Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL's Wedding

148 replies

FerretsRfun · 11/01/2014 15:42

Firstly some background i'm 28+2 with my first, arraigning my own wedding, arraigning all the details for our first mortgage, PIL's offered a loan to cover the deposit for this year, out of work currently with work guaranteed for July and while me and DP are surviving on his wages alone once i am back at work i will not be earning that much more than maternity allowance so would much prefer a few small family treats eg being able to have a take away or being able to buy a few new things for baby rather than all second hand rather than saving for this "holiday" (also will be paying back loan to PIL's as well)
To top it all of me and DP have thankfully very similar ideas of what we like in holidays which is a caravan in the New Forest taking the dogs with us :)

Just to compare our "wedding" will consist of me and DP signing a wedding certificate just before we register Baby's birth as it saves 2 trips and possibly a small party at my Uncles property (he hosts wedding's lots). several months later our honeymoon including baby's travel is very generously being paid for by PIL's a 3 day cruise to France/Germany

SIL announced yesterday that she wanted her wedding in either the Canaries, America or a Private island which they would hire for 2 weeks at a cost of around 100k and splitting the cost between the wedding party as "you would all be staying on the island with us"
She also said that as she was giving family a year or two's notice that we all had no excuse not to come and pay 3k or more for the privilege, she hasn't decided on summer 2015/16 yet

Now are me and DP BU in saying no way will we be able to afford it already?
We mentioned it to her yesterday and she basically told us if DP loved her we would save the money somehow and that we were expected to be there under any circumstances
to top it all off PIL'S said we should easily be able to manage to save the money, they have been very generous but do not seem to realize our financial situation

Our arguments are that :-
We will have a child under the age of 2 for possibly a flight of several hours or more, we may even have another baby by that stage
Kennel costs of someone watching our animals for 2 weeks

A mortgage and other debts to pay
And to top it all if we did somehow due to lottery or death of family member leaving us money manage to save that amount of money we have talked for years about saving for a caravan or being able to get those odd bits we have always wanted but never been able to afford before eg replace our awful falling apart death trap lovely car, being able to go out for a drink without saving for 2 months first

Are we BU saying that even if we can magically save the money that we will unfortunately not be attending if the wedding is overseas, i mean can they really expect all their friends and family to pay that much?

P.S after a quick read through i just want to state we are in no way jealous of their disposable income we just have very different ideas of what will make our wedding day special and hope they have a lovely time x

OP posts:
Liara · 11/01/2014 20:53

YANBU. I had similar with my brother, who is getting married in his fiance's home town, which just happens to be a 17hr+ flight and a 450 mile drive away from where I live.

Tickets would have cost 3k. When I told him we couldn't pay them, at least he had the grace to offer to pay for them. We still said no, as if we are going to take the amount of time off work that going would imply, there are less exhausting things we would rather do with our time.

He is pretty upset though, I don't think he will forgive me in a hurry.

I don't get why anyone thinks they have a right to expect others to put themselves out to attend a wedding.

lastnightIwenttoManderley · 11/01/2014 21:09

Wow. Since when did it become customary for your guests to fork out a small fortune to attend your wedding? How self important! Reminds me of that couple from Don't tell the bride who were married for six months.

We got married half an hour from where family live. We stayed in a hotel and wanted bridal party and family to stay too. So we paid for them. If not we'd have fully expected them to say 'sorry, but £100 for a hotel vs £20 for a taxi, we"ll be sleeping at home thanks.

For someone else to even dare to comment on how you should spend your money in this way is appallingly rude.

Stand your ground. 'No' is the answer!

cjel · 11/01/2014 21:15

Tell them you won't go then Just stay quiet and wait for all the others to drop out, either cost will go up and up as they do or she will cancel. Just sit back and watch.

mameulah · 11/01/2014 21:22

YANBU

She sounds awful.

FerretsRfun · 12/01/2014 09:00

No they arn't high earners or lotto winner's or anything they earn a bit more than us but not by very much.
Her DP is older and when he separated from his first P he had loads to put towards their new mortgage so that will have saved them lot's

Trust me when i say it's deff going to happen, the main family will all be very happy to go as to them that is exactly the type of holiday they all love and regularly take (not counting hiring the island) and seeing SIL married at the same time will be a bonus to them, no other small DC's in the family

PIL's while lovely and helpful are very . . . since it's so long since they had young DC's they seem to have forgotten the costs, FIL brought us a tin of formula milk as a "just in case" as I'm intending to BF but handy to have none the less and said it was bloody expensive LOL

yep for cute small things baby's can cost a lot Grin

Don't worry as it gets closer i will keep everyone updated as a good source of laughs x

OP posts:
Inertia · 12/01/2014 09:11

If demonstrations of sibling affection are so important to your SIL she can pay for you to go.

We couldn't attend my brother's wedding abroad - I wasn't allowed the time off work and we didn't have the money. He responded like a grown up and accepted that that's what happens when you get married abroad.

