Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why my older sis is so uninterested in our family

93 replies

sorrytosayivebeenthere · 18/05/2011 15:34

Hi I am no 3 of 4 children (all adults now) 49, 47, 42 and 38

My older sis is the eldest, then my bro, me and younger sis. Our parents split when I was 18 so 24 years ago, both remarried, Never really got to know my dads wife as he is a funny man not very interested in us anymore.

Both myself and my db are still in contact with him although it is limited, My sisters have no contact, Older one cos she can't be arsed to make the effort, He is very hard work and I think very old school and if we don't make the effort then he will hold a grudge.

Younger sis didn't speak to him for years and then when her dh died last year my dad called her but no contact since.( I lost contact for a few years whilst with my abusive ex but when my bro told my dad about it he called me and we have been in contact since)

A few years after my mum and dad split my mum met and married a wonderful man, they were sweethearts at school, met up by chance, and my younger sis and I went to school with his 3 sons, He has been more than a stepdad to us and has been the only real grandad that my kids have known.

sorry if i'm going on a bit but felt a bit of history would be needed.

Well if you were to ask all four of us about our childhood I know that 3 of us would say we had a good childhood, hardworking dad, very loving mum who worked pt, My dad wasn't a very physical person, I cannot remember ever having a cuddle when I was young or anything but he was there for us and provided what we needed, We respected and looked up to him cos he was our dad, I do remember a few rows between my parents in my teens but nothing really bad.

My older sis reckons we all had a crap childhood,

Well now back to the present, Me, 2 sisters ( kids) and mum and stepdad all live in same area, my bro lives a fair bit away and works really hard but still finds the time to visit when he can and phones my mum regularly,

Both myself and my younger sis are very close to my mum, My mum is very good with my niece and takes care of her before and after school as my younger sis has to work, My older sis couldn't give a shit about any of us to be honest, she never visits or phones or texts unless there is a birthday or very special event,

She lives 10 minutes away from us by car (she drives, we don't) but no bus route so for us to go to her would take prob 40 min walking, not that she has ever invited any of us to her flat in 4 years,

It is my stepdads birthday today and my mum has heard nothing from her, my ex bro in law (who we are still very close to him as she left him for someone else and he is the father of my niece's) has dropped a card in but she will not bother, she never has for my stepdad.

My mum cannot understand why she is the way she is towards family, she always has more than enough time for friends but family doesn't seem to matter.

My mum says that she prob thinks that if there is a problem then one of us will let her know but I cannot understand why she can go months at a time wothout speaking to us, just to see how things are going or to catch up on any gossip, to see my little niece whos is almost 6 and just a wonderfull little girl,

I do not get how that out of four of us one can be so uninterested and cold towards close family members, we all grew up together, my bro was only 2 years after her, why does she have such a different perspective on our childhood?

OP posts:
Bumfuzzle · 18/05/2011 21:06

have they refused to delete it or simply not replied yet?

sorrytosayivebeenthere · 18/05/2011 21:09

Ive had 3 replies from them, they won't delete it

OP posts:
pink4ever · 18/05/2011 21:09

Op-there are many types of abuse and you cant say with 100% certainty that your sister didnt suffer. Maybe she was more upset at your mum and dad splitting than you assume?. Maybe she genuinely doesnt like your stepdad and doesnt think he's as wonderful as you do?. Maybe she does have deep seated issues about being a surviving twin(btw I know 3 people who this happened too and it did effect them).
And maybe she is just thoughtless and selfish. But a cunt? really?.

Pagwatch · 18/05/2011 21:09

No one thinks your sister was abused.
You really are massively over reacting to everything.
People are just suggesting that you don't know what is going on with her so maybe cut her some slack.

Your behaviour is really odd. Why are you over reacting like this?

claretandcheese · 18/05/2011 21:10

Well I don't hate you.

Pagwatch · 18/05/2011 21:19

You can't get a thread deleted just because you don't like the replies.

And people are trying to respond helpfully in the main.

sorrytosayivebeenthere · 18/05/2011 21:20

if i deregister will my threads go?

Oh am im not odd and i don't think im overreacting,

She doesnt know my stepdad like me and my younger sis do cos she was married when my mum got with him, she has never made an effort to get to know him really,

We have lived with them as a couple, gone on holiday with them and had our kids grow up with him as a couple. he is grandad to mine and my younger sisters kids, my older sisters kids have always been told to call him by his first name, I could understand it more if they saw my dad regualrly but they dont because she wont have anything to do with him.

