Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Fed up of being treated like I am worthless and a drain on society because I don't work

707 replies

elliejjtiny · 08/12/2024 22:32

Dh works. He used to have a well paid job but he took a pay cut so he could be more flexible for the dc who have SEN and multiple hospital appointments. I am carer to 10 year old ds who has autism and emotional development delay. He is considered "high functioning" but he receives high rate dla and he is in mainstream school with part time 1-1. This is going to be increased to full time 1-1 when he starts secondary school. In a lot of ways he is like a very intelligent toddler, especially with maths.

PIL came round today. They provide regular childcare for SIL's dc but have looked after my son probably about 5 times in the last 10 years. And never for very long. Because he is difficult. That's fine by me. But then they criticise me for not working. It's not just me,( actually they moan about me a lot less these days because they know I will argue with them and point out that they won't look after ds, school struggle with him so how am I supposed to work) , they go on and on about "people on benefits" and they assume things that are just not true like they think everyone on universal credit gets free holidays and they say the benefit system is more than generous and that people should stop moaning and get a job. Fil has been telling me with glee that one day ds won't need me to care for him and I will have to get a job. To me that's like telling a blind person that one day they will be able to see and they will have to give up their white stick. I would be more than happy to work if ds didn't need me to look after him.

I know sil thinks I should be working (although how, I have no idea) and every so often I keep thinking that maybe other people think this too. I've always said that when ds sleeps through the night I will try and go back to work part time but that hasn't happened yet.

OP posts:
Halible · 12/12/2024 08:24

Teateaandmoretea · 12/12/2024 07:59

I really wouldn’t take too seriously what people on this site say.

Yes. As a full time carer I have never come across judgement in real life about the fact I don’t have paid work, ever, or at least not to my face. Quite the opposite in fact. And that’s as the parent of a child who doesn’t have astronomically high needs, although they are reasonably complex. A lot of the time he probably doesn’t even appear disabled.

elliejjtiny · 12/12/2024 10:22

Halible · 12/12/2024 08:24

Yes. As a full time carer I have never come across judgement in real life about the fact I don’t have paid work, ever, or at least not to my face. Quite the opposite in fact. And that’s as the parent of a child who doesn’t have astronomically high needs, although they are reasonably complex. A lot of the time he probably doesn’t even appear disabled.

I find it's only the in-laws who judge me in real life for not working. It does get a bit special needs top trumps at the school gates sometimes. Parents arguing about whose child has the highest needs. Parents arguing that they want the same support for their child that someone else's child gets. I do understand the last one though. Many children with SEN are getting less support than they need and no parent wants to see their child struggle. My son should be in a specialist school really but there are no specialist schools near us which carer for my child's needs. There used to be but children like my son are in mainstream school these days.

OP posts:
Vettrianofan · 12/12/2024 10:29

Candy24 · 12/12/2024 03:54

As a full time carer for my daughter this thread is really sad. Like on one hand there are so many people that get it and you are lovely. But there a few of you that just don't and really you suck. it is hard enough to cope with the lack of sleep the endless tasks and care our children need but to face judgement is just too much.

Ignore these people. You know yourself you're doing the best job for your DD. Stay strong and don't lose ever doubt yourself ❤️

ChallahPlaiter · 12/12/2024 21:43

Rosscameasdoody · 11/12/2024 20:27

It’s the ‘free car’ that most people land on when talking about disability benefits. With a bit of research they would know that motability is a charity working with the motor industry to provide discounted vehicles and adaptations to allow disabled people what, for some, will be their only chance to be mobile.

Motability is absolutely nothing to do with the DWP and PIP/DLA claimants can only join the scheme if they are on the enhanced rate of mobility component - which only those with severe impairment will qualify for. I’ve been a disability outreach worker for many years and for me, one thing stands out. I’ve come across many people who take the view that a mobility allowance is a fair provision for the disabled, but who completely change their stance when motability is mentioned. The general consensus seems to be that disabled people shouldn’t be able to access ‘free cars’. I’ve never understood this attitude. The mobility allowance is payable if you meet the criteria. If people have no problem with that, why should they have a problem with the ability to exchange that allowance to lease a car ? Given that the provision of that car is at no cost whatsoever to the tax payer, it doesn’t make any sense, especially when you realise that for many people with substantial mobility problems, a car is the most convenient option.

Edited

I’m sure people don’t know that motability cars are paid for via the mobility element of DLA/PIP (or that there’s often a hefty deposit to pay, especially if you need a wheelchair accessible van - that’s pricey!). I think they imagine you just wake up to see a new car parked outside your house, totally free of charge! It’s baffling that nobody ever asks themselves how plausible this theory actually is.

GabriellaFaith · 12/12/2024 23:06

I have 2 children. 1 I would describe the same as yours and throw in adhd and immunosuppressed. However, I still work, part time so within school hours. Hospital appointments an employer has to let you take so no issue. And I work for the NHS so some understanding. If your fed up of the consequences of not working, do some work. And you can't moan about your parents nine wouldn't cope with the kids, but they aren't their kids so not their problem. I chose to have them, my responsibility.

Maybe make more use of his HF to fully appreciate him too. I won't say not hard work, it is, but I focus on different because she has her own gifts.Found my daughter is amazing at some hobbies as her brain suits it and it also means we have something for her to enjoy and we can enjoy with her .

Viviennemary · 12/12/2024 23:08

Stop worrying what folk think. You have good reason not to work.

ChallahPlaiter · 13/12/2024 06:57

GabriellaFaith · 12/12/2024 23:06

I have 2 children. 1 I would describe the same as yours and throw in adhd and immunosuppressed. However, I still work, part time so within school hours. Hospital appointments an employer has to let you take so no issue. And I work for the NHS so some understanding. If your fed up of the consequences of not working, do some work. And you can't moan about your parents nine wouldn't cope with the kids, but they aren't their kids so not their problem. I chose to have them, my responsibility.

Maybe make more use of his HF to fully appreciate him too. I won't say not hard work, it is, but I focus on different because she has her own gifts.Found my daughter is amazing at some hobbies as her brain suits it and it also means we have something for her to enjoy and we can enjoy with her .

Employers don’t have to give you time off for your child’s medical appointments. You can apply for parental leave which is limited and unpaid but then what’s the point of going to work if you’re having to constantly take time off without pay?
I have disabled children. I can work now but I couldn’t for years and I appreciate that for some families paid work will never be possible. No idea why people insist it always is.

MusicMakesItAllBetter · 13/12/2024 07:32

Adventlandonhs · 08/12/2024 23:11

I agree. It’s odd.

Your child is in school full time. You could get a part time job.

I have a special needs son, much worse then high functioning and I work 30 hours a week and my husband works full time so I don’t really buy all this can’t work because I have a disabled child malarkey.

and no, I don’t have any family help either.

Well isn’t that most wonderful for you and don’t your shit smell like roses????
OP, you clearly are living a life of Riley and are not reaching your full potential as this person has so how dare you come on here and complain 🙄

MusicMakesItAllBetter · 13/12/2024 07:33

Viviennemary · 12/12/2024 23:08

Stop worrying what folk think. You have good reason not to work.

This!

GabriellaFaith · 13/12/2024 09:23

ChallahPlaiter