Lindsay clancy trial

[Widowwith2]

Has anyone else been following the lindsay clancy trial? What is everyone thinkin? I dont think she done it

No you asked people not to judge LC on one clip. In the same breath you asked everyone to judge PC.

In what way did I ask everyone to judge PC? You need to be clear.

To say no one checks out on a family activity for certain periods is disingenuous and only used to suit a narrative.

It was a video used by the prosecution.

Are you suggesting that the prosecution used this clip to suit the narrative?

Here is where you asked us to see how unsupported she was. I don’t think it’s that difficult for you to see but hopefully your own words will make it more clear.

Or did you mean something completely different?

Do I think the prosecution used evidence for their own narrative. Yes. Yes I do. Do I think to suit your narrative. No. No I don’t.

It clearly shows how unsupported she was. taken from your previous post.

one snapshot moment, and you’re saying it’s showing she was unsupported. How unsupported? In that instant? The split second of that video? A couple of minutes? What happened before and after the video was shot? Oh, wait, nobody knows, and yet you’ve made a judgement of his character based on that moment.

Based on that moment she on the other hand was showing as a devoted, normal, sane mother. No psychosis or mental illness anywhere. Therefore as much as he was an unsupportive mother she was clearly a coldblodded murderer as there was no sign of mental illness there.

Gosh its incredible how you can judge someones state of mind from an image. You must be a multimillionaire with this gift and in such high demand.

Now, stop talking out of your arse.
Depression, anxiety, and other mental conditions don't come with a highviz jacket. Psychosis develops silently and quickly. Someone can be perfectly fine one day, and then the next they believe their skin is crawling, their partner is trying to kill them or their is a radio in their brain telling them there will be a nuclear apocalypse.

The short video shows a women single handedly managing 3 children whilst her male partner stands by, meters away, not doing anything to help ease her burder. It's a snapshot in time, doesn't tell us what she was thinking or feeling, but it paints a very damming picture of their relationship at that moment in time.

No longer replying to your posts neverlook.

Rant into the void.

I never said I was judging her on that basis. I made the comparison on the basis of the previous poster who has used that one clip to judge that PC was clearly unsupportive and that she was clearly unsupportive.

That clip doesn’t show that any more than it shows she isn’t mentally ill. But posters are using that video clip to judge him whereas some could judge her on the same basis.

It just doesn’t work like that.

My comparison was illustrative.

Glad you can admit when you’ve lost the argument.

"That clip doesn’t show that any more than it shows she isn’t mentally ill"

Please divulge your medical qualifications that render you capable of diagnosing mental conditions based on a short video clip.

It's clear that there's a poster on this thread who is determined to shut down discussion via intimidation. It shows exactly who they are.

My advice is to not directly quote.

anyone know what time the live feed starts?

The trial resumes again on Monday. Prosecution were expected to close their case yesterday but following a sidebar of some type, the judge gave the jury a long weekend with orders to return Monday.

@AhHereNow Thanks, what time does it usually start?

Exactly. What kind of father lets the mum carry everything!

Think it changes day by day, I generally catch ip with it, not live. The jury was asked to be back at 9am Monday so I’m guessing somewhere around 2pm.

My opinion on the video of the museum is that PC was standing over at the opposite exhibit (if you look close you can see it has the same activity as the one Cora is playing on. He is waiting for Dawson to go over to him, which Dawson eventually does do. At one point LC even gestures to Dawson to go to PC. I think it is easy to misinterpret what is happening in that short clip.

That being said as a parent of an ND child who can’t wait for long periods (or short periods) was wow these kids are really really good and sweet. How lucky they were as parents to have 3 beautiful kids.

I also think stepping away from this case is good for sanity. I’m trying not to follow as closely as it just is very upsetting. The museum clip was hard to watch.

I think you are a voice of reason in this thread @NeverLookInTheMirror .

The testimony of the prosecution side seems very clear that there was no psychosis apparent to ANY of the multiple, multiple professionals who dealt with LC. We can only go with the evidence. Maybe the defence will show a different picture.

Yes I've been following it. What a horrendously sad case. I think she did it and was very unwell. I struggled post partum.. not to this extent but I do remember feeling it was the worst time in my life, not feeling like my usual self and making frantic calls to samaritans. I lool back now and it doesn't feel real. I asked repeatedly for support , it was hard to get any but thankfully I eventually had amazing support from a great GP and an amazing peer support charity, I will never forget those women who helped me. It's scary how easily you can slip into feeling so unwell with the sleep deprivation and hormones.
I really do feel so so sorry for her. It must be such a horrible position to be in. But yes I think she did it and the husband just didnt understand how ill she was....she was maybe good at hiding it.

Except that the PP literally says that diagnosing based on a short clip is not possible. And, this, doing the opposite of claiming that she can.

Genuine question.What evidence is there that she did kill the children other than an obviously mentally ill woman saying she did and her husband saying she said she did?
Can that alone be reliable beyond all reasonable doubt?

I understand this trial is about wether LC is criminally responsible for the killings of her children due to her mental illness or not. However, i'm interested in why its "fact" that she killed them. I genuinely want to know what evidence there is that she killed them other than her saying so and PC saying she said so. Is a confession from a clearly mentally ill woman reliable on it own?

I think you are missing the point that she is on trial. It’s not up for discussion what the evidence is. The only questions are, is she a sociopath? was it PPP or was there something about her medication which caused this?

For the past 3 years her lawyer and his team have been pulling it all together and now after a couple of weeks people like you think there is an aha I’ve figured it moment!