Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

DS’s white lie put me in tricky spot

81 replies

TangledWeb6 · 11/08/2025 03:12

My DS13 has a good friend who lives around the corner from us. The boys go to different schools.

I received a text from the friend’s mum last night. She said she had been speaking to her DS and he told her that my DS receives similar results to him- mainly C’s and Ds. She asked if we could meet up and have a chat about how best to help our sons with tutors and how to navigate academics at school. She said all of her DS’s cousins and other friends seemed to have no struggles at all at school and she felt a bit isolated-she would love to catch up with someone who was in a similar situation with an academically struggling son. It was a really reaching out heartfelt text.

Except my DS does not struggle academically. He is a straight A academic scholarship holding student who is likely to receive the year level dux this year. I asked him what he was playing at and he said that his friend was so down and he just downplayed his results to make his friend feel better.

The funny thing is her son has such people skills, charm and grit that he is likely to end up the most successful of all his cousins and friends (including my son) but that would just sound patronising if I said this to her. Argh. My son is a complete wally.

What on earth do I tell the mum? My son lied because he felt sorry for your son? The poor woman has reached out about something and I can’t continue with the lie- she will find out eventually and it would just be wrong. Obviously DS has to fess up to his mate, but how do I respond to the mum who just poured out her worries to me as she thought I was a fellow traveler?

OP posts:
DoctorMarten · 13/08/2025 10:08

How about:

DS has done okay at school - privately, he’s a nerd!

I’ve heard some amazing things about [name of tutor], might be worth seeing if they have rapport with your son.

I would love to go out for a drink - when are you free?

verycloakanddaggers · 13/08/2025 10:24

Oh no no no, your text is far too much and sounds patronising.

The other mum's text was a bit full on, but you don't have to join in.

Also you must talk to your son before doing anything much, as this is his social life you're meddling in. He is navigating the nightmare that is school and it's tricky.

I'd send something just to acknowledge it but nothing at all about my son.

BooneyBeautiful · 13/08/2025 21:08

TangledWeb6 · 11/08/2025 03:25

Something like this?Argh I hate this.

“Hi X. Thanks for your text. Raising teenagers can be challenging! I have to say upfront that DS downplayed his school results a bit- he doesn’t like his mates to see him as a big nerd but he is actually going pretty ok at school. I’ve had a word to him about being more honest with his mates. Results aside and without wanting to downplay your concerns, I was saying to my DH recently that your DS is going to be the most successful of all the boys! I saw his lawn mowing flyers at the shops and was most impressed. He’s got all the charm and grit. I would love to catch up to chat about the boys and our teenage challenges- I just wanted to be upfront and apologise for DS giving the wrong impression about his results. Let me know if yiu want to catch up”

Edited

That's excellent!

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

Lavender14 · 13/08/2025 21:18

I'd actually text her and suggest going for a coffee and then just say, I feel a bit wick bringing this up, but I got your message which was lovely but I had to have a conversation with my ds about it because he's actually been doing fine in school. He did mention your ds was feeling upset about his grades so he's handled it badly and lied about his own grades to try and be a good friend. I've talked to him about how he's had good intentions but it wasn't the best way to be supportive. I'm really sorry. What if we arranged revision sessions for the boys and x can come over and maybe they could study together?

In the meantime I think you need to discuss a strategy with your ds for being honest. I remember doing the same thing with a friend who was struggling with something and my mum finding out and pulling me on it, and then having to go back and explain that I'd lied and why. Which felt really humiliating. Thankfully the friend took it as I'd intended. I'd tell him when you're meeting the mum and that gives him some time to come clean in the best way he can. Then you could also float the idea of a regular revision session and see if he'd be up for it and he can suggest it to his mate. If he's not keen then I wouldn't suggest it to the mum.

I think coffee would be nice because it sounds like she could use a bit of support with this as well and means you can move it forward and listen to her properly and really clear the air in a nice way rather than feeling awkward the next time you see her.

Flowercakes · 14/08/2025 08:43

Cornflakess · 13/08/2025 09:44

I think it’s really sad that you want OP to play down her son’s achievements and big up some other boy.

Interesting that’s your take. No idea where you extrapolated ‘playing down’ and ‘bigging up’ from.

AmIEnough · 18/08/2025 07:17

TangledWeb6 · 11/08/2025 03:25

Something like this?Argh I hate this.

“Hi X. Thanks for your text. Raising teenagers can be challenging! I have to say upfront that DS downplayed his school results a bit- he doesn’t like his mates to see him as a big nerd but he is actually going pretty ok at school. I’ve had a word to him about being more honest with his mates. Results aside and without wanting to downplay your concerns, I was saying to my DH recently that your DS is going to be the most successful of all the boys! I saw his lawn mowing flyers at the shops and was most impressed. He’s got all the charm and grit. I would love to catch up to chat about the boys and our teenage challenges- I just wanted to be upfront and apologise for DS giving the wrong impression about his results. Let me know if yiu want to catch up”

Edited

This is a great way to put it, I can’t see anyone being offended by this. I think you’ve put it very succinctly and politely and actually I commend your son for downplaying his results as he clearly has empathy and doesn’t want to hurt his friends feelings.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread