Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

When will people realise that pensioners have paid for their state pension.

758 replies

notsafeanymore · 19/06/2026 09:13

Every time there is a debate about the cost of living pensioners get a bashing.
And some have also paid for a private pension.
It's people who have never worked that should be targeted first.
I'm not on about the disabled. It's people who are benefit cheats and have never worked.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
TheRealMagic · Yesterday 12:58

ThreadGuardDog · Yesterday 12:52

But free childcare hours are available to those who qualify.

Again - almost no one gets genuinely free childcare. I know it's confusing because the government tagline is 'free childcare', but for most people it is actually lightly subsidised, and the average family still spends considerably more on childcare after the 'free' hours than they did a decade ago.

ThreadGuardDog · Yesterday 12:59

Scotiasdarling · 19/06/2026 15:32

When pensioners went to university only 8% of the school leaving population went. Even if they all got grants, which they didn't, even middle class families had to pay what was known as a parental contribution, the sums involved would have been miniscule. Now that 50% or whatever it is want to go to university it's perfectly obvious that it has to be funded by debt. Going to university is a choice, and for a great many students not a sensible one.

Absolutely this.

Snoopymayhem · Yesterday 13:01

TheRealMagic · Yesterday 12:56

You can see, though, why 'no one under 40 will get a state pension but they'll need to keep paying for other people's for the rest of their working life' isn't an announcement that any political party is keen to make!

.When the UK's modern universal state pension system took effect in 1948, the government introduced a "pay-as-you-go" approach. This allowed existing older citizens to receive a pension even if they had not contributed into the new National Insurance (NI) scheme throughout their working lives.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

Brokentoes85 · Yesterday 13:02

When are people going to realise you can't make sweeping statements, not everyone has paid for their pension, it's a benefit and you pay for the previous generations not your own?

nomas · Yesterday 13:03

I overpay into my work pension but I think there are people who think (rightly or wrongly) that they’ve left it late for a meaningful private pension and would rather take their chances with the state pension and pension credit, rather than paying into a private pension now and not qualifying for pension credit.

Snoopymayhem · Yesterday 13:05

TheRealMagic · Yesterday 12:58

Again - almost no one gets genuinely free childcare. I know it's confusing because the government tagline is 'free childcare', but for most people it is actually lightly subsidised, and the average family still spends considerably more on childcare after the 'free' hours than they did a decade ago.

More than a decade ago
not London
One child cost over £1000
i had twins and one other
over £3000

no money off
no free hours
Nothing

Free childcare means for the hours allowed you don’t pay
It doesn’t have to mean every hour you chose is free

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 13:12

Brokentoes85 · Yesterday 13:02

When are people going to realise you can't make sweeping statements, not everyone has paid for their pension, it's a benefit and you pay for the previous generations not your own?

Maybe people who haven't read the numerous posts saying the same on this thread?

WhereverIlaymycatthatsmyhome · Yesterday 13:26

Parker231 · Yesterday 12:01

The majority of millionaire pensioners hold property wealth not cash. A significant number of pensioners live below the poverty line.
If the country doesn’t/can’t fund a state pension going forward, there needs to be plenty of advance warning - as an example no one under the age of 40 will get a state pension - tapper it out so that those impacted have time to make their own pension arrangements.

I guess in future those sitting on over £1m of assets will have to sell or downsize in order to live if their wealth means they don’t qualify for a state pension.

Something has to give and none of it is palatable.

MontyDonsBlueScarf · Yesterday 13:37

Downsizing releases a larger property but it doesn't always release much cash. There isn't a lot of difference between the price of a 3 bedroom hhome and a 5 bedroom home in some areas, and the competition for the smaller homes is higher. Then there are moving costs and stamp duty to pay. If people are reluctant to move in the first place, it's often not sufficiently financially attractive to encourage them.

Snoopymayhem · Yesterday 13:38

WhereverIlaymycatthatsmyhome · Yesterday 13:26

I guess in future those sitting on over £1m of assets will have to sell or downsize in order to live if their wealth means they don’t qualify for a state pension.

Something has to give and none of it is palatable.

I’m guessing by then the Govn will have pre warned all younger workers
and they will have paid into their employer subsidised private pensions all their working lives anyway
So they won’t need to sell their home

WillowFae · Yesterday 14:12

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 11:44

And what if your workplace didn’t have a pension to pay into?

I never said I was encouraged by my workplace. I was encouraged by people around me. Had there been no workplace pension I would have started a private one.

My children are about to go into the world of work in freelance careers. We have already had the discussion with them about pensions and are looking at private options for them.

WillowFae · Yesterday 14:17

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 11:59

There was always the expectation you would get your state pension though.

Yes, but even back in 1993 I was told that living purely on the state pension may not give me the sort of lifestyle I might want. Basically the way I looked at it was that a state pension would be like a basic wage and my private pension would allow me to live a bit more comfortably. This is not something that wasn't talked about until recent years.

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 14:21

WillowFae · Yesterday 14:12

I never said I was encouraged by my workplace. I was encouraged by people around me. Had there been no workplace pension I would have started a private one.

My children are about to go into the world of work in freelance careers. We have already had the discussion with them about pensions and are looking at private options for them.

"I was told back then that it was a good idea to pay into my workplace pension. So I did. It wasn’t rocket science."

It's "rocket science" to people who haven't been "told" to either join the work place pension (if one existed back then) or get a private one.

Plus, if it isn't "rocket science", you wouldn't have needed to be told.

suburburban · Yesterday 14:29

Katypp · Yesterday 10:54

Can i just point out that, although pps are keenly pointing out that pensioners probably have not paid in as much as they are getting out, they are pretty much the only cohort of benefits claimants that have to have paid anything in to get something out.
I never understand the largesse on MN towards UC claimants and the derision towards pensioners.

