Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think friend's should help out with childcare, not be the childcare themselves.

83 replies

pingu2209 · 16/12/2011 13:11

My friendship network all help each other out here and there. From borrowing clothes, kitchen items to giving lifts and looking after children if the mum/dad can't get back from work in time to pick up etc. I am sure this is all very normal stuff all around the country.

I believe I am particularly helpful as I look after one friend's children every morning, so I don't think I can be accused of being a 'taker' of favours and not a 'giver'.

I am unsure how to handle a situation with a different friend. She started a job in September working 1 day a week, although sometimes 2. The hours she works mean she can drop her children off, but not pick them up from school.

However, my friend has not set up any formal after school club childcare and every week, about Wednesday, asks whether any of our network could pick up her children and look after them till 5.30.

A couple of us have commented (amongst ourselves, which I realise is not very nice) that we are feeling more than a little taken advantage of. We all work, and we all work far more hours than our friend does each week, but we have all set up formal childcare for our children.

Clearly friendship is give and take, and it is important to help our friends out, but in my view, that is normally when the usual childcare has broken down, it is not to be the actual sole childcare.

I was asked this week to pick up and look after my friend's children. I said yes but something came up during the day that meant I couldn't do it. As my friend (call her A) was already in work, I asked a mutual friend (call her B) if she could take the children home with her instead. B said yes and together we texted A to let her know.

However, an hour before school pick up, B phoned me to say that something had come up with her too. I phoned and texted A to try to get through but the phone went to answer phone. Eventually I phoned A's work and explained that due to unforseen circumstances neither B nor I could pick up her children.

A burst into tears and said that it would cause her a lot of trouble at her work. I said I was sorry but it wasn't B or my fault that something had come up and that this is what all working parents deal with every now and again.

She is a single mum but because she works less than 20 hours a week, she doesn't get any government help towards childcare costs. Therefore, she doesn't want the majority of her money going towards childcare. She earns about £42 net a day, childcare after school would cost £30.

It isn't just me getting fed up and to be frank A's tears just pissed me off as I felt she was using emotional blackmail. However, my personal circumstances had changed that day (to do with my eldest child and something that had to be dealt with).

Am I being unreasonable and mean to take this attitude?

OP posts:
zipzap · 16/12/2011 17:28

Another line if you get caught and are ales about a specific date...

'ooh. That date does ring a bell for something but I can't remember what off the top of my head. Best to count me out.'

Clarajinglebumps · 16/12/2011 17:32

Jeez! Thats taking the mick! She's living off a substantial inheritance and you are expected to pick up the childcare?? If she likes being a homebody then she should stay at home and suffer a little financially. Its a huge imposition on you .

I totally understand that its hard to say no to friends especially when they do the "guilt-face" but just tell her with working almost ft and looking after two other kids in the morning, its too much!
And leave it at that..just say I can't do everything!

I commend you for helping your other friend by taking the kids to breakfast club.Wine

Clarajinglebumps · 16/12/2011 17:33

ooh! zipzap- I'm stealing that!!

ChristinedePizaTinsel · 16/12/2011 17:34

R&T - if she's living off a big inheritance, she won't be eligible for help with childcare. Really it sounds like she's a bit tight tbh!

CalamityKate · 16/12/2011 17:51

If she says "What are you up to on X date?" just laugh gaily and say "Ooh blimey I haven't even thought that far ahead yet! No idea what I'll be doing!"

That's what I do.

natation · 16/12/2011 18:03

And do the children have a father living? If they do, well they are 50% from him, so he should be dealing with the child care for them.

pingu2209 · 16/12/2011 18:36

Their father will only look after them on a Sunday - and never ever over night. He does the bear minimum in terms of hours he looks after them.

OP posts:
Tangle · 16/12/2011 19:17

Has the legal situation changed? I'm not saying this is the best way of dealing with it (as may backfire with Friend X), but last time I looked it was an offence of some description to care for someone else's children in your own home more than "occasionally" unless you were close family. It was aimed at protecting genuine CMs. Intuitively a reciprocal arrangement between friends wouldn't fall foul - but wasn't there that case of two women police officers who arranged their part time jobs so that they could share child care, and both were had up for it?

I'm wondering if maybe your DH was chatting with a colleague about how supportive you were being and the colleague mentioned a friend of his who'd just been cautioned for this very thing... You're sure Friend A wouldn't want to put you in that situation so unfortunately you're going to have to decline any further child care for her for the foreseeable future and then will only be available for genuine emergencies.

If you can get something in place that means you get some childcare in the holidays in return for after-school favours that might be better. But if you've just had enough and don't WANT 2 extra kids on a regular basis that could be one way out.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread