Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU in thinking the attitude of some MNers towards the grandparents is dreadful?

82 replies

janey68 · 27/08/2012 12:15

There's a thread at the moment from a mum who handed her child over to granny to be looked after for the day while she went to a wedding, and then the mum was horrified that granny had given the (faddy) child a weightwatchers petit filous when he wouldn't eat yoghurt.

Another thread is from a woman who wants PIL around on Christmas day to be with the grandkids, but doesn't want to put them up overnight so is planning to stick them in a hotel (even though her DH disagrees and she hasn't even asked the PIL yet!)

And there are regularly threads from parents who are happy to use the grandparents as unpaid childcarers so they themsleves can earn, but then complain that their child watched a bit of telly/ate a couple of sweets/slept for 10 minutes too long.

I feel that some (not all) people have a really selfish attitude. If the gps are still relatively young and active, then surely this is their time, having raised their own family, to have the freedom to travel when they want, see friends, not be restricted by being an unpaid childminder, and yes godammit, even spend christmas in their own home if they want! And if the gps are elderly and frail, then surely it goes without saying you shouldn't be expecting them to run round after toddlers and have all the worry and responsibility? (Though there have also been threads about gps in their 70s who are still being expected to revolve their lives around their adult children....)

I expect many of us on here will become gp's within the next 20 years. I am sure we won't feel any different inside. We will still have our own lives and want to make our own decisions. I'm sure I'll love any future grandchildren to bits, and enjoy spending time with them, offering babysitting now and again etc. But I hope my adult children would respect the fact that DH and me are still people and not there to simply service the needs of others.

(And before anyone jumps in saying well I cant afford to work unless granny minds the kids for nothing, we certainly weren't at all well off when our kids were small, every month was a struggle and all my income went on childcare, but I still wouldn't have expected anyone else to care for them for free. Our children, our responsibility)

OP posts:
thegreylady · 27/08/2012 17:30

I love looking after my dgc and regard it as a privilege.I may be a little free with the jelly babies at times but my dd and I have agreed a set amount of treats which works.
The first time she complains in the carping way I sometimes see on here will be the end of regular childcare from me.

HermioneE · 27/08/2012 17:31

I still wouldn't have expected anyone else to care for them for free. Our children, our responsibility
I didn't realise there was one blueprint for a 'normal loving family' .......

OP that's exactly the problem, from your posts it does appear that you expect everyone to fit your blueprint of GPs' involvement, and if they don't then their attitude towards GPs/childcare is wrong.

Every post you've made about GPs helping with childcare is completely negative and you say that it means the parents think the GPs' lives revolve around them. Not everyone wants to do things the same way your family did. Hence YAstillBU.

valiumredhead · 27/08/2012 17:31

YANBU it's very noticeable on MN. Worth remembering that one day we might be MILs/grandparents!

RedBlanket · 27/08/2012 17:41

posters pulling the 'I'm livid MIL gave pfb one jelly baby Whilst minding all day for free' generally get a good pasting on here.
Both sets of gps provide lots of childcare for me, and don't always do things the way I would like, but so long as they're not letting them juggle knives, I don't complain.

Viperidae · 27/08/2012 18:01

We never had any childcare from either set of GPs and really struggled when DCs were young so I am often shocked at posts complaining about something that gives those that have it a real advantage. I think these people should either accept the help gratefully or make other arrangements.

brdgrl · 27/08/2012 18:01

I agree with you birds.People here stay close to each other and look after their old and young because they want to and love each other its not some awful burden.

Sigh. The problem is that some of the posters here (birds included but not alone I'm afraid) seem to be assuming the opposite to be true as well - that families who view their relationships as being ones of 'respectful boundaries' don't do it out of love and devotion.

Socknickingpixie · 27/08/2012 18:31

is it possible that we could just say different familes have different thoughts regarding dc's/time with external family/childcare without it becoming about how much you love them.

families from certain backgrounds tend to be far me activly involved with each other than families from different types of backgrounds.im sure that neither is right or wrong its not a love issue its just a difference.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread