OP - I will acknowledge first off that I am slightly emotionally invested in this. That said though, yes - I do think YABVFU.
Smoking is an addiction that owns you to your very soul. My Mumma died of lung cancer in February, and yep, she carried on smoking even after terminal diagnoses and whilst in hospital. She didn't give a flying fuck if she was in her nightgown, all she wanted was for me to flirt outrageously to acquire these get a wheelchair from the Porter's office and take her outside. So she could smoke. And chat. And feel like HER 'normal' self. Did I hate it? YES. Could I 'judge' it? NO. Not least as I too am a bastard smoker and hooked on the evil things.
Most hospitals have MANY entrances and exits - am pretty sure most people could find a way in without the wretched smokers (who cannot move that far) being in their way. Have done that myself with my DS's lots of times. So yep, I DO think YABU...
But NOT as beyond nuts and unreasonable as THIS one:
Hamwidge Wed 22-May-13 17:27:06
It's the alcoholics necking tenants super or straight vodka before going in that bother me.
As a smoker who has spent many months in hospital with dd I've seen it all, from people dragging drips outside to women in labour smoking between contractions!!
After few months of hospital monotony you can't be arsed judging people anymore.
Ham - HThe FUCK can you write "....that bother ME. And THEN write "after X/Y/Z... you can't be arsed judging people anymore ..."
Can you GENUINELY not see the oxymoronic size of Grand Canyon 'gap' between first sentance and third? 


Here - please take your well-earned JudgeyPants of the day award