Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not agree to ban MIL- long

77 replies

LuckyRocketshipUnderpants · 10/11/2011 14:14

I?m afraid this is one of those ?parents vs MIL visiting post baby's arrival ? messes and I?m sorry it?s sooo long but there is some history which I really need to give to avoid drip feeding.

I?m expecting DC2 at Christmas. It?s my DH?s first child. I have also DD age 4 from a previous relationship.

DH's widowed mother lives about 45 minutes away. It's her first DGC, as DH is an only child himself. We see her maybe once a month or, either at our home and hers, at times that mutually suit. We all get on well. She loves DD, she?s nice to me and she?s been extremely supportive of us in various ways, including when DH became very ill with depression.

My parents live overseas. When DD was born, they bought property within walking distance of us and started spending between 3-5 months here at a time. We also used to go over to see them at least once a year.

My mother and MIL had a big shouty falling out a couple years ago. Everyone else has tried to put it behind us & move on- but my mother has since held a serious grudge against MIL.

Matters finally came to a head when my mother demanded that MIL make herself scarce for the whole of one of their visits. We?re talking 4 months. And that included us not going to see MIL. She went spectacularly off the deep end when I tried to gently but firmly explain that this was quite unreasonable, for many reasons but not the least because DH was still on the mend from serious depressive llness. As a result of not getting their way that summer, my parents chose to stop coming over to visit for extended periods- and even decided to then put their property on the market (even knowing by then that I was pregnant with DC2.) My DD, who adores them, has been more than a little confused and saddened by their absence.

So, my parents made it clear to me that they had prior plans for Christmas- and so would not be here for DC2?s birth. No problem, we said, and since we haven?t been there in awhile, we made plans to fly over to see them with both the DCs in the spring- which is about as soon as we think we could reasonably manage it.

Then last week my mother said they would like to come to visit after the birth- but they want to be certain of their ?priority access? . In other words, in order to accommodate them, my mother says it is MY responsibility to ensure that MIL is "completely banned" for the duration of their stay (however long that may be). They think that MIL gets to see the DCs ?whenever she wants? all year long- and that their reward for time, effort and expense of their coming is that everyone else now gets out their road, as per their wishes.

I told her in no uncertain terms I was not prepared to ban MIL this way. I don?t even know if MIL would in fact want be around or not while my parents are here- but I know she?d be extremely angry if it were to be suggested to her she?s in any way barred.

I totally can see how my folks want to ensure they get ?their? time with the baby and DD. But while we would make every effort to be welcoming and facilitate that as much as possible, I also think the world should not necessarily revolve exclusively around them and that it?s out of order to expect they can dicate to us this way- especially when they are coming to OUR home.

My mother is now furious and upset. And I feel I really don't need any of this stress- and especially not after I've just given birth.

What do you think-AIBU?

OP posts:
LuckyRocketshipUnderpants · 10/11/2011 14:15

Oooh, and sorry about the punctuation looking weird (at least it does on this computer-I'm not sure why it's done that!)

OP posts:
andthisisme · 10/11/2011 14:18

I don't think YABU. Can you say what the argument was about?

Unless it was something really awful I think your DM is being rather childish.

KaraStarbuckThrace · 10/11/2011 14:20

YANBU. Your mother is, and needs to grow the fuck up and realise that it is not about her. She is being incredibly selfish.
You are a grown woman, she cannot ban you from seeing anyone, least of all her grandchildren's other grandmother! Unless the falling out was something to do with your MIL attempting to feed you child crack cocaine, then she needs to get over it.

Flisspaps · 10/11/2011 14:20

YANBU. Your mother is being an arse.

DamnBamboo · 10/11/2011 14:21

Your mother is VVVU.
What the hell happened?
Has she always been this entitled?

BaronessBomburst · 10/11/2011 14:21

Bloody hell! YANBU. Your mother is. Tell her to get a grip and grow up. Point out that you do not need to put up with this kind of behaviour, especially with a new baby, hormones etc, and that if she is going to add to your stress she can just stay away. MIL has every right to see her GC too.

Although that's probably easier said than done......

ChitChattingWithKids · 10/11/2011 14:21

YANBU!!!! Your mother is being daft and extremely self centred. Don't back down on this. It sounds as though your DMIL will be a wonderful support to you, but your (not so D)M is only looking out for herself.

duckdodgers · 10/11/2011 14:21

YANBU

"Priority Access"?? sounds like jumping the queue to get into a concert, not visiting your new grandchild!

Can you imagine if you allowed this to go ahead - your poor MIL would be extremely hurt, shes done nothing wrong.

Firawla · 10/11/2011 14:22

yanbu, your mum is being very unreasonable herself and also childish and controlling. how can she ban you from seeing anyone, let alone your own mil who is family! how would she feel if your dh banned her!!! ridiculous. dont give in to it

JessieLeGrund · 10/11/2011 14:22

Yes, we need the full facts before we can judge advise Smile

Catsdontcare · 10/11/2011 14:25

Wow your mum is being unbelievable here! I would not accommodate this behaviour from her. If her love is that conditional I would tell her not to come at all.

ChocolateBiscuitCake · 10/11/2011 14:27

Agree with all the previous posts. Your mother is being ridiculous and extremely childish. However, it does sort of depend on the nature of their falling out? If your MIL was in the wrong I can see why your mother might be so demanding (not that it is the right way to behave). However, this should not be about her - it should be about the GC and supporting her daughter who has just had a baby. Can you talk to your father?

Onemorning · 10/11/2011 14:28

YANBU at all.

wannaBe · 10/11/2011 14:30

I would tell your mother to grow the fuck up.

JingleAllTheSoddingWay · 10/11/2011 14:31

Wow. YANBU.

What did your MIL do to piss off your DM who sounds positively lovely by the way so much?

Doyouthinktheysaurus · 10/11/2011 14:31

YANBU in the slightest.

Your mum is behaving appallingly.

PrimaBallerina · 10/11/2011 14:33

YADNBU but yes, spill the beans on the row for us please! Grin

saintlyjimjams · 10/11/2011 14:33

Your mother sounds jealous.

Well done for standing up to her (not easy I know).

JenaiMarrHePlaysGuitar · 10/11/2011 14:38

Good grief.

What on earth happened?

ChippingInNeedsSleep · 10/11/2011 14:38

YANBU

Your mother is 'furious and upset' - shame that. She only has herself to blame.

It is terrible that they are punishing your DD for all of this. They seriously need to grow up.

It sounds highly unlikely, but even if your MIL had done something terrible & hurt/upset your Mum, this would still be bang out of order. If that were the case I feel it would be acceeptable for your Mum to say she doesn't wish to see your MIL and to ask if she could phone before visiting (which it sounds like she does anyway) so that your Mum can leave your house before she arrives.

Do not do anything to upset your lovely MIL.

alana39 · 10/11/2011 14:40

YANBU at all. I thought my MIL was bad in this respect (also lives abroad, seems to be jealous of the time other grandparents get with grandchildren) but she is but an amateur compared to your mother.

eurochick · 10/11/2011 14:42

Give your mother a piece of paper with "Priority Pass" written on it. Tell her that if she comes round when MIL is there and waves it, you will make sure MIL stands behind her until she has spent time with the grandkids.

Maybe that will make her see how daft she is being.

(I also want to know what the row was about. It sounds like a humdinger.)

RubyLovesMayMay · 10/11/2011 14:44

No one would be telling me who I can or cannot have round to my OWN HOUSE Mother or not cause Im a stubborn bitch who will not be dictated to

You're giving birth so you decided who comes to see you and when.

Families always get out of hand when it comes to visiting newborns and it can really piss you off at the best of times.

You shouldn't have to be worrying about this

Their arguement had nothing to do with you and she shouldn't be bringing you into it.

Well done for standing your ground.

Good luck with the birth and try to relax.

schobe · 10/11/2011 14:45

YAdefNBU but we do need details of barney.

pollyblue · 10/11/2011 14:47

What on earth did they fall out about?! Must've been a right old ding-dong.

How does your MIL feel about your mum now? Would she be quite happy to give your parents a wide berth when they visit?

Though to be fair, I'm with the majority, regardless of their fight the important thing is you get on with your MIL and want to see her. It's perfectly possible for your mum to visit and not see your MIL, but she can't insist that you don't see MIL at all while they are in the country. Surely if MIL wants to visit you, your mum can go out for a while?