and Benefits Britain programmes are just nasty judgemental propaganda.

119 replies

GratefulHead · 28/05/2015 19:49

Following another thread I made the mistake of watching Benefits Britain.....or at least as much as I could stand before turning it off.

We met a large family with 14 kids....yep....huge family but one of very few such families nationally.

The voiceover says that the programme makers worked out the family's benefits at £70k per annum. And added "two of the children have disabilities so that means they can also claim Carers Allowance" as if that was such a crime ffs. They live in an 8 bedroom "benefits house" apparently and the cameraman was careful to ensure they got all the things like flat screens, games consoles etc into shot.

Then there was Sarah from Essex, a woman unemployed and probably unemployable. She is divorcing and planning to marry her new boyfriend she has known all of two weeks.(does she sound stable and employable to you?). She lives in a "benefits house" with her two adult children who the programme makers couldn't wait to tell us had never worked. From the short bit I saw of Sarah she came across as Dysfuntional ...and yes I did mean to put in a capital D! I would put money on her having had a crappy life right from birth with poor parenting which she has repeated with her own kids. I've seen other similar families....in all cases the families were know. To social services from when the parents were small children the,selves.

The last one was a 60 year old man who has been unable to work for the last two years due to degenerative arthritis of the spine, he walks with a frame and lives in a "benefits flat". But hey...who cares if he walks with a farm and is in constant pain as long as you get that footage of him playing his XBox eh? Judgemental and nasty.

I just wanted to scream FUCK OFF very five mins at the screen. Wtf IS a "benefits house"? Am I in a "benefits house" because it's social housing and I claim housing benefit (and Carers Allowance too), or if I pay my own rent does it cease to be "a benefits house" Is the private let a "benefits house" of the tenant claims housing benefit?

Seriously....these programmes are awful.....and I was so angry at the comment about Carers Allowance as they made it sound almost an "extra perk" for the family with 14 kids. Do you know what it's like to support a child with autism or ADHD or anything else which is severe enough to warrant middle rate care for DLA? It's bloody exhausting and non-stop, if my DS doesn't sleep then neither do I ....and its a regular occurrence too. How dare anyone think it is some kind of fucking perk. Live my bloody life for a week and then see if you still think it's a good deal! This week has been very difficult as its half term and my son has been full on in his tics and activity levels...day AND night!

These programmes just turn people against the most vulnerable....and they managed to pick three families with circumstances which were frankly not usual. Most families on benefits DONT have 14 kids (would like to see the stats for how many families nationally are both that large and on benefits), most families on benefits are far more stable and functional than Sarah from Essex whose new boyfriend was a homeless Polish man she met on the steps of her local Morrisons.
The poor man with the severe spine problem was almost flagged up as "deserving"...until the filmmaker spotted his XBox I assume.

Horrible and judgemental, I won't be watching any more of them. They need taking off air.

OP posts:
fairgame · 28/05/2015 19:53

YANBU.
I happened to see a bit of it last night and cringed at 'benefits house'.
I work but earn a crap wage so still get housing benefit for my private rental. I must live in a 'benefits house' as well.

BastardGoDarkly · 28/05/2015 19:55

Yup.

Rollermum · 28/05/2015 19:59

Yep totally agree, is vile. At election time it felt like propaganda for austerity measures.

UnspecialSnowflake · 28/05/2015 19:59

YANBU, but sadly a lot of people seem to want to watch these programmes so they can sneer and benefits bash. While there's an audience for them and a profit to be turned they will still be made.

AnyoneForTennis · 28/05/2015 19:59

I thought last nights programme was a bit better than the usual ones

They DID point out the large family was one of a few ( they said how many but I've forgotten)

The older mans difficulties and frustrations were put across

You don't usually get this other side pointed out

Fatstacks · 28/05/2015 19:59

We should film a counter series.

Inbred, rich and proud.

Would be ace, I wonder where we could find a bunch of clueless, middle/upper class twats to star in it.....

skinnyabc · 28/05/2015 20:07

Ynbu which is why I don't watch such crap

CommonplaceMagic · 28/05/2015 20:10

YANBU. It's vile TV.

