Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think "No! I'm not depriving her"

83 replies

LifeIsButtercream · 20/01/2011 16:25

Ok, please don't pelt me with {biscuit], I'm not meaning to come accross as wondermum or trying to polish my halo, I'm just confused:

A friend of mine and I were chatting about what our LOs had been up to (her DS is almost exactly the same age as my DD). The conversation turned to LOs fave food (and the often amusing eating antics of 20m olds). I mentioned that I'd been making cakes with DD as a treat and she said that homemade cakes could never be treats to children, only 'shop bought ones with cartoon characters, like their friends have'.

I was a bit Hmm and she continued to say that she made sure her DS had fruit shoots/character-endorsed yogurts/cheese-strings etc 'the same as his friends' so that he wouldn't feel left out, and for me not to do that with DD was depriving her and she would feel left out by her peers.

"THEY AREN'T EVEN TWO!" - my mind screamed

When my DD is older - an example, if she is at a birthday party at McD's, or Pizza Hut, she will have the same as her friends (i.e. I won't be there with the organic carrot sticks and wholemeal-stoneground-homemade-bread saying she isn't allowed), but at 20m the need hasn't arisen for her to have these in her diet, and I'm not causing her to feel 'uncool' cos she hasn't had them yet?

DD hasn't had a Fruit Shoot, she loves watered down apple juice (asks for it all the time) and didn't like cordial when I gave her some to try. I love baking so we usually have homemade cakes in the house, therefore I don't buy them.

I came away from the chat feeling that either I was a mean mother (my first time around so I'm not very confident as a parent) or some kind of crack-pot who restricts her daughters diet..... am I?

OP posts:
bubbleymummy · 20/01/2011 20:44

Bumper, Sully might not be too difficult! :)

onceamai · 20/01/2011 20:46

Our wedding cake was only 110!!! FFS a mumsnet first time swear word acronym from me Shock.

sungirltan · 20/01/2011 20:46

my mum stil lets me lick the bowl now! baking with my mother was/is an integral part of my childhood and defintelty part of my relationship with her. i love baking too but the best part is still when mum turns up at ours with a tin - dh and dd are always really excited! :-)

schmee · 20/01/2011 20:47

I'm with lifeinlimbo - I think she's winding you up. Maybe she's a bit intimidated by your cake making activities...

Heard someone on the tv yesterday complaining that someone was stuck up for suggesting to their child that they had pasta for lunch. Made me think about some of the things I've said innocently like that - I love cooking and I'm lucky to have kids that love healthy food as well as harribos. I probably really wind people up Sad

Diamondback · 20/01/2011 20:54

Your friend is either:

a) Mental! In which case, smile and ignore, or...

b) Very, very insecure and oversensitive about her own parenting skills, to the point that when you told her a lovely story about making cakes with your LO, she took that to mean "Unlike you, with your shop-bought cake mix and your Cheesestrings, you CHAAAAAAAV!!!"

Maybe some other, very smug mummy has been criticising what she feeds her kids?

Either way, this is all about what is going on in her head (as is the case with most criticism/unsolicited advice) than it is about you having a lovely, lovely time baking cakes with your kid.

pointythings · 20/01/2011 20:54

YANBU, OP. I always make home-made cakes for birthdays and for every other excuse that I can find too. You soon get handy with icing and I always get told how beautiful our cakes are (testimony to my DCs' creativity as they are the ones who put on the designs in silver sugar balls/flowers/icing spirals/other sundry decorations). And they taste blooming marvellous.

Thank goodness mine have gone off fruit shoots and now only crave smoothies - bad for the bank balance but so much less crap...

LifeIsButtercream · 20/01/2011 21:11

Wow! Lots of replies! Am so grateful, maybe I should bake you all cakes!

trixie DD can just about help - armed with a heavy mixing bowl (mine has a rubber ring in the base to stop it sliding) and a wooden spoon - she stands in her FunPod and tips ingredients in (I give them to her in little bowls measured out) and 'stirs' - we often stir together lol!

OP posts:
ilythia · 20/01/2011 21:18

Your friend would hate my DD's nursery.

They made chocolate rice krispie cakes today and one of the staff told me that after they ran out of cake cases they handed all the children a spoon and let them go nutsGrin

Shop bought cakes are ming. And you can't decorate them and eat all the icing. How boring is your friend!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page