to eat all my dh's Toffifees and put the empty tray at the bottom?

[OpenToLawSuits]

A surprise for him once he gobbles all the top layer muah ha ha.

no,you are definately not being unreasonable, what a lovely surprise for him!!

Sounds reasonable to me. I eat them then blame the kids/dogs/neighbours

Made me laugh _ thank you! ;)

YANBU

Ah yes, the children. Perfect blaming! WHy do I get the feeling you've done this before.

YABVU

Eat the lot, throw the whole box away, and deny all knowledge of anything toffifee related.

ha ha ha ha. Even better. He actually counted them yesterday. I figured if I ate the tray and removed it he'd think he was going mad...!