The whole concept invites the viewer to feel superior to the nasty, scrounging poor people. I hate it.

meditrina · 28/05/2015 20:12

'Yep totally agree, is vile. At election time it felt like propaganda for austerity measures.'

As pointed out on the previous thread on this, the programme is made by a company headed by a friend and supporter of Ed Miliband.

morethanpotatoprints · 28/05/2015 20:13

I don't watch them as it is obvious why they are on.
What did Orwell call it? news speak? something like that.

It's particularly poignant at the moment as they want to appeal to any they haven't hooked yet, and as a last ditch to convert others.

Could be to keep us proles in our place so we don't rebel. But hey, I'm just an old cynic.

TheABC · 28/05/2015 20:17

This is why I don't watch it. 14 kids! That's two decades of nappies «shudder». I think my life as a working taxpayer is easier than that SAHP. Thank Gods we have contraception.

Ubik1 · 28/05/2015 20:18

I watched about 5 minutes of one and thought it was
A) depressing
B) boring

It's like Arabella the producer has come with a simply super idea about 'real people ,' yah and they're like on benefits, yah , and y'know, it's gritty but it's like funny too

Load.of. Shite.

Why don't they actually put on something worth watching.

NinkyNonkers · 28/05/2015 20:18

Yup, newspeak. And they are such A painful load of tosh. Combined with the Daily Hate et al they are doing a grand job of vilifying the very small population of 'hard core' benefit claimants.

glitteryflange · 28/05/2015 20:18

I don't watch it. It's shit. Plus I find it quite patronising to the people on benefits. Also feels it glorifies it.

MamaLazarou · 28/05/2015 20:20

Don't watch it!! It's a trap intended to make poor people hate each other so we ignore the fat cats.

Tryharder · 28/05/2015 20:23

Nodding along at the comments on here. They are indeed Orwellian designed to make us hate people on benefits so the Government can get away with massive cuts.

ssd · 28/05/2015 20:25

agree these types of propaganda programmes are utter shite

LotusLight · 28/05/2015 20:29

The latest made by the Milliband friend supposedly gives the view point of the claimants.

People like these programmes and one reason the Tories got in was people in the UK support their policies to try to ensure only those who genuinely cannot work receive benefits. That concept has been very popular indeed with both Tory and Labour voters.

fanjoforthemammaries7850 · 28/05/2015 20:31

Yes there was one on today called "my big fat Xnas benefits blowout".

Totally vile. And they work judging from the comments on MN frothing about those on benefits.

ghostspirit · 28/05/2015 20:33

the xboxes etc could have been bought my realitives. even if they were not i say good luck to them if they can find a way to save and buy them then all good.

i do think theses programes have been made on purpose so that people turn on the vunerable

fiveacres · 28/05/2015 20:34

Honestly, seriously, why watch?

I don't understand. If you lived in Ancient Rome and the gladiatorial contests evokes such a strong reaction, you wouldn't watch them, would you? So why watch this then come on Mumsnet which tends to be left leaning anyway 'fuming' about it?

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe2726 · 28/05/2015 20:36

Yes they are but why, OP, are you promoting them? You say how awful they are and started a thread about them... Confused

If everybody ignored these bloody awful programmes and stopped talking about them... they.would.go.away. Not difficult. I think your thread is either misguided or it's disingenuous and you'd like a ranty bunfight. I think that of anybody who posts threads like this.

fanjoforthemammaries7850 · 28/05/2015 20:36

I have never watched one. The titles themselves are vile enough.

Mn used to be left leaning. Sadly not now .everyone seems self interested and obsessed with the thought that people on benefits might be getting more than them.

fanjoforthemammaries7850 · 28/05/2015 20:37

I think the OP made a perfectly valid point. More people should object vocally to these programmes.

GratefulHead · 28/05/2015 20:38

Yeah point taken....I just got very ranty when I saw the small part I managed to get through before turning it off.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread