Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why my older sis is so uninterested in our family

93 replies

sorrytosayivebeenthere · 18/05/2011 15:34

Hi I am no 3 of 4 children (all adults now) 49, 47, 42 and 38

My older sis is the eldest, then my bro, me and younger sis. Our parents split when I was 18 so 24 years ago, both remarried, Never really got to know my dads wife as he is a funny man not very interested in us anymore.

Both myself and my db are still in contact with him although it is limited, My sisters have no contact, Older one cos she can't be arsed to make the effort, He is very hard work and I think very old school and if we don't make the effort then he will hold a grudge.

Younger sis didn't speak to him for years and then when her dh died last year my dad called her but no contact since.( I lost contact for a few years whilst with my abusive ex but when my bro told my dad about it he called me and we have been in contact since)

A few years after my mum and dad split my mum met and married a wonderful man, they were sweethearts at school, met up by chance, and my younger sis and I went to school with his 3 sons, He has been more than a stepdad to us and has been the only real grandad that my kids have known.

sorry if i'm going on a bit but felt a bit of history would be needed.

Well if you were to ask all four of us about our childhood I know that 3 of us would say we had a good childhood, hardworking dad, very loving mum who worked pt, My dad wasn't a very physical person, I cannot remember ever having a cuddle when I was young or anything but he was there for us and provided what we needed, We respected and looked up to him cos he was our dad, I do remember a few rows between my parents in my teens but nothing really bad.

My older sis reckons we all had a crap childhood,

Well now back to the present, Me, 2 sisters ( kids) and mum and stepdad all live in same area, my bro lives a fair bit away and works really hard but still finds the time to visit when he can and phones my mum regularly,

Both myself and my younger sis are very close to my mum, My mum is very good with my niece and takes care of her before and after school as my younger sis has to work, My older sis couldn't give a shit about any of us to be honest, she never visits or phones or texts unless there is a birthday or very special event,

She lives 10 minutes away from us by car (she drives, we don't) but no bus route so for us to go to her would take prob 40 min walking, not that she has ever invited any of us to her flat in 4 years,

It is my stepdads birthday today and my mum has heard nothing from her, my ex bro in law (who we are still very close to him as she left him for someone else and he is the father of my niece's) has dropped a card in but she will not bother, she never has for my stepdad.

My mum cannot understand why she is the way she is towards family, she always has more than enough time for friends but family doesn't seem to matter.

My mum says that she prob thinks that if there is a problem then one of us will let her know but I cannot understand why she can go months at a time wothout speaking to us, just to see how things are going or to catch up on any gossip, to see my little niece whos is almost 6 and just a wonderfull little girl,

I do not get how that out of four of us one can be so uninterested and cold towards close family members, we all grew up together, my bro was only 2 years after her, why does she have such a different perspective on our childhood?

OP posts:
expatinscotland · 18/05/2011 19:47

'as far as im concerned she can go whistle, if i do get anything then its for my kids. not her.'

I also don't see why you want a relationship with her at all if she's such a cunt and a twat, to use your own words.

claretandcheese · 18/05/2011 19:48

You asked in your OP " why does she have such a different perspective on our childhood?". Some of us have tried to guess possible answers to this, bearing in mind that we can't possibly know anything as this is an internet forum and none of us ( I assume ) have the gift of being psychic.

Being angry about this doesn't make sense, really.

madwomanintheattic · 18/05/2011 19:49

i might have a bit of a thing about your stepdad myself - introducing y'all as his daughters in a pub after just meeting your mum? you've already got a dad, who apparently is a perfectly normal chap, not an abuser. stepdad sounds like a smarmy type who i'd not be sending a b-day card to either, if i'm honest. do you think it's your stepdad's overfamiliar attitude with a grown woman who'd already left home that might be the reason for her not, er, liking him that much, however nice he is to your mum?

bit needy for my liking.

sorrytosayivebeenthere · 18/05/2011 19:50

Pagwatch I do not want to fight with anyone,

I think this has gone way to far and I have asked for the thread to be removed as it has spiralled way out of my controll,

I did not want this to happen, I am very upset by it all.

My sis was spoilt, she was a twin and the other twin didnt make it, she was their first and was spoiled for that reason, older family members have confirmed that, as the rest of us came along things changed and we all had a good childhood.

when they split i was 18, my younger sis was 15 older ones had left home,

my older sis has never said anything about abuse, i just see it as it was, just upsets me now when my mum gets upset cos she feels like my older sis doesnt care,

OP posts:
expatinscotland · 18/05/2011 19:56

'I think this has gone way to far and I have asked for the thread to be removed as it has spiralled way out of my controll,'

Newsflash: your determination to control and dictate to others, along with your determination to paint your sister out to be a 'cunt' and a 'fucking twat' and to hate her, is very off-putting.

Sure, you can have this thread removed because you don't like how it's going, but IRL, you can't do that, so I'd suggest you let things go and focus your energy on something more positive because your negativity is very unpleasant.

claretandcheese · 18/05/2011 19:57

It may sound strange but there is some evidence that people who lost a twin at birth are often more disturbed by it than those who lost a twin later in life.
It is thought this may be due to the problems in adjusting that the parents have ( difficulties grieving at exactly the same time as having a newborn ). It could be that your sister had a difficult attachment/bonding with your mum at a very vulnerable stage and this has continued to affect them both in a way that wouldn't happen with children coming later.

Not an excuse by the way, just an attempt to understand.

expatinscotland · 18/05/2011 19:58

She doesn't want to hear it, claret. She wants everyone to say, 'Yes, your sister is vile. You are wonderful. Here is a medal.'

That is not happening, so the thread will be removed.

JamieAgain · 18/05/2011 19:59

Before you go, I also wondered about the change that happened after she split from her husband, as AMAZIN said

The mention of abuse has upset you. But no-one was saying that's what happened, simply that it could be a possibility you don't know about.

Or she might just be selfish.

Nixea · 18/05/2011 20:03

I know it's not helpful or constructive in any way but to be quite frank, if you were my sister then I'd be damn sure not to have any more contact with you than I needed to. Sorry but for me you crossed a line when you called your sister a cunt.

What really strikes me as barmy is that you're getting so worked up about this on behalf of someone else!! Is this really about contact or is this more about you resenting having to be the one who's always having to visit the family because she won't? Either way...you've come across as rude, self-centered and aggressive. Nice.

NotQuiteCockney · 18/05/2011 20:06

It sounds like there's a family dynamic where someone has to be the 'bad' one, and it sounds like you've decided it should be your sister.

needanewname · 18/05/2011 20:12

Nice OP, real nice.

Don't post a thread in AIBU if you don't want to hear that maybe you are.

Pagwatch · 18/05/2011 20:18

Op. You really do need to contemplate that most of this stuff isn't up to you.

The thread is actually quite instructive if you chose to read it properly rather than flying off at the bits you take umbrage at.

Fwiw I was abused my whole childhood. None if my sisters knew. They thought I was the favourite. It wasn't my father but it still took me a long time to get over the fact that my mum and sisters never knew. It felt to me as if, if they cared about me, they should have known. Plus my mum unwittingly gave this man access to me.
No one knew. He was a great bloke, everyone loved him.

My point is you just assume you know about your sisters life and choices. But you don't

sorrytosayivebeenthere · 18/05/2011 20:58

I think you are all a bunch of wankers who think you know it all

OP posts:
sorrytosayivebeenthere · 18/05/2011 20:58

report me please i wanna get banned

OP posts:
sorrytosayivebeenthere · 18/05/2011 20:59

this site is fucking shit

OP posts:
sorrytosayivebeenthere · 18/05/2011 20:59

I hate you all

OP posts:
JamieAgain · 18/05/2011 21:00

Sorry you feel that way

sorrytosayivebeenthere · 18/05/2011 21:01

all i wanted was for this thread to be deleted as it went so out of controll and it is so upsetting but they wont delete it and i cannot not read it

OP posts:
pink4ever · 18/05/2011 21:02

Shock that you spat the dummy out? not really......

Bumfuzzle · 18/05/2011 21:03

you can deregister if that is what you would prefer to do. You can go to 'my mumsnet' and deregister from there. You don't need to be banned.

I am sorry you feel we are all this, that or the other. I personally think that's quite unfair.

JamieAgain · 18/05/2011 21:03

OP - you ca hide it. Click on Hide at the top

pink4ever · 18/05/2011 21:03

Why do you want to get banned? If you want to leave then just de-reg and go. Dont let the door hit your arse on the way out,dearie.

JamieAgain · 18/05/2011 21:04

I also think we've been trying to be helpful.

sorrytosayivebeenthere · 18/05/2011 21:05

i dont really hate you all but i just want this to go and they wont , my sis wasnt abused,

i started this about her not being interested in the family now.

why wont they just delete it?

OP posts:
MCos · 18/05/2011 21:06

OP, it sounds like you think your sister has it too easy, and that it is making you jealous/driving you mad.

From your posts, I can see why she stays out of family matters. Charming, NOT.

Swipe left for the next trending thread