I am sorry

OP posts:
PaisleyLeaf · 18/05/2011 21:21

Did someone remind her that her stepdad's birthday was coming up?

Also, you probably don't know all that much about what's going on her life at the moment....how is she in herself etc? She may have her own stuff going on. Afterall you "lost contact for a few years whilst with my abusive ex". She's going through a time in her life where she's losing contact for whatever reasons.
And what's the ex BIL playing at? His golden-boy stuff might not be helping either.

frgaaah · 18/05/2011 21:25

OP, stop trying to make work for the admins at MN - just because you don't like the responses to a post doesn't mean to say they're going to go in and remove it for you.

Really, grow up.

This is an adult discussion board, and I rather think that the relies on here have been quite muted compared to the negative qualities you appear to be sporting here.

If you don't want to continue to read the thread, bugger off back to la la land where some "yes" men will agree that you're/your mum is being treated horribly, and oh my isn't your sister the bad one, with your fingers in your ears to anything else being posted.

Pagwatch · 18/05/2011 21:26

Well, she presumeably see it differently.
Why does that bother you so much that you are racing around calling her a cunt and trying to get the thread deleted. That is what I mean by over reacting.
Do you think this is a rational response to your sister being distant?

PaisleyLeaf · 18/05/2011 21:32

"she was the first born, spoilt as shit"
I expect my younger sister would say that about me too.
Funny how differently things can be interpreted within the same family. But then my sister's 5 years younger - there's no way I'd've ever opened up to her growing up.
I expect with your attitude your sister will feel there's no point trying to build a relationship.

sorrytosayivebeenthere · 18/05/2011 21:32

Its not just because i dont like the answers that I want this gone,

It has spiraled from my sis and my stepdads birthday today to people suggesting that maybe there was abuse in the family when she was a child.

i felt i should put a bit of history in the op as if you drip feed you get told off but i never expected abuse to come into it,

And as for my bil, he is not the golden boy, he is my 2 nieces father, my sis was shagging someone else and left him for another man, he has been part of our family for the last 25 years and just because my sis had enough of him doesnt mean we are gonna cut all contact,

He never forgets a birthday, pops into us all for a cuppa if he is passing,

He is with someone else, has been for the last couple of years but still see's us as family, What is wrong with that?

OP posts:
Pagwatch · 18/05/2011 21:39

One person implied abuse may be involved.

You have said that is not the case. Why is it necessary to get everything deleted. Why do you not just report that post if you think it is offensive ?

You don't seem to like her at all from what you have written here. Perhaps she just knows that?

StewieGriffinsMom · 18/05/2011 21:41

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

madwomanintheattic · 18/05/2011 21:47

omg that's hilarious. i hadn't even realised they were all still glad-handing the ex-bil. and referring to the break-up of the relationship as 'her off shagging someone else'. is that what he told you? Grin did he also say she was 'spoilt as shit' etc etc? this is actually v funny. the ex turning the entire family against the firstborn!

i can't imagine why she doesn't feel comfortable hanging out with 'the family'...

but don't worry. bil will still be there for a cuppa and a gossip whilst your sis is working chatlines all night.

expatinscotland · 18/05/2011 22:19

If you de-reg no, the threads don't go with you.

moomaa · 18/05/2011 22:50

Ok, I'm going to try and do a sensible reply cos it might help even though you have called your sister some really nasty names.

I think that you cannot assume any person will have a good relationship with a step father, especially if that man replaces the father you have lived with all your life. It's great that you have welcomed him into your life and are glad that your mum is with him but you can't assume your sister can do the same.

I also find it odd that your BIL is still so involved in your family life. Her relationship broke up, you can never know the real reasons why, you weren't in the relationship with them. No matter how you feel about it you should be polite but have a certain distance with him. Your sister could feel very alienated by how pally pally he is with you all. Might make her unco,fortable in her own family.

Is it worth talking to her to ask about these things and try to understand each other a bit more?

needanewname · 19/05/2011 11:25

OP are you like this in real life? Lots of people have given some very helpful suggestions but because its not what you want to hear you are flouncing?

I wonder why your sister has distanced herself....

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread