Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that Facebook is for the vacuous and banal

157 replies

FunnysInTheGarden · 22/09/2011 22:25

On the whole?

I mean it's worse than I thought. Am a recent convert, but the shit some folk post about their lives. I mean REALLY who is interested?

Pages and pages of my 'friends' most detailed stream of boring consciousness.

Mebeez I need to log off!

OP posts:
BupcakesandCunting · 24/09/2011 20:09

Facebook has been great for me for many reasons but it's been most helpful in helping me discover which people on my FL are closet racists/homophobes/mental-health-ists.

DELETED.

StrangewaysHereICome · 24/09/2011 20:32

I was an addict but deleted my account today. I didn't find it too bad and a nice way to keep in touch with people (I kept my friends list to around 50 and didn't use any apps or 'likes). But a number of things made me give it up. Firstly the security aspect worries me as secret squirrel pointed out the new changes mean you don't know who is reading your posts. Also I seemed to waste rather a lot of time on there so I am now feeling quite liberated (although I seem to have wandered on here Confused). I also discovered that people who I thought were good friends and who I would go out of my way to speak to didn't feel the the same about me - so sod them!!

mumblecrumble · 24/09/2011 20:35

What really is the difference between posting shite on facebook and talking about it on here?

UsingPredominantlyTeaspoons · 24/09/2011 21:19

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

pointythings · 24/09/2011 22:41

FB - useful for co-ordinating DDs' social lives with other working mums, useful for staying in touch with archery club, enjoyable for playing one particularly addictive online game (which the DDs also enjoy as it's about finding objects in pictures).

Otherwise meh - I'd rather MN.

Butkin · 24/09/2011 22:44

Absolutely love FB and read it daily. However don't do any of the games etc and ban them from appearing on my Newsfeed.

I just post my news and photos (particularly of DD and the ponies) and love seeing the same from my many friends from around the world.

twotesttickles · 25/09/2011 00:27

So, to be clear, you are complaining about social networking, on a social networking site (which for the avoidance of doubt is how Mumsnet is being described in most media these days)? Confused

Weird.

My Facebook is very interesting thank you. And yes some people are vacuous, it's called small talk and makes up 80% of conversation between friends. But hey, I can screen out that stuff because the other 20% is really quite enlightening. I've found out about lots of things I would never have known about through Facebook.

And for the record it's not as good at Google plus but G+ lacks the core customer base to work properly yet.

mumblecrumble · 25/09/2011 08:54

Agree - My faebook is also very interesting. Perhaps its the people who are being vacuous rather than the social network. This morning I saw the photos of an old friend's new baby, heard back from 12 past students about their music careers so far in response to a survey I sent out to them yesterday, arranged a meeting with a musician who is a friend of a [real!] friend to come in and do a song writing workshop. I also messaged my Mum adn dad who are in Spain, and had a laugh about some commetns friends had made.

Now I'm sorry but facebook is great cos it alllows me to do those things. I am sick of the argument about facebook. 10 years ago I used to get prank phonecalls from students, chat to friends for ages about useless crap - never heard people saying that the telephone system was "vacuous and banal".

Hurrah for small talk, very well put twotesttickles.

smallwhitecat · 25/09/2011 11:58

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

funnyperson · 25/09/2011 12:01

An old schoolfriend sent this round our facebook group some months ago and we all had a virtual giggle over 4 continents
The 76-year-old woman walked down the hallway of Clearview Addictions Clinic, searching for the right department. She passed signs for the "Heroin Addiction Department (HAD)," the "Smoking Addiction Department (SAD)" and the "Bingo Addiction Department (BAD)." Then she spotted the department she was looking for: "Facebook Addiction Department (FAD)."
It was the busiest department in the clinic, with about three dozen people filling the waiting room, most of them staring blankly into their Blackberries and iPhones. A middle-aged man with unkempt hair was pacing the room, muttering,"I need to milk my cows. I need to milk my cows."
A twenty-something man was prone on the floor, his face buried in his hands, while a curly-haired woman comforted him.
"Don't worry. It'll be all right."
"I just don't understand it. I thought my update was LOL-worthy, but none of my friends even clicked the 'like' button."
"How long has it been?"
"Almost five minutes. That's like five months in the real world."
The 76-year-old woman waited until her name was called, then followed the receptionist into the office of Alfred Zulu, Facebook Addiction Counselor.
"Please have a seat, Edna," he said with a warm smile. "And tell me how it all started."
"Well, it's all my grandson's fault. He sent me an invitation to join Facebook. I had never heard of Facebook before, but I thought it was something for me, because I usually have my face in a book."
"How soon were you hooked?"
"Faster than you can say 'create a profile.' I found myself on Facebook at least eight times each day -- and more times at night. Sometimes I'd wake up in the middle of the night to check it, just in case there was an update from one of my new friends in India . My husband didn't like that. He said that friendship is a precious thing and should never be outsourced."
"What do you like most about Facebook?"
"It makes me feel like I have a life. In the real world, I have only five or six friends, but on Facebook, I have 674. I'm even friends with Juan Carlos Montoya."
"Who's he?"
"I don't know, but he's got 4,000 friends, so he must be famous."
"Facebook has helped you make some connections, I see."
"Oh yes. I've even connected with some of the gals from high school -- I still call them 'gals.' I hadn't heard from some of them in ages, so it was exciting to look at their profiles and figure out who's retired, who's still working, and who's had some work done. I love browsing their photos and reading their updates. I know where they've been on vacation, which movies they've watched, and whether they hang their toilet paper over or under. I've also been playing a game with some of them."
"Let me guess. Farmville?"
"No, Mafia Wars. I'm a Hitman. No one messes with Edna."
"Wouldn't you rather meet some of your friends in person?"
"No, not really. It's so much easier on Facebook. We don't need to gussy ourselves up. We don't need to take baths or wear perfume or use mouthwash. That's the best thing about Facebook -- you can't smell anyone. Everyone is attractive, because everyone has picked a good profile pic. One of the gals is using a profile pic that was taken, I'm pretty certain, during the Eisenhower Administration. "
"What pic are you using?"
"Well, I spent five hours searching for a profile pic, but couldn't find one I really liked. So I decided to visit the local beauty salon."
"To make yourself look prettier?"
"No, to take a pic of one of the young ladies there. That's what I'm using."
"Didn't your friends notice that you look different?"
"Some of them did, but I just told them I've been doing lots of yoga."
"When did you realize that your Facebooking might be a problem?"
"I realized it last Sunday night, when I was on Facebook and saw a message on my wall from my husband: 'I moved out of the house five days ago. Just thought you should know.'"
"What did you do?"
"What else? I unfriended him of course!"

NoobyNoob · 25/09/2011 12:47

I had a massive clearout, massive.

I'm now down to 17 people, friends and close family. I love it. I get to share pictures with family who live overseas of DS and scans of DD, I get to see comments and status updates of the people I want to see, not someone I met briefly with 20 years ago :)

piellabakewell · 25/09/2011 15:55

Can't bear it, won't use it.

My best friend had massive problems with someone setting up an account in her daughter's name, having chats with her school friends who had no idea it wasn't her...this person knew a lot about her. It wasn't until the police were involved that the account was shut down, and that was after the impostor had started posting links to porn sites on there.

Maggie1973 · 25/09/2011 15:58

I think it's good to keep in touch with friends that you don't see as much as you'd like to and it's also nice to catch up with old school/college friends. However, I'm sick of everyone in work talking about it. They see each other everyday in work and then talk to each other on Facebook every night. For God's sake, get a life!

vmcd28 · 25/09/2011 16:03

I've got a friend whose posts are like this:
Morning all!
[2 minutes later] Had a great sleep last night!
[4 mins later] Having a croissant for breakfast, mmmmmm!
[20 mins later] Nothing beats Sunday papers and coffee.
[20 mins later] Wow, that shower was so refreshing!
[10 mins later] Vote please - will we go to soft play or out for lunch?
[30 mins later] Thats settled then! Soft play it is!
[10 mins later] Anyone fancy meeting at soft play today?

And it goes on......and on...............and on..................

londontoyco · 25/09/2011 16:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by Mumsnet.

microfight · 25/09/2011 17:52

Deleted my account over the new changes and the fact I can see status updates of people I don't know because my friends have liked it! You can also see photos of peoples kids for the same reason even though their privacy settings are set to friends only.

