Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

... to think we, the grown-ups, should have the attic room and our two year old daughter should not!

62 replies

Carrie1983 · 13/08/2012 11:57

My husband. Arghhhhh!

We have just moved from a beautiful house, which we extended and renovated, to the point we were able to sell it for more than other same-size homes on the cul-de-sac were valued at/selling for. We hadn't quite got to market, someone came to look round, saw it, put an offer in there and then. That was the first week of April. We moved into an unloved house that needs much work, 3 weeks ago. It needed electrical work before we could move in, so we stayed with my mum. It is about the same size as the old house, but has a massive garden (which is why we moved - we have a child now), and whereas our last house was divided into three doubles and a box room/fitted office, this one is three big doubles including a huge attic room. In the last house we had a family bathroom and en-suite shower room; in this house, it's a 'family' bathroom with shower over the bath, and the bath is under the window, so you shower between two shower curtains! Obviously we are going to renovate the place and everything will change, but the size of that bathroom cannot be changed without eating into the third bedroom's size, and we don't want to do that. Our office area will be at the end of the landing as that's a big enough area.

So anyway, when we looked round the house, we thought it would be nice for our two year old daughter to have the attic room, as we could imagine her bringing friends home and having sleep-overs, then as she gets older having her own space to get away from us. However, when we moved in, it really became apparent (to me) that a) we needed to find a way to fit in an en-suite somewhere; b) the en-suite would only really work in the attic room; c) we, as the grown-ups, should have the attic room as our daughter's playroom (until a 2nd child maybe comes along) will be the third bedroom which is next door to the 2nd bedroom and the family bathroom.

We do have a downstairs loo.

There are several factors: we both feel we want a shower cubicle, and I have actually slipped many times climbing out of a shower bath (we considered an omnitub); we need a bath for our daughter, and we both enjoy a bath from time to time; we can't fit both in the bathroom; our daughter is 2 and if we are all on the same floor and have the attic as spare/playroom, we will disturb her sleep when we get up for the loo/shower late or early. His only surrender, is to say she can have an en-suite shower room in her attic room, but that we are not having that room ourselves.

Now, I have tried explaining a number of issues to my husband, that influence this, and I'm hoping some other parents might see my point. Having been a nanny (now a teacher), for many years before having my own child, I have encountered a fair few toileting issues/ logistical issues, and want to avoid them now while we have a chance to get the layout sorted. So:

  1. Imagine our daughter has the attic room, she wakes up at 2am desperate for a wee, she has to walk across her room, down a flight of stairs and along a long landing, before getting to a loo. I see accidents;
  2. I often have my shower after she goes to bed/before she gets up - what's the point having a shower cubicle I can't use, as I will end up needing to shower over the bath if the shower cubicle is in her room;
  3. If she has the 3rd room and we have the 2nd room, we will disturb her;
  4. If we have the attic room with no en-suite, it will be a pain in the wobbly backside to have to trundle down the stairs every time I need a pee (when I was growing up, we had a downstairs bathroom and loo, and I used to lie in bed to the point of tears of discomfort because I didn't want to get up in the cold/dark to go!).

I have lost my train of thought really, but am I being unreasonable to expect that we have the attic room and add an en-suite so that a shower cubicle and a third floor loo can be achieved? The 2nd room is not much smaller than the attic room (we are talking a couple of feet either way), and it is next door to the third room which will be the spare room/playroom, and the family bathroom so that she has close access to a loo.

My husband's concers: she will be stolen by a burglar and we won't know; when she is 15 and rebels, she will escape and we won't know; it is quieter up in the attic away from the downstairs noise, so nicer for her; it's like a big den for her.

I'm thinking that, as a growing girl, I'd rather have had my own bathroom and playroom next door to my bedroom, than my own stairs and an attic bedroom and having to run down a flight of stairs to the loo!!

OP posts:
MadgeHarvey · 13/08/2012 16:06

Sorry - my brains started seeping from the back of my head before I got halfway through your marathon post but I'm sure I wish you well to sort out your problem. If it is indeed a problem. Hard to say.

SoupDragon · 13/08/2012 16:20

So you came on the thread just to insult the OP? Hmm

LeeCoakley · 13/08/2012 16:23

She won't play up in the attic for years, preferring to be under your feet. You might as well make the living room the playroom Wink If you had another baby tomorrow, realistically you wouldn't want them both playing two floors above you for a few years yet. Best for me would be to just use the 1st floor bedrooms between you until another child comes along, or until your dd decides she needs to get away from you and demands the attic. Your dd will get used to bathroom noise.

We've lived in a 5-bed house for 14 years and every once in a while rooms change from study/bedroom/playroom/junk room and back again!

MadgeHarvey · 13/08/2012 16:37

Oh terribly sorry soupdragon I must have missed the bit where you were appointed 'in charge' of individual opinions. Pffffft.

Bobyan · 13/08/2012 16:50

We live in a three storey house and after carrying out building work the building control officer told us to have the loft and put the kids on the second floor. Then if there is a fire you can collect the kids on your way out of the building, instead of having to collect them from further away from the exit.

olympicbelle · 13/08/2012 16:51

1st world problem.

Carrie1983 · 13/08/2012 16:54

That's a good point Bobyan. LeeCoakley - you have a point! :-P

As for it being a 1st world problem: well, it's not a problem; it's an 'AIBU?' and as I live in this supposed first world, I suppose it might be apt that it would be these kinds of problems that trouble my obviously very small mind. Now, where to house the servants, that's the bigger issue.

OP posts:
uselfullife · 13/08/2012 18:06

I'm a bit lost, but will give you my experience

we converted the loft into our bedroom and ensuite walk in shower room

DS on floor below
when he was little, we had baby monitor and would hear him no problem, gate on his bedroom door

Now he mostly comes and wakes us, doesn't go downstairs by himself

Now he is 5, he isn't disturbed by DH getting up early and showering
When I was working I could get ready upstairs without disturbing him

When at home I usually use the middle floor bathroom to get ready, closer to him when he is downstairs playing

WRT fire, just make sure all smoke alarms are working
fire could break out anytime, when you are on different floors

I think if you put her playroom in the loft, you are generally further away from her when she will be playing, depends if you can trust her to play alone

you can change the set up at any time, you don't have to plan as far forward as her teenage years

When we were kids, we regularly swapped bedrooms

ZonkedOut · 13/08/2012 18:58

I wouldn't want a small child in the attic room - you'll be 2 floors below from when she goes to bed til you do. If she wakes up early, that's 2 flights of stairs up to settle her, then 2 down again. It might have range issues for a monitor too. Plus, it would take longer to get to her/get her out in an emergency.

I would have you and DD on the first floor to start with (you'd probably do that anyway) and convert the attic room to have a shower ensuite. When it's ready, either you move there or keep it as a guest room (you can still use the shower unless you have guests). Then reassess as time goes on.

lovebunny · 13/08/2012 19:05

please don't put your two year old in an attic room.
there have been too many cases of house fires where the children have died because they've been on the 'extra' floor away from the parents.
keep your baby near you.

Glittertwins · 13/08/2012 19:36

Where are these examples? Nobody need urban myths/scaremongering etc!

scummymummy · 13/08/2012 20:12

My house has an odd layout with one bedroom per floor. Currently my newly turned 3 year old is on the top floor, older kids share the slightly bigger bedroom on the 1st floor and we are on the ground floor. I would much prefer to be on the same floor as the toddler, for purely logistical reasons rather than safety fears. It's a pita having to trek up 2 flights of stairs if she wakes up at night and I usually really regret it if I am foolish enough to say "If you do that again you will go to your room!" as getting a writhing, tantrumming toddler to the top floor is not that easy. The stairs are quite steep too. She has quite a sweet little room but rarely plays in it really, except first thing in the morning, because it just feels too far away.

We don't have much choice in the matter and it's certainly not the end of the world but given the choice I would definitely go for having her on the same floor. I do agree with your dh that an attic bedroom would be great for a teen tho- my teenagers would love love love a big garret bedroom with an ensuite! But I would do what suits you now and reconfigure as necessary as she grows up and your family needs change.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page