Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would it be unreasonable to take a guy back...

98 replies

CouldDoWithABrew · 17/02/2014 22:44

If he did the 'dirty' on you? Then suddenly he realises how much he wants you in his life and says 'I didn't treat you well enough then but I'm willing to now'. Then has dinner with his ex gf (once) cos she's 'just a friend'. And he fucks off on stag do's cos he thinks you'll be ok with it cos apparently you can trust him now.

But you can 'tell' he has changed for the better deep down.....

Discuss...

OP posts:
CouldDoWithABrew · 18/02/2014 13:15

On a brighter note, I'm considering applying for a job that is miles away. It's a great career move and means it would give me plenty of distance from him. I might be emotionally screwed but I still have the capacity to work

OP posts:
HelloBoys · 18/02/2014 13:16

I'd never take a man back full stop but especially NO re the cheating and the seeing the ex GF.

Leopards (changing spots), trust, lying. no to all three.

HelloBoys · 18/02/2014 13:16

Could - PLEASE apply for that job, sounds perfect and you'll be well away from the loser.

CouldDoWithABrew · 18/02/2014 13:17

Meadow you are after my own heart. Stupidly I took him back after playing the friend card. I shoulda stayed in Friend Zone. You live & learn and it would have been so much easier being his 'mate' after what he did. It's better than being constantly on edge

OP posts:
YouTheCat · 18/02/2014 13:18

Why invest so much emotionally in someone who has hurt you, who you don't trust and who needs to learn to be a decent human being?

He is utterly selfish and will disregard your feelings again as and when it suits him.

HelloBoys · 18/02/2014 13:19

Can you explain Could re the friend bit?

I almost never stay friends with exes as no point, what for? Unless you were friends before you met and even then what's the reason?

Hissy · 18/02/2014 13:25

Now I'm in a predicament. What if you lot are right?

we USUALLY are love... :)

In all my years in relationships, despite a number of them being total tossers, I have never had to TRY not to cheat on them.

You either cheat or you don't. the choice really IS that simple.

Don't be an idiot. don't take him back.

You should never ever have been in Friend Zone after he did what he did. Please don't think being a 'cool girlfriend' is a good idea. It usually isn't.

AnyFuckerHQ · 18/02/2014 13:30

Ugh, I wouldn't stay "friends" with a prick like this either

friends don't treat other like this

Hissy · 18/02/2014 13:31

What's with the HQ love? Have you finally been given a wing in Mumsnet Towers?

Hissy · 18/02/2014 13:31

that was to AF btw... Blush

CouldDoWithABrew · 18/02/2014 14:01

Helloboys He was my friend before we entered into a relationship - I deemed him to be a good friend too but always felt like there was something more between us. Months down the line we stupidly entered into a relationship. He was still cut up over his ex missus leaving him (for someone else I might add - the guy she is now engaged to). She left him waaaaay before I met him. He tried to convince himself that me and him were good and that he could make it work with me. Turns out he couldn't so he turned to other women behind my back. He slept with someone else when he went to Ireland for his birthday trip but didn't tell me about this. I guess I was in the 'relationship' and he wasn't at this point. Upon his return from Ireland all he said was he couldn't be with me.

I cut off contact with him and few months lapsed. He got back in touch with me again and me deciding to be the bigger person and that I did in fact want him in my life as I missed our friendship I decided to give friendship a shot. He told me he still had feelings for me. I laughed it off.

We continued to be friends for sometime and I eventually started dating someone else. Suffice to say he stopped talking to me when I told him I was seeing someone else. I told him to grow up (he's 41 ffs!). He apologised for being immature and said he was being silly, wounded pride and all that.

Me and the guy I was dating fizzled out, I didn't feel the same way about him so we parted ways. That's when my partner decided to step in and 'sweep me off my feet' again. I asked him why he felt he couldn't be with me early on and what made him bin me off. He said he was still cut up over his ex and wasn't sure of himself or what he wanted. I asked him if he slept with anyone whilst we were together. This is when he told me yes 1) the skank in Ireland and 2) another skank closer to home. Hurt was not the word. And he had a nerve to stop speaking to me cos he got jealous of me dating someone else (I never slept with this bloke, my heart wasn't in it).

I asked him what's changed. He said me dating someone else and realising he could lose me made him realise how much he had taken me for granted and how much he only wanted to be with me blah blah. He was know longer getting those 'feelings' for his ex and he slept around because of his messed up emotions. But he has promised me he won't do anything like that again as it took another guy to make him figure out just how much he 'cared' for me.

I decided to give him the benefit of the doubt and for all intents purposes claimed sure I'll be in a relationship with you but you have really destroyed my trust and I want you to make it up to me. About 2 weeks later, I get the call that he would be having Chinese with his ex. He was straight up and honest about it but I was crushed. Turns out I too was invited but I'm wondering if he said that just cos I kicked up a stink about it. But he went ahead with it anyway knowing how I felt but like I said there was a group of them. I still think it's pushing boundaries tho.

Then a few weeks after that it was the stag do in Spain. I asked him not to go (God that sounds controlling). But he said 'I booked it before we got back together, I can't back out now, you just have to trust me'. I said I couldn't. He said 'If I don't go on it, I would like you to book us somewhere to go for that week instead' (the cheeky b***d!!!). Regardless, when the time came he ended up going anyway. Probably to save face and not look like a whipped pussy.

I hated it the whole time he was there. I asked him to tell me everything when he got back. I grilled him over it.

As the months have passed (but my demented emotions haven't Sad) he has now said he is in love with me and anything that would hurt me would hurt him. But I CANNOT get over his past so it regularly comes up in our conversations. One of us will eventually break, as I am pushing him away and even if I wasn't I feel resentful and miffed at having my feelings pushed aside. He says in retrospect it was very selfish on his part to put me thru all this and he does seem sincere about it now. At the time I doubt he could have cared less. This was months ago so I should let it go. But I can't and now I'm in a pickle.

His ex has since contacted him to say she is engaged. This brought back a load of shitty feeling for him. Hence he has since told her he cannot be friends with her any more. But he should be over her completely in my mind.

Sorry for the essay, I just had to get it all out in the open. Good job he doesn't use MN or I would be completely 'outed'

OP posts:
ISeeYouShiverWithAntici · 18/02/2014 14:38

I wouldnt touch him with a bargepole.
but if I was stupid enough to, I would have no right to complain about anything he did to me after I chose to take him back because it would be the consequence of my choice.

so id have to be bloody sure his personality transplant had taken.

AnyFuckerHQ · 18/02/2014 15:40

Hissy, just a bit of fun on another thread Smile

Hissy · 18/02/2014 15:55

AF: thought I'd missed a memo... Wink

Hissy · 18/02/2014 15:59

...erm CouldDo, why are you calling the women HE shagged skanks?

Were you married to this bloke? Did they KNOW you were "an item"

No. They were just 2 women that he slept with. he did.

Please don't blame THEM for HIS CHEATING on you.

Some women can put their partners infedelity behind them and move on. You clearly can't - which is by NO means any poor reflection on you (much the opposite)

So if you can't trust him, you don't have to. you can end this and go on with your life and meet someone decent and worth it.

CouldDoWithABrew · 18/02/2014 16:21

Cheers Hissy

Skanks is just a way of releasing my pent-up anger. You are right. I don't have to put up with mis-trust and all this shit. I have my gorgeous son to think about and don't need scum messing with my mind.

I have strong feelings for this scum tho haha. But they aren't as strong as the feelings I have for my son and the feeling that I need to get to a happier place. Im gonna have to tell him I need space to clear my head, think about things and find myself. If he's worth his weight in man-dust he'll support that and not be a self-centred cock-master who only considers his own feelings in these situations. I feel like he's from another realm sometimes

OP posts:
Snoozybird · 18/02/2014 16:26

CouldDoWithABrew Tue 18-Feb-14 12:32:09 I've had so many wrong 'uns in my time I could write a flippin book!!

Maybe it's because you're so determined to ignore the red flags in your relationships (let alone actual shitty behaviour) that you don't free yourself up to meet someone decent?

There are some decent men out there, honest. Why saddle yourself with damaged goods?

CouldDoWithABrew · 18/02/2014 16:27

Where do you find these decent blokes haha? Where do they hide?? All the good ones are already shacked up! I'm gonna be elf on the shelf here haha

OP posts:
Snoozybird · 18/02/2014 16:39

I know it's easier said than done, I was in an EA relationship for 17 years. It was only once I'd sunk so low that I no longer cared what happened to me, that I left. Four years later and I am finally with someone who respects me in both their words and their actions.

The longer you stay, the more likely you'll emotionally keep throwing good money after bad trying to recoup your losses. All this man does is gift-wrap the shit he gives you. You're worth so much more!!

CouldDoWithABrew · 18/02/2014 16:43

Thank you Snoozy for sticking a much needed smile on my face! You lot have been brill and given me some clarity and perspective on a v. messy situation.

My confidence is shot to shit! Thanks to all the lovely blokes I've encountered over the years. Still it's my own fault for getting involved with these train wrecks. At least I know how I DEFINITELY DON'T want my son to turn out.

I think I need a holiday.... Grin

OP posts:
AnyFuckerHQ · 18/02/2014 17:49

It might be worth you accessing some individual counselling to find out why you keep choosing the arseholes, OP

CouldDoWithABrew · 18/02/2014 17:57

I can already answer that one. Cos I'm soft, naive and they see me coming with the flashing neon 'Mug' sign above my head.

I always try to see the best in people, always have done. Doesn't do me any favours tho

OP posts:
Bluestocking · 18/02/2014 18:02

So many flags, of the reddest red.
To pick just one, you say "He has completely f*ed his ex off now. I'm not proud but I 'snooped' thru his phone (trust issues or what?!? I never do that sort of thing normally). I could see she has text him recently. The last text he sent to her was 'I'm sorry, I don't think I can be friends with you anymore, you hurt me too much in the past etc' and I swear to god that was nothing to do with me, I never told him to do it and never implied that he should."
That text to his ex means "keep on texting me, I like it, and there might be a bit of cock for you in it at some stage when I feel like it". If he really didn't want to be in touch with her, he'd have ignored her text.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page