Feel rather liberated

RebelFromTheWaistDown · 25/09/2011 18:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by Mumsnet.

ravenAK · 25/09/2011 18:23

Dh is the frontman of a fairly 'niche' sort of band - there's a thriving FB community exchanging information on gigs, DJs, album & single releases within the genre.

Fans post meet up or liftshare messages, reviews, photos, videos...

It's useful.

I just delete anyone with appalling opinions & hide anyone who posts every hour to update the world as to their children's genius or their painful verruca, etc.

Pandemoniaa · 25/09/2011 19:54

If it is love or hate then I'm much more for hating Facebook nowadays and if it wasn't for some genuinely nice friends (who I don't see regularly enough in real life) and one or two groups that I belong to which remain an excellent way of organising events (also in real life) then I'd de-activate.

I'm sure that Facebook wasn't actually invented as a Nest of Vipers. Let alone as a home for unacceptable and reactionary comments made by people too cowardly to face the sector of society they accuse. Worse, you then discover who "likes" this shit and this is more depressing than the original posting. Although the constant, unquestioning spreading of long-debunked urban myths is getting pretty fucking tiring too.

I suppose, as the saying goes, "all dogs have their day". So far as Facebook is concerned I suspect it is high time to have it humanely put down.

Mum2be79 · 25/09/2011 21:32

I've just read an article that says FB is going to allow you to see who 'defriended' you. I'm rather concerned at all the changes as it is becoming too complicated for me to follow and be 100% sure of my privacy.

Someone 'defriended' me over the past 2 days. I'm not sure who it was 9now 70 instead of 71 friends) but that says it all really - a friend is not a friend if you don't know they're missing. Whereas I am not bothered if someone has done that - I've done it before, not because of dislike but because I wasn't communicating with these people and I wanted better control over my home page - it has 'bothered' me in the sense of 'Who is it?'. It's happened before but it was a situation where I thought maybe I did it, not them as it coincided with a cull I was having. And just like to add that whilst typing this, I have realised who it is - a person who forewarned everyone he was doing it in response to the changes made recently.

It goes to show that when defriended it can lead to a whole host of 'issues' and questions and make people think someone is being malice but they're not.

I love being able to share 'mundane' things with people I don't see across the world and whose friendship is not that strong to talk on the phone but strong enough to 'keep in touch'. There is someone I know who lives in Australia (a parent of a child I taught 7 years ago) whose father died two days ago. I don't talk much to her, sometimes I leave 'mundane' comments but it was comforting to her to know that I cared enough to read her post and pass on my condolences. This is what I will miss about FB - and being able to search for my estranged DB and SIL and check profile pics of my little niece that they don't allow me to see (he cut ties with me when I announced my engagement for reasons unknown).

I really don't know what to do. I fear for my privacy yet fear losing touch with the 50+ people I don't get to see, keep in touch etc, etc because lets face it, when do we have the time? FB is easy because everyone is there at a click of the button and you can announce something special just the once and 70+ people all get to see it.

Decisions, decisions ...

FunnysInTheGarden · 25/09/2011 21:50

one of my Inlaws threads went a bit like this

"oh I must get that dress off corrie lol!!"
"which one hun, lol"
"the one with the feathers, lol!!!!!"
"lol,how about the internet hun, lol???!!!"
"oh maybe hun,lol, will look hun,lol"
"ok hun, lol"

Vacuous and banal shite. I have since hidden, on the advice of this thread

OP posts:
Angel786 · 25/09/2011 22:13

Ohh I want to know which threads were deleted by MN and also if you can tell who has defriended you as I cull people quite often Blush

LeBOF · 26/09/2011 00:41

I think Facebook is skating in thin ice by making so many changes. MySpace was thriving before they started messing with the format too much- it died within six months.

qo · 26/09/2011 08:28

I can't stand the whole culture that facebook has bred - that of sharing everything, and people just accepting this as normal now.

And it's a great way of keeping intouch with family that live in different parts of the world? so is email, having a phone conversation, writing a letter etc - you don't NEED facebook to keep in touch with people.

I deleted my account over a year ago now and have absolutely no regrets, and my real friends have made the effort to keep in touch via other means.

Meteorite · 26/09/2011 09:28

Very good point qo. My thoughts too!

"And it's a great way of keeping intouch with family that live in different parts of the world? so is email, having a phone conversation, writing a letter etc - you don't NEED facebook to keep in touch with people."