Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Giving money to family AIBU

83 replies

Aliensstolemychocolate · 20/06/2011 14:07

Potted history, my husband is one of a large family all the family are very 'pro family' when it comes to sharing. They were not well off growing up, but managed fine. My family were better off but certainly not rolling in it and my husband and I have worked very hard to get the jobs we have and earn the money we do.

Anyway, we have had an email today from our nephew (21) who lives in the USA with his mum and her husband (essentially my SIL/BIL). He has said he cannot pay his college fees and is having to work instead of study but really wants to go to school - the email is very emotional but says his stepdad wont pay (but still has money for other stuff) so could we help him out.

Now this is not a first by any means,my DH family have struggled financially and we have helped significantly for all of his siblings, and it was not long ago she was asking for money to leave him (our BIL) but that is another story.

DH is worried that he will be viewed as mean and spiteful if he doesn't give the money (that goes back to another story in the family about money) but thinks, like me that we should all take personal responsibility for ourselves/children.

So much so we have argued about this in the past and I am fearing another set of monumental arguments (including MIL phoning to say we need to help).

AIBU (and mean) not to want to help out (again)? I am starting to feel like giving into the pressure may be easier Angry

OP posts:
TheOriginalFAB · 21/06/2011 14:39

When did you last hear from him before his begging email?

Aliensstolemychildren · 21/06/2011 14:40

A few years back, maybe January 2009, could have been a bit later

elastamum · 21/06/2011 14:43

Good for your DH! Your DN needs to stand on his own two feet.

You have given the right message IMO. We have a university fund for grandchildren which my parents set up years ago. My DB recently vetoed giving money to HIS son and he said unless 'he gets off his lazy arse and also starts to earn some money of his own, we shouldnt be bailing him out'!! The message being we will help them, but we wont just pay their way for them. He has a point Hmm

SenoritaViva · 21/06/2011 14:48

He contacted you back in January...2009??????? WTF?????????

Unbelievable. Really, I am utterly shocked. Biscuit Shock Angry now need Brew to calm myself down.

The audacity and a whole lot more.

TheOriginalFAB · 21/06/2011 14:50

O
M
G.

Sewmuchtodo · 21/06/2011 15:18

Well done, what a horrible situation. Please let us know how the family respond.

StellaSays · 21/06/2011 15:31

Good job, I think the email you sent was very good. Please let us know what the family say.

vmcd28 · 21/06/2011 16:10

I'm confused - why would the family not speak to you if you say no, especially given the comment in the op that he "says his stepdad wont pay (but still has money for other stuff"?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread