Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or does charity beat everything?

82 replies

feckfeckfeck · 06/03/2015 22:53

I've name changed because while I don't think I'm BU I've never posted my own AIBU before and quite frankly I'm terrified if this all goes wrong for me. But I digress, on to the tale of woe:

Nice day here today so DS (3) & I decided to go for a very exciting long walk to the big supermarket on the other side of town. While we're getting ready to go out DS was playing with my purse, taking out coins and putting them into this little purse his gran gave him. I checked and he'd taken about £3 - £4 in pound coins and 20p & 50p pieces. He then put his purse in his backpack and told me he would pay for the shopping today. So far, so cute.

Got to the shop, wandered around, picked up a few things then went to pay. At the till there was two staff members, one on till, one doing something else. DS charms them both by chatting away and I get bags ready, get my purse out to pay and try and clear up for both of them what DS is talking about.

The staff member not on till asks lots of usual questions about DS and I answer as I put the shopping in the bags. Then I notice DS and the till lady are counting something out and I think "oh, he's trying to pay the lady for the shopping" but when I look to see whats happening (yes I was distracted although he was next to me) I see the till lady holding a charity collection tub towards DS and she's helping him count all the coins from his little purse into the tub.

I told him to stop and had a look at what was left - just the 20p's. I must have looked at the till lady like this Shock as she just shrugged and said at least it was for charity. I looked at the woman I was taking to and she said something like "aww, at least it's for a good thing, not on sweets" (not verbatim). I stuck my card in the reader to pay and finally said I didn't think it was on the encourage a 3 year old to put all their money in the collection tub without asking their parent if it was ok. The woman on the till said nothing but the other one said (head tilted to the side and sounding sympathetic) "I know, but it is for charity" (that is verbatim, it's burned into my memory!)

I scoffed and left with DS, him asking did he pay for the shopping. I said yes.

So, AIBU in thinking you don't encourage little kids to put money in charity collection boxes without asking their parents first or does charity trump everything?

I know people will say I shouldn't have let DS keep the money. I know if it had been lost in other ways it would have been my fault but what happened today feels like it's been taken from him under my nose.

And yes I wasn't given him my full attention but he was at my side, I thought he was just talking to the woman.

The worst thing is I didn't even look to see what charity it was for. Knowing my luck it will be something dumb like a doll museum Angry

OP posts:
Oldraver · 07/03/2015 14:09

I would of stopped at the 'he took money out of my purse'...its not cute

Methe · 07/03/2015 14:14

Yanbu but that bit the main reason to not let him play with money; money is absolutely filthy and you have no way of knowing where it's been - down the side of some mingers sofa, in a druggys pocked with his wraps of crack, down the drains.. It makes me Envy just thinking about it.

Fauxlivia · 07/03/2015 23:13

I'd have made her take the money back out of the box!

Definitely contact the supermarket and the charity.

PrettyFeet · 07/03/2015 23:21
Grin

Found this funny actually.

No, I wouldn't complain to the shop FFS.

mommy2ash · 07/03/2015 23:48

seeing as you were standing right there she should have asked you if it were alright.

my dd's school are big on bringing money in for the missions around advent time. so much so that my dd snuck her money tin in her school bag and donated the entire thing. i was so annoyed the school took it off her. the last one had over 100 euros in it and this one was almost full, she was saving for her holidays in it. she was about four almost five at the time. i check her school bag every day since then.

i didn't have the heart to show her i was annoyed. she was happy she did a good thing and got a little reward from the teacher for being so generous which made her day.

Lamourestbleu · 07/03/2015 23:59

YANBU. No it doesn't be anything! I'd be fuming! Last time I checked charity was voluntary but the person giving should know exactly what they were giving. A three year old doesn't have that grasp!

Frankly I think you were nice to let it go. I'd be saying, "No, wait! Give me (whatever amount you want back) back." FWIW I only give to a very few charities anyway. I give generously, but although there are many good ones out there, I give to the few that mean a great deal to me. I would have given them a very token amount just to satisfy your child and left!!

PiperIsTerrysChoclateOrange · 08/03/2015 00:29

I wouldn't have allowed my DC to go into my bag or purse.

Of Course they have done and I have corrected that behaviour.

My purse is out of bounds and also my bag, it's not cute for a 3 year old to take money.

You should stop this immediately and teach him it's wrong to take money out of your purse.

The charity bucket what UR for not checking

New posts on this thread. Refresh page