My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

AIBU?

to think my upstairs neighbours are taking the utter...

167 replies

MoanyOldTiredMum · 24/05/2014 03:04

Forgive me this is going to be epic and humiliating so have name-changed but I need to unload and get it all out in one and it has probably been moaned about loads before.

Moved in here about 15months ago, big old building (so no soundproofing, wooden floors etc), mostly owner occupier and mostly quite elderly so quiet, look after each other and all happy to have a poorly dc to dote on. Travelled a lot last year so wasn't around every weekend and only noticed occasional gatherings upstairs that got a little loud drunk chatty but generally seemed to be not too intrusive or late. Very quiet over summer then a BIG party followed by lots of DIY type noise leading me to think new owners were in and hopefully all would quiet down after the initial housewarming, settling in and then realising that your neighbours can hear EVERYTHING!

Wrong. Every other weekend, friday night preclub party upstairs, first I know is flat filling up with people from 930pm doesn't stop til after 1am. Then back at 4am crashing about, slamming doors etc. This is on top of 4am noisy taxi deliveries to the front door on thur/sat/sun, (thurs is student night here) so 4 nights per week plus the occasional tues or wed thrown in for good measure. New Year's Eve was the tipping point when I was woken at 530am by someone coming back putting on music for half an hour then turning it off (by which point I was up with dc) then once the bells went and my other neighbours came over for a drink and left about 1am, we all went to bed and upstairs party started at 2am and went on until 530am. I was zombie mum on new year's day, and lots of saturdays after.

There was a leak in my ceiling one feb eve so I had opportunity to meet upstairs neighbour, show her my flat, point to teeny tiny dc wheelchair next to front door and heavily hint that we were being very quiet because dc is asleep. Hoped that would do it. Nope, but had contact details now from girl I met who told me she and her flatmates owned the flat, cut to the following weekend and I texted her at 1am to say my 3yo has now been up for 2 hrs so please turn off music thanks. No answer, music went off then back on quieter a little later, until after 3am. Got a message the next day apologising, she wasn't there and would ask flatmates to keep it down in future. I asked her to please come for coffee (so I can have a civil shut it type chat) and gave a couple of different times, no answer, contact stopped.

So next party I called 101, no one showed. Next party I called 101 and really insisted they come over. They did, twice, because party goers smoking outside saw them coming so when upstairs heard my door go they all went really quiet, then cheered once the noise team left (they had heard the party coming up the street anyway so went around the block and then logged it). When the noise team did go up and ask for the party to move on the students refused on account of they were going out in an hour anyway?!? They did go out an hour later (1am) but not before stamping repeatedly on the floor whilst yelling 'fuck you fuck you' all the way around the flat and into the street, really intimidating. And that was that, just advised to keep logging complaints.

The guy in the flat above theirs is the unofficial factor for the stair and called me about some repairs, whilst talking I find he is also bothered by the noise, though not quite as bad, and the rest of the neighbours in the stair are narked by the front door banging and stair noise etc.

Turns out it is a student flat upstairs from me and the flat is owned by the mother of the girl I met not the people living there, we all think maybe 4 or 5 people live there, which is more in one flat than all the other flats put together. There is no landlord listing or HMO license or anything, not familiar with the rules but it seems they consider themselves exempt. So I get the number for the owner but hesitate in calling because I figure it could go either way since I am calling a mother to complain about her child and I am not good at confrontation, hate it.

Following the noise team intervention the students up the ante by stamping, properly slamming their way about at all hours and frequently waking us all up. After a month of thinking I have no choice but to call owner I realise the plaster on my ceilings is cracked, in every single room and so I make the call.

Spoke to father first, who was mortified, then was called back by mother who was very apologetic, this year's lot of students are a lot younger than last year's phd students; any more parties and they are out etc etc. All good, and she is visitng the following week so will come and see the damage. And the only people who live there are her daughter and two others!

Between that conversation and the next, the tone completely changed and I was hearing noise from another flat perhaps, or they were good students who never went out drinking, I must be thinking of someone else Shock!?! Oh and the party the team were called too was just a little dinner party with one or two guests. The factor guy also tried to have a chat with her and got the same line, total denial. Her answer to my cracked ceilings? Oh well I have seen worse Shock !!!

Anyhoo all was good for a couple of weeks after her visit (which was to oversee floor sandings, she refused to consider carpeting, and also swapping a same size bedroom with a sitting room so that their sitting room is not above a bedroom because their bedroom is carpeted so no compromise whatsoever). I was told to contact owner directly and not council noise team in future.

Then last weekend we had a return to evening stampathons resulting in me texting owner at 10pm sun eve to ask that the students please stop banging around because dc was ill from 4th disturbed night in a row. The phone went upstairs immediately and then all quietened down so I went to sleep and was woken later by her ringing me at almost 1am to say she had just received my text and had spoken to the students and woken them up so ~I must be sensitive to noise and hearing it from another flat Angry! There were no more visitors or music or anything that could be causing a problem and obviously the students were just walking around and being as quiet as they could, blah blah blah. This went on for a bit with her totally trying to gaslight me into thinking I have a crazy imagination, lucky I was tired or the conversation would have ended very abruptly, as it was I just said mhhmm a lot and got off as soon as I could. She did relent and give me their landline to call them if they are being noisy.

Now this evening guests arrived upstairs at 1130pm, waking dc, and left about 1am when I started banging about flushing loo etc really noisily to make them realise we are awake and fuck the actual fuck off which they did eventually in staged groups, thinking they were being sneaky but the drunk high heels on wooden floors and hysterical laughter outside the front door as they scarpered kind of gives the game away, no Hmm?

I considered calling them but figure there is no point, they have no intention of stopping this and anytime I try to communicate the situation just gets worse and I can't be bothered with being woken up repeatedly whilst they try to get even or whatever it is they are doing.

I will move Sad, (I rent and the flat and other neighbours are lovely), but it won't be immediate and I need a short term solution. I am sure owner told me initially they were finished in june and there would be a new tenant but when I last spoke to her that seemed to change to september and I really don't think she can expect us all to put up with this crap until then, also I fucking object to being called a liar, (as does neighbour two up) because owner has to believe what students say and can't we see that ( Shock no I fucking can't they are overgrown nocturnal teenagers with no morals), AIBU?

And congrats if you made it this far Wine, I feel a bit better now I wrote it all down!Thanks

OP posts:
Report
ChelsyHandy · 25/05/2014 21:44

TheBogQueen in all Scottish cities in which medicine is studied, HMO licensing kicks in at 3 or more unrelated persons sharing a flat.

Plus Private Landlord Registration on top.

Report
Pipbin · 25/05/2014 21:46

Read this and thought of this post: www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-27502469
It's about a sitcom in Paris where is it common to live in flats, like it is in Scottish cities.

Report
TheBogQueen · 25/05/2014 21:48

Sounds like op should get on to the council then. She will
Be doing them a favour in ensuring all
Fire safety requirements are in place all of which cost a flipping fortune

Report
Itsfab · 25/05/2014 21:49

Only read the OP so far but what about recording the noise, etc? She can't deny it then!

Report
ChelsyHandy · 25/05/2014 21:50

How many people are actually living in this flat, OP?

Report
TheBogQueen · 25/05/2014 21:51

That Paris feature sounds very familiar - except I glasgow the chief annoyances are fag butts, chip wrappers, late night taxis and pre club parties.

Report
KatieKaye · 25/05/2014 21:52

yes, leases are very common in tenement flats that are rented out in Scotland. In fact, it is normal to have a lease when you rent. A lease is merely a form of contract after all.

As I've tried to explain, in Scotland only certain types of leasehold property are capable of registration. The current statutory provisions are found in s2(1)(a) i of the Land Registration (Scotland) Act 1979 while s3(a) provides that registration is the only way in which such a lessee can obtain a real right to that lease.

Most residential leases are of short duration and are therefore not capable of registration. Tenement flats are especially popular for renting out in all the major cities in Scotland - for example, in Edinburgh there are whole swathes of the city (eg around South Clerk Street, the Meadows etc) that have flats that are predominately rented out to students. In the same tenement building there will also be other flats that are privately owned and occupied. there are other tenements or blocks of flats that are entirely rented out.

Report
KatieKaye · 25/05/2014 21:55

For a humourous look at life in Edinburgh tenements, try Aleander McCall Smith's Scotland Street books. (he's on the law faculty at Edinburgh university too!)

Report
cerealqueen · 25/05/2014 22:12

All sounds horrendous! Aren't wooden floors forbidden in flats? Though this seems to be only a proportion of the noise being made.
Lots of good advice on here. Hope you get some resolution.

Report
brdgrl · 25/05/2014 22:17

Yes, contact the university. Mine has specific regulations about antisocial behaviour...

Report
ElephantGoesToot · 25/05/2014 22:25

Honestly partly yabu, music yanbu but walking about, the phone ringing, flushing the loo, closing doors...if you can hear all that you need to soundproof your flat.

Yes of course because everyone can do this in their rented 200 year old flat.
Are you for real?

I live in a block of apartments, also about two hundred years old, and we all are, in general, very considerate of each other, despite their being many children and a mix of people in the block. We are very lucky to have good neighbours, though.

Report
Spongeshampooloofah · 25/05/2014 23:15

Look on the land registry for their address. For a small fee (£3?) you can read the terms of their lease, then make their landlord comply.

Report
Igggi · 25/05/2014 23:27

I can hears someone having sex two floors away. I think the sound travels through the chimney. And people running the bath in the same flat (hence I never sing in the shower!)

Report
MoanyOldTiredMum · 26/05/2014 00:37

That bbc link is hilarious, thanks for that! I also seem to spend a lot of time pretending I can't hear my neighbours dtd, the fact that the building does actually move doesn't help Grin and BogQueen you forgot to mention the early doors passing renditons of "Sheddy bonnn..." big yin style.

and this totally sums it up;

"I'd so add that students need to realise they are no longer in halls when they decide to pay tent on that pricey beautiful tenement.

There are loads of purpose-built students flats but the well heeled like the lifestyle that a high ceilinged, sash windowed flat brings.

Most people live in tenements with the expectation if noise. You learn. You send a letter round when you have a party. You take your shoes off in flat. You keep children quiet on weekend mornings.

Students brought up in , no doubt, larger detached properties have no flipping idea"

But the savagery is that the only way students can afford it is to pack em in like sardines in a tin. First time my downstairs neighbour casually mentioned she could hear my shoes in the hall was the last time - shoes off as soon as I am in the door ever since and I regularly check in to see if we are being any bother. I proper tiptoe at night too, would probably have been made to sleep in the garden if I grew up stompin about the place!

How can people get by without talking to their neighbours?

OP posts:
Report
Toadinthehole · 26/05/2014 01:46

Good luck OP. I do hope you won't be put off doing anything by promises and apologies. I have had my share of bad neighbours in the past and know how much a misery they can be.

I strongly recommend that you tell your landlord about the damage to the ceiling forthwith.

I used to live in Victorian tenement flats right in the middle of student territory and never remember being that disturbed by noise (my bad neighbours were elsewhere). I say this to point out that the racket, actually harassment your neighbours are inflicting on you doesn't sound in any way reasonable.

Report
Toadinthehole · 26/05/2014 01:51

Just to add that I think the amount of misery inflicted by increasingly cheap, loud hi-fi is hugely underestimated. It depresses me that people should have to rely on councils our the police to do something about inconsiderate neighbours. There ought to be a law.

Report
kinkytoes · 26/05/2014 07:17

They do sound like spoilt little rich kids to me.

I hope things improve for you and that by taking all the advice on here, you at least feel you're doing something constructive about your situation.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.