Well said

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 14:29

WillowFae · Yesterday 14:17

Yes, but even back in 1993 I was told that living purely on the state pension may not give me the sort of lifestyle I might want. Basically the way I looked at it was that a state pension would be like a basic wage and my private pension would allow me to live a bit more comfortably. This is not something that wasn't talked about until recent years.

I started work in 1982. It was talked about then. Mine was compulsory at first (LA), then optional.

A lot of people left it because, like now, they needed the money. What for I don't know as they had been paying 6% of their wages into anyway.

My parents, at that time, 40 years ago, gave me the same advice you were given.

So I agree, to an extent.

We were lucky that we got that advice.

A lot of people didn't.

june35 · Yesterday 14:36

suburburban · Yesterday 14:29

Well said

Working age people on benefits get a lot more stick than pensioners do. They are benefit bashing stories in the press everyday but not much negativity about pensioners. The opposite in fact.

UC is much less than the state pension too, a single person gets about £420 a month.

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 14:46

june35 · Yesterday 14:36

Working age people on benefits get a lot more stick than pensioners do. They are benefit bashing stories in the press everyday but not much negativity about pensioners. The opposite in fact.

UC is much less than the state pension too, a single person gets about £420 a month.

It’s not pensioners vs benefit claimers! The pensioners might have claimed benefits back in the day too. Like JSA.

This is divide and conquer.

WillowFae · Yesterday 14:47

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 14:21

"I was told back then that it was a good idea to pay into my workplace pension. So I did. It wasn’t rocket science."

It's "rocket science" to people who haven't been "told" to either join the work place pension (if one existed back then) or get a private one.

Plus, if it isn't "rocket science", you wouldn't have needed to be told.

I think you misunderstand me. I was told it was a good idea and when it was explained to me it seemed obvious and therefore 'wasn't rocket science'. Of course if no one had explained it then I probably wouldn't have done it.

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 14:48

WillowFae · Yesterday 14:47

I think you misunderstand me. I was told it was a good idea and when it was explained to me it seemed obvious and therefore 'wasn't rocket science'. Of course if no one had explained it then I probably wouldn't have done it.

We were both lucky then?

WillowFae · Yesterday 14:49

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 14:29

I started work in 1982. It was talked about then. Mine was compulsory at first (LA), then optional.

A lot of people left it because, like now, they needed the money. What for I don't know as they had been paying 6% of their wages into anyway.

My parents, at that time, 40 years ago, gave me the same advice you were given.

So I agree, to an extent.

We were lucky that we got that advice.

A lot of people didn't.

And a lot of people probably rejected the advice if they were given it. I remember people in my first job who decided not to do it even though we all talked about the benefits. I guess when you are in your 20s it just seems so far off.

Snoopymayhem · Yesterday 14:49

june35 · Yesterday 14:36

Working age people on benefits get a lot more stick than pensioners do. They are benefit bashing stories in the press everyday but not much negativity about pensioners. The opposite in fact.

UC is much less than the state pension too, a single person gets about £420 a month.

Plus housing and other benefits

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 14:58

WillowFae · Yesterday 14:49

And a lot of people probably rejected the advice if they were given it. I remember people in my first job who decided not to do it even though we all talked about the benefits. I guess when you are in your 20s it just seems so far off.

Agree. At that age I just looked at the bottom line and that was my wages. So glad I did now.

Badbadbunny · Yesterday 15:13

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 14:21

"I was told back then that it was a good idea to pay into my workplace pension. So I did. It wasn’t rocket science."

It's "rocket science" to people who haven't been "told" to either join the work place pension (if one existed back then) or get a private one.

Plus, if it isn't "rocket science", you wouldn't have needed to be told.

There's something called personal responsibility! It's like WASPI's all over again! So many people seem to be living under a rock and make no effort to look after themselves. Always expecting to be "told" to do things. What do people want? A personal visit by the prime minister of the day to come and tell them? The information is more easily available than ever. It was massive in the mid 80s when private pensions were introduced - you couldn't help but see it throughout mainstream media (TV, newspapers, magazines etc). Pension firms spent millions on advertising and marketing.

I remember being at a local Polytechnic on day release course for my accountancy exams and one lecture was cancelled and replaced by a pension firm who came in to give a presentation re personal pensions.

I also sat in on a talk given by a different pension firm at one of our client's businesses to all staff when they set up a firm pension scheme - it was a no brainer to join as the employer paid in several percent of wages, but a stupidly high number of staff didn't want to join!

You can lead a horse to water but you can't make it drink.

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 15:15

Badbadbunny · Yesterday 15:13

There's something called personal responsibility! It's like WASPI's all over again! So many people seem to be living under a rock and make no effort to look after themselves. Always expecting to be "told" to do things. What do people want? A personal visit by the prime minister of the day to come and tell them? The information is more easily available than ever. It was massive in the mid 80s when private pensions were introduced - you couldn't help but see it throughout mainstream media (TV, newspapers, magazines etc). Pension firms spent millions on advertising and marketing.

I remember being at a local Polytechnic on day release course for my accountancy exams and one lecture was cancelled and replaced by a pension firm who came in to give a presentation re personal pensions.

I also sat in on a talk given by a different pension firm at one of our client's businesses to all staff when they set up a firm pension scheme - it was a no brainer to join as the employer paid in several percent of wages, but a stupidly high number of staff didn't want to join!

You can lead a horse to water but you can't make it drink.

So condescending.

june35 · Yesterday 15:16

Snoopymayhem · Yesterday 14:49

Plus housing and other benefits

You only get housing benefit if you rent, and only up to a certain amount. You get no help if you have a mortgage.

Pensioners are also entitled to housing benefit if they rent and have low earnings.

Swipe left for the next trending thread