Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jealous of DS's perfect GF (Will I be a toxic MIL?)

85 replies

Yestotallyunreasonable · 29/12/2014 17:49

(Name change).
OK OK OK. I know IABU. I just need people to straight-talk a bit of sense into me.

We are a fairly average family, averagely happy, averagely paid, averagely sized, averagely eccentric etc. DS (18) is not average - to me at least. He is very clever, witty, great company and a lovely person that I am immensley proud of. He is going out with his first serious girlfriend. GF is very bright, gorgeous, polite, friendly and talented. All fine and lovely.

So here's the unreasonable bit. GF and her family are just too bloody perfect. Perfect GF's parents are both extremely successful (well-known, top of their respective fields - yes I've been googling them ). The family is mega wealthy (think mansion with grounds) and all the siblings (there are several) are also fantastically good looking, highly successful in a range of high-powered professions and according to ds, all great company, hilarious and interesting. To cap it all, perfect dad is also a successful member of a hobby group that ds is obsessed by.

Since October ds has spent all his spare time with perfect GF's family and I feel like he has almost dropped our family and been adopted by hers. He's included in their family get-togethers and is FB friends with them all. We, on the other hand, have met GF a sum total of twice for no more than 3 minutes each time (enough to say hello and smile and for ds to then pull her out of the room in case we embarrass him by talking to her). We have suggested to ds lots of times that he invite her to ours or she joins us on a family outing or whatever, but ds is very uncomfortable with the idea and it's never convenient.

Am I BU to be a tiny bit jealous of perfect gf's perfect family and perfect life? Is it U to feel a tiny bit sad that clearly her family can offer ds so much more than we can? Am I being a future MIL from hell to wish that DS wanted to spend some of his time with his perfect gf here in our family home instead of all their time at hers?

Yes. I know I am. Now give it to me straight.

OP posts:
monkeytroubles · 29/12/2014 20:23

There is no such thing as the perfect family. They may seem perfect now but every family has their faults, foibles and weird family dynamics. Some are just better at hiding them than others. In the (unlikely, given their age) event that DS ends up marrying into this family, a few years down the line he will probably be complaining to you about his in laws Grin

editthis · 29/12/2014 20:31

I totally understand why you feel the way you do, but yes, I worry you will become the hellish MIL you fear if you allow these feelings to develop! (Though they are very young... There's no reason to believe they are about to tie the knot, surely?)

Because the thing is, it's not about her family's background is it? Perhaps your son is seduced to a certain extent by their charms, but it sounds more like - if he is like many eighteen-year-old boys I am aware of - it's just easier to be a guest than a host. Often girls at that age are more mature too, keener to share their family lives with their new loves, looking to the long-term when the boys might just be enjoying the present situation.

If she is so gorgeous, clever and charming, I'm sure your son is her match in every way, and you should feel very proud. Also remember that she is making him happy, which is surely all we mothers want (how much worse if she were controlling, demanding, unkind, narrow-minded, jealous?...). Your role is to make her feel welcome in your home when the time comes, as a thank-you for making your son happy. I'm sure she'll relish a different atmosphere, different conversation, getting to know you and your quirks just as he has been able to do with her family. Be relaxed and open and it will happen naturally. Smile

Yestotallyunreasonable · 29/12/2014 20:44

Lovely comments. Thank you.

I am happy he is happy and no, absolutely no chance of wedding bells ringing yet. He wants to travel the world first. Smile

OP posts:
Tinks42 · 29/12/2014 21:00

You're welcome OP. Of course you're happy he is. It is also hard to let go (weeps into my hanky) Grin

NanaNina · 29/12/2014 21:15

NO - OP you won't be a toxic MIL! The very fact that you mention this (even in jest) ensures that you won't be. I do feel for you though. I have sons and no daughters and though I love them unconditionally the older I get the more I miss a daughter. I'm fortunate with my DILs but then I'm a good MIL!

There is another quote "a daughter's a daughter all of her life and a son's a son till he gets him a wife" (not always true and has the same meaning as the other quote.) I think you need to talk to your son and say you'd like to get to know his gf a bit and agree how this can happen. Mind there may well be many more gfs in the future, and by then he might feel mature enough to introduce them to his family.

All we want is for our kids to be happy isn't it.....but there is another old saying "when they're little they make your arms ache and when they're grown they make your heart ache...." and that can be so true as parents of adults we can't just "makes things better" like when they are little. My sons are in their 40s now and whilst the things that I worry about change, the intensity of my love for them doesn't diminish............

MammaTJ · 29/12/2014 21:16

YANBU! As a mum of a DD who has married at age 19 and been totally encompassed by her DH's family, I get where you are coming from!

This Christmas DD told me she could not come to ours for Christmas dinner because as newly weds, they wanted to cook at home. They gave us a generous 2 hours at mine, then went to HIS parents for their Christmas dinner! DSIL gave it away by saying that next year they would like to do their own! Pics were posted on FB!

I am at least comforted by the fact that my DD cared enough to lie to me to protect my feelings!

TheGuiltEatsMe · 29/12/2014 21:20

ZeVite I am reading he Wild Ass's Skin at the moment, I love Balzac, I am just sad I have to read it in translation. If only I had paid attention in school!

I am dreading this too. DS is looking more like a man every day and he is beautiful, I have given him strict instructions and a clip board with a very exacting characteristics Grin one of which is she must like me! if she likes me she will be rare indeed.

Tiptops · 29/12/2014 21:23

You won't be toxic if you're conscientious enough to start this thread!

I don't even think YABU to feel sad he is choosing to spend so much time away rather than with you.

However, you would be U to blame the girlfriend when it's your son where the issues really lies.

Lastly, you are not 'mental' (as another poster offensively put it) to have googled the family, that is pretty standard now!

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 29/12/2014 21:27

I am just sad I have to read it in translation. If only I had paid attention in school!

I have said exactly same thing, if only I knew what there was to read!

Not heard of Wild Ass Skin! Sounds....interesting....

Lost Illusions Is I think my fav book of all time, I have also read Eugenie Grandet and cousin bette.... off top of head, all utterly fabulous. Also love Zola - Nana esp...and Flaubert. I have his biography but not read it yet. He had such interesting life and I have visited his house in Paris.

Guilt, just add to list she must like Balzac, then you will be sure to like each other.

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 29/12/2014 21:28

Lastly, you are not 'mental' (as another poster offensively put it) to have googled the family, that is pretty standard now!

Just make sure your not googling them on linkden with an account yourself as it will email them and tell them!

Boomtownsurprise · 29/12/2014 21:30

Shit. Mamma. That IS harsh. I'd cut her off...

For at least two weeks

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 29/12/2014 21:31

Mamma that is harsh indeed.

Hang in there, just keep door and communication open, when I look back on how I hurt my poor mother....totally un intentionally ....i came back though...she was never horrid to me...

Yestotallyunreasonable · 29/12/2014 21:38

Very good point about Linked In ZeVite. I'd better warn dh. Wink

OP posts:
Yestotallyunreasonable · 29/12/2014 21:42

And yes, Mamma. Ouch. Sad

I bet you they'll be delighted have Christmas back with you once the newly wed novelty wears off.

OP posts:
SisterNancySinatra · 29/12/2014 21:48

Must be a huge weight off your shoulders poster, time for You Time now! So go on and have a ball !

Hassled · 29/12/2014 21:50

At 18 there's no way my DS1 would have willingly let me spend time with a GF, or in fact any of his male friends if he could possibly help it. Now he's late 20s and he and DIL have happily spent Christmas with us. The change came someway through university - he just needed to mature enough to realise we weren't actually weird freaks of nature.

By contrast, DS2 is very comfortable about us knowing his friends - so I know it was never us. So don't dwell too much on it - he'll sort himself out.

Babycham1979 · 29/12/2014 22:01

^Add message | Report | Message poster ZeViteVitchofCwismas Mon 29-Dec-14 21:28:56
Lastly, you are not 'mental' (as another poster offensively put it) to have googled the family, that is pretty standard now!

Just make sure your not googling them on linkden with an account yourself as it will email them and tell them!^

Yawn! I know subtle irony doesn't carry well on here, but please get over yourself. The whole thread is tongue-in-cheek, it doesn't need a PC language zealot on her high horse, policing what we say.

TheGuiltEatsMe · 29/12/2014 22:03

ZeVite Yes she must, absolutely must love Balzac Grin Flaubert, I have only read Madame Bovary, but is one of my all time favourites.

I guess it is an age thing. At ten they start grunting instead of talking, that wears off in time for teenage strops and throwing football boots up the hall every morning, to be replaced with the idea that parents are uncool.

What will you say to you DD Mamma

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 29/12/2014 22:06

Babycham1979 Mon 29-Dec-14 22:01:12

you have pasted two comments there one by me and one by another poster but its my name you are mistakenly slurring there.....

MammaTJ · 29/12/2014 22:07

I will say nothing! I do not wish to prove toxic accusers right! It is hard, it hurts like you would not believe, but I will not react!

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 29/12/2014 22:08

THE GUILT

If you love Madame B try Effie Briest by Fontane ( sp) same thing but I think better....(love M B too) sorry to derail op!

Tinks42 · 29/12/2014 22:20

a novel competition now? errrr Ive read "bridget jones diary" then went on to watch the film, great laugh... Is there a underlying threat that women won't be thought of as being fantastic unless they are wordy and "well read"?

What about being real?

Tinks42 · 29/12/2014 22:31

what about the OP just saying she is missing her son and quite understandably jealous about him wanting to be at the girlfriends house all the time, what about us telling her she has done a great job in bringing him up to be totally loveable within her family?

Surely, its what we all go through. I applaud your honesty OP....

Fabulous46 · 29/12/2014 22:41

Mamma that was a very hurtful thing that your DD did and it was completely unnecessary to lie to you. I don't expect any of my kids to come for Christmas although the offer is always made. Most are married or with a DP and we expect them to spend their Christmas Day however they choose. I could stay silent if I'd been lied to I'm afraid, especially finding out about it on FB.

MammaTJ · 30/12/2014 04:48

Fabulous I always look at the intentions behind actions! I am sure she told me what she did in order that I would not be hurt!
The forgot what she had said! She is a rubbish liar, not enough practice!

Swipe left for the next trending thread