FerretsRfun · 13/01/2014 12:31

Just to update as im wetting my self laughing

SIL has posted it on FB that its booked for mid 2015 and that its 1.5k pp for 2 weeks not including travel costs and that a year is plenty of time to save and to top it all when asked if she would be having a little do back home for people who cant afford to go and i quote "always wanted to get married somewhere hot not really interested in a big day, just special and different"

Her family is already posting that its reasonable . . . wtf

so for me DP and DC 4.5K and add kennel costs and travel costs . . .
Nope we will not be going :)

OP posts:
ExitPursuedByABear · 13/01/2014 12:42

Your none attendance will of course put up the costs for everyone else.

Shame on you Wink

skinoncustard · 13/01/2014 12:43

I wouldn't get upset about it, I can guarantee it won't happen ! At least not with guests in attendance. She will hopefully come back down to earth soon.

Kundry · 13/01/2014 12:46

Well if she's not interested in the big day, she won't mind you not coming.

I'd be classed as a high earner and no way would I spend £4.5K and use up 2 weeks of my precious annual leave to go to someone else's wedding. Thinking about it, I didn't spend £4.5K on my own wedding!

Please, please, please keep us updated.

Finola1step · 13/01/2014 12:48

Wow. So with travel, kennel costs, clothes, passports etc, your probably looking at the 8-9K mark? Wow, wow, wow!

EssentialCoffee · 13/01/2014 12:51

This sounds awful! I got married abroad as it was so much cheaper than getting married in the UK and we took it as a bonus if the people we invited could make it. As it was we paid for DM, Dsis and DBro and DBro paid us back when he had the money, as they couldn't afford it. That's what families do IMO.

OTheHugeManatee · 13/01/2014 12:53

I think elaborate overseas weddings are fucking inconsiderate.

People's annual leave and holiday budgets are generally limited; by choosing an overseas wedding you're effectively forcing everyone you know to take their big annual holiday in a destination they have no choice over.

ceebie · 13/01/2014 12:53

I love that she thinks that everyone would just love to work very very hard for a few years to save up enough to go to her wedding. After all, what else could people possibly want to spend their hard-earned cash on? I'm sure they aren't particularly bothered about spending money on their houses, family holidays, etc. I'm sure if I knew her, I would be happy to stop buying clothes for my children for a few years, cancel the family (UK-based) holiday, leave my child in a cot rather than buying him a bed and postponing plans for a new back door that doesn't jam in winter and all the other maintenance work needed on the house, to make sure I could save enough to go! After all, it's her special day.

FryOneFatManic · 13/01/2014 12:57

If she's talking how it's £1500 pp, plus travel, etc, then to make the £100,000 costs she's going to need plenty of guests. Suspect that plenty will drop out when they realise the total cost involved.

Kundry · 13/01/2014 12:57

So you need to save £500 a month Shock And if you could do that obviously the best thing to do would be to spend it on a holiday you don't want to go on, not a deposit on a house, paying off a mortgage, getting a new kitchen or any of the gazillion things we all need money for.

I just can't imagine being so confident deluded that I'd believe my friends and extended family would think I was their number priority.

NynaevesSister · 13/01/2014 13:28

I would tell them both that saving £500 a month to do this is just not possible. But say it in as lovely a way as possible and post it publicly on FB :D

NynaevesSister · 13/01/2014 13:29

Then see how she can spin that into guys being so mean to not go!

StraightLineOfResignation · 13/01/2014 13:34

yanbu,

I would have thought foreign holidays are more for intimate weddings x

NicknameIncomplete · 13/01/2014 13:34

Aww bless.

She really is deluded isnt she.

CuttingOutTheCrap · 13/01/2014 13:39

Oh, I'd be tempted to make a very concerned query as to whether she's ok financially, seeing as she's asking her guests to pay for her wedding, in addition to paying for their own travel...

As a pp said, she's going to need a lot of guests to pay for the wedding she has in mind, I suspect she'll be having a re-think before too long, hope she hasn't paid too much in a non-refundable deposit!

2014newme · 13/01/2014 13:42

Clearly this private island fantasy is not going to happen, tell her now you won't be going then sit back and watch the drama unfold as all the other guests drop out over the next 2 years

onetiredmummy · 13/01/2014 13:47

So what exactly do you get for your £1500 per person?

Accommodation? What else?

How long does £1.5k buy you on the magic speshul island, are you expected to stay a week or just a couple of days?

PumpkinPositive · 13/01/2014 13:47

We mentioned it to her yesterday and she basically told us if DP loved her we would save the money somehow and that we were expected to be there under any circumstances

Who/where are all these nutters? I swear I don't know anyone in RL quite as bad as the people I read about on MN. Confused

Get your husband to tell her he doesn't love her. Problem solved.

maras2 · 13/01/2014 13:48

After these bank breaking nuptials I give it 6 months.

Swipe left for the next trending thread