Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Actually I'd rather be on benefits

235 replies

Spudulika · 09/06/2011 13:31

... than have to work 40 hours a week in a boring minimum wage job.

Not doing either myself thankfully (working DH, I have well-paid p/t job), but thoroughly resenting the line that the conservatives are taking that the reason many people have a terrible quality of life is because they're not working, and that they'll invariably have a better quality of life if they're not on benefits, because going to work somehow always makes your life better.

I suspect that the majority of mp's have never done these sorts of jobs, and have never had to live on the minimum wage, otherwise they wouldn't be saying this.

IMO what makes people's live shit is being educationally and culturally impoverished, poor housing and poor mental and physical health, none of which are likely to be alleviated by spending 40 hours doing repetitive manual labour.

If work doesn't leave you significantly better off financially, is in itself not interesting, and results in you becoming time poor, so you have fewer hours to read, stroll in the park, meet with friends or watch interesting films on TV (all of which activities are free and accessible to the unemployed), how on earth can you be said to be better off doing it?

And then there's the option of enriching your life by doing voluntary work while unemployed, or studying.

So - if you were an MP and I was an unemployed person, how would you persuade me that I would be much happier cleaning out buses for 40 hours a week, than sitting at home reading the newspaper and listening to the radio?

OP posts:
ilovedora27 · 11/06/2011 20:29

My husband and I do 70s hours between us in minimum wage jobs and i would ALWAYS rather work than be a benefit claimant tbh. I would have to be severely disabled or have disabled children (who deserve benefits) before I quit work, regardless of my low wage. I have self respect.

wotnochocs · 11/06/2011 21:12

haven't read all 10 pages but the point is that some poor bugger is cleaning buses and paying tax to support the idle fecker reading and listening to the radio

pumpernickel10 · 11/06/2011 21:55

Decided to come on her wot and spread your venom I see

ballstoit · 11/06/2011 22:02

xstitch, my lovely, you are possibly the furthest from a shit or morally repugnant than any of the posters I've come across. We were both wrong only in trusting the men who made promises they didn't keep. You will not give up, nor will I, and one day our DC will be very proud of us. For now, please know that you are a worthwhile person, with or without work.

Maypole - you are the exact opposite of all I've said to xstitch...why should my DC starve?? They have done nothing wrong. And nor have I. I'd be more ashamed to let pride prevent me from feeding my family. I sincerely hope you never have an illness which prevents you from working. Or have your partner pull the rug out from under your feet while your pregnant.

ZXEightyMum · 11/06/2011 22:04

Maypole said on the Poor Kids thread that when she had her first child at the age of sixteen, she worked and never claimed benefits.

She explained that she left her child with an elderly neighbour for whom she did cleaning and shopping in kind.

So she has never been in the position of paying out practically all her of earnings in childcare as most lone parents do and instead left a young child with a vulnerable person who was presumably unable to do her own shopping and cleaning.

Very admirable.

Fifis25StottieCakes · 11/06/2011 22:10

Nice...i could do that and leave my 3 dd's with my 86 year old granny. I dont think it would enrich her life though TBH

TheFrogs · 11/06/2011 22:57

Universal credit (is that what it's called?) Great idea. My mum works in LA and they will all be made redundant within two years. Fact. This helps how exactly?

BitOfFun · 11/06/2011 23:00

That makes sense, ZX. Fits the profile of exploitative selfish fuckwit I've come to expect from that type of poster.

maypole1 · 12/06/2011 00:11

Fiffis you would let the government take care of your kids.

Zxe yes I am sure you rather I was on benefits we know how you like keeping people on them

Fifis25StottieCakes · 12/06/2011 00:24

Fiffis you would let the government take care of your kids.

I assume you havent had any child benefit or tax credits. No i take care of my kids. I dont palm them off on some elderly neighbour.

As i asked before where would you like the unemployed to work. Would you be willing to job share.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread