Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How much of a say do bridesmaids get on their dresses?

99 replies

SloanePeterson · 03/04/2015 16:16

Possibly about to out myself as a massive bridezilla so have donned my flameproof suit ready for a roasting. I'm getting married this year, it'll only be a small wedding and we're trying to do it as cheaply as possible. My dd is flower girl and I've asked my sister and best friend to be bridesmaids. Ds's dress is bought, as is mine, and both are ivory. I thought I'd like the bridesmaids in shades of ivory too. The difficulty here is that my dsis is away at university and my friend lives a good three hours away and getting them both together is a challenge to say the least. My dress is secondhand but beautiful, and neither bridesmaid objected to having second hand dresses, as they know we're trying to keep costs down and I'm not comfortable asking them to pay for their own dresses.

I've bought three good as new dresses, all different styles that haven't cost a lot at all, and with the intention of selling them back on if they're not right. My friend managed to come a few weeks ago, tried them all and loved them all, didn't mind which she wore. So far so good. My sister has come home from uni and has insisted that they're not right. She is as far from a diva as you could get, very bookish and, dare I say it, a bit dowdy, but she's decided she wants a very fitted dress, and in burgundy because she's so pale. I love my sister but I'm a bit thrown. I didn't mind the bridesmaids having different styles of dress, but burgundy is a no. It's a summer wedding and I wanted to keep it quite 'light' I suppose. Fake tan apparently isn't an option, and nor is a different bra, which I suggested might make one of the dresses look better.

We don't have a lot of cash but now my dad has said he'll pay for a new dress for dsis. I'm wondering if the issue is really that she doesn't want a secndhand dress, which is fine I suppose, my friend and I spent most of our uni days in one charity shop or another so it's not an issue for either of us. I want both of them to feel comfortable but I also don't want my friend to have to buy a new dress, which she's said now she will if she has to.

Where does this nudge into bridzilla territory? I want them both to feel and look great on the day, but I don't want to have to have dark dresses and I think that's what my sister is nudging for. Friend has similar colouring, looked great in the paler colour and honestly isn't fussed, though does have her heart set on one of the Ivory ones. How can I resolve this? I just can't get over my complete aversion to the idea of burgundy dresses!

OP posts:
WrappedInABlankie · 03/04/2015 16:34

When I was a bridesmaid I was given the dress colour (shit brown) and got to pick a style she liked I.e had to have complete boob coverage not even a cm of chest as her DH didn't like the fact "I always had my boobs out" Hmm them being 38GG and me not wearing a turtle neck instead of a standard vest top was having them out . They were all hideous as could be.

It was a hideous experience that put me off having any bridesmaids

SloanePeterson · 03/04/2015 16:34

Yes she's my sister, but she's ten years younger than me and tbh very very young for her age. I don't want to upset her but I also don't want to have to pander to her either. im not worried about standing out, my dress is totally different to the bridesmaids ones, mine is lace with straps and quite a train and the bridesmaids ones are calf length. I'm going shopping with her tomorrow but wanted to gauge opinions of wether I was being unreasonable first! It's all very well that my dad will pay for hers, but this then means my friend will feel obliged to pay too when she already has a perfectly good dress.

OP posts:
ThinkIveBeenHacked · 03/04/2015 16:35

Could you offer to treat her to a spray tan on the condition she wears a pale dress?

TwoOddSocks · 03/04/2015 16:35

You choose the colour and the style, the most I'd expect as a bridesmaid is to be able to avoid something that is grotesquely unflattering.

GraysAnalogy · 03/04/2015 16:35

I'd say no, tell her it will change the whole colour scheme so no, it's not going to happen. Be firm.

SloanePeterson · 03/04/2015 16:39

I did say about a spray tan but my sister doesn't wear make up and sees fake tan as terrible vain. She is pale but tbh all three dresses looked lovely. I think I'll see what happens tomorrow, I'm completely open to her finding something she loves in a different shade as the others could maybe wear complimenting sashes on their dresses, but it's not going to be a dark colour if I'm honest

OP posts:
JeanneDeMontbaston · 03/04/2015 16:41

Yeah, TBH, I'd hate a spray tan, so I can understand that. But if she looked lovely anyway, I think she is just being childish.

Has she not been to many weddings?

SloanePeterson · 03/04/2015 16:43

Funny you should say that jeanne, I've just realised that possibly one of the last weddings she went to was our brothers about ten years ago, where she was bridesmaid. In a long burgundy dress Shock I could weep!

OP posts:
Jackieharris · 03/04/2015 16:48

If she's that self conscious does she really want to be a bridesmaid?

Maybe just have one bridesmaid, problem solved.

JeanneDeMontbaston · 03/04/2015 16:49

Oh, no! Call her on that - point out you're not your brother, and at most weddings bridesmaids fit in with a colour scheme.

LoadsaBlusher · 03/04/2015 16:51

I have been adult bridesmaid twice and both dresses were picked by the bride.
Other bridesmaids and I had no choice in style or colour scheme.
I think you are being more than reasonable and bridesmaids generally have to go with the flow as it is not their day.

Eggynuff · 03/04/2015 16:57

I was going to say the same as Jackie, are you sure she wants to be a bridesmaid. If you gave her the choice of wearing the colour you want as one of your bridesmaids or the dress of her choice as a guest, which would she prefer?

EveBoswell · 03/04/2015 16:59

I agree with the others, OP. Your sister should fit in completely. You thought she looked good in the dresses you had. Was there a mirror around when she tried them on?

My bridesmaids were going to be my STBSiL and my own sister (about same age). I picked what I thought was a lovely royal blue dress for them both. STBSiL didn't love it but looked forward to being a bridesmaid in whatever I chose. My sister wanted to choose her own but I stood firm. In the end, she stropped and was not bridesmaid.

Stick to your guns, OP. This is your day. Hers will be in the future.

ThinkIveBeenHacked · 03/04/2015 16:59

Well, she has two options (1) wear a pale dress that you approve (2) not be a bridesmaid and wear what she wants.

ImperfectAlf · 03/04/2015 17:07

She'so lucky with the amount of choice you are giving her, tbh. When I was be for my sister, I had to wear a little bo beep dress, in Orange candy stripes. All I needed was a sheep! YANBU

SloanePeterson · 03/04/2015 17:08

I did wonder that tbh, if her complete lack of confidence was the problem. If she'd rather not be bridesmaid that would be fine but very Sad that she'd let her own low opinion of herself hold her back. I was worried she might not like being the centre of attention. But then why suggest an even tighter dress?

OP posts:
SenecaFalls · 03/04/2015 17:09

I have been a bridesmaid many times over the years and have worn some truly ugly-as-fuck dresses, all of which I had to pay for because that is the custom in the US. I just think of being a bridesmaid as playing a role; you wear the costume in the color the bride has chosen, and the next day, you forget it.
I think you are being more than reasonable.

One thing I don't understand, though, is why if your sister gets a new dress, your friend will have to get a new one as well.

SloanePeterson · 03/04/2015 17:13

Seneca if my sister gets a new dress it wil be vastly different from any of he ones she's had the choice of. They won't look like a part of any distinct bridal party if that makes sense. My friend is happy to accommodate my sister as, again, my sister is very young (acting) and my friend is the reasonable sort. What she wears really isn't an issue for my friend. But I don't feel at all right asking her to pay for my sisters choice.

OP posts:
millymae · 03/04/2015 17:14

My view is that it is your wedding, not your sisters, and this being so it's not unreasonable for you to decide on the colour of the dress you would like her to wear and especially so, as you are paying.

That said, truthfully what do the three you've bought look like on her? Are you expecting her to wear something that really doesn't flatter/suit her, (there's obviously a problem with one of them if you feel a different bra would make it look better) or is that just her opinion? If you genuinely think she looks lovely in what you've chosen then it's not unreasonable for you to stick to your guns (and your dad would be wasting his money on a dress that really isn't necessary). If she doesn't look her best, then in order to keep family harmony you may need to negotiate a more suitable colour with her.

I agree with you that burgundy is not particularly summery, but would it really be so terrible if your sister wore a dress in that colour (if she can find one at this time of year) Could your daughter perhaps have a burgundy sash on her dress to make your sisters choice look not so random. If you absolutely can't bear the thought of her wearing a burgundy dress, then what about navy blue or even black? If either of those colours don't take your fancy then are you carrying flowers? - if so, could your sister have a dress in the predominate colour of your flowers and carry an all ivory bouquet herself?

I'm just throwing suggestions out - having been a bridesmaid myself and hating the dress that was chosen for me I know it's not a nice feeling when you think you look awful, but equally I think that if you are a bridesmaid and not paying you have to go along with the bride's choice. I could barely bring myself to look at the photos so know where your sister is coming from if she doesn't think that what you've chosen suits her, but unless it makes her look like ten ton Tessie, then I think she is being a little unreasonable especially as your other bridesmaid is happy with what you've bought.

yeahokthen · 03/04/2015 17:17

I'm the same as Senca. I've been a bridesmaid four times, in dresses that I would never have chosen myself. I just thought it was part of the job, to wear what the bride wants.
I have a peach sateen leg of button monstrosity in the loft, with a broken hoop if she'd rather Grin.
Seems unfair that DS gets a new frock but you and the other BM don't.

StrawberryTot · 03/04/2015 17:20

I love an AIBU wedding thread, but I'll put the flamethrower away!! YANBU, it's you and your partners wedding so you can choose what you want.

In regards to your sister, it's a case of telling her to like it or lump it. I'd tell her that the colour you have chosen is the colour scheme of the wedding, end of, no discussion but she (your dad) is more than welcome to buy her a different style dress.

Embrace your inner Bridezilla Grin

SloanePeterson · 03/04/2015 17:21

Milly, she's a real slip of a thing, both bridesmaids are very small size 10s, she certainly doesn't look wide! The bra comment was because she wears very unflattering, soft cup (forgive me) granny bras that give no shape or support at all. Trying on a dress with that underneath is just going to look awful. I actually feel terrible for most of what I've said in this thread about my sister as I love her dearly. She is just very very young and unworldly, and tbh I think does feel quite uncomfortable about finally having a 'grown up' body. I've gone shopping with her before to buy her some flattering clothes but they end up unworn. I'm now wondering if I should have asked her at all and that makes me feel very bad indeed, there's no nice way for me to rescind the offer or for her to back out without feelings being hurt.
As for different colours, I'm not opposed to navy and it was one of the first ideas thrown around.

OP posts:
SloanePeterson · 03/04/2015 17:26

I'm also more than aware that if somene was posting on here about being made to wear something that didn't flatter their shape or skin tone people would have every sympathy. I just don't think that the dresses ARE unflattering, but we all have our hang ups.

OP posts:
Didiusfalco · 03/04/2015 17:28

You cant ask your friend to stump up the cash because your dsis is being - shall we say - 'particular'. Its just not on. If you are going to pander to dsis then you need to find the cash for the dress for your friend. Just because your friend is trying to be lovely and accomodating doesnt mean you should take advantage of her good nature.

icelollycraving · 03/04/2015 17:34

I'd tell your dad then if he wants to indulge pay for a dress for your sister that won't match your other Bm dresses will he be paying for those too?
Having a colour or theme running through & not matching is fine but lots of different ivories may not work.
The idea of the dress ft what she wore last time is quite handy to reinforce that worked then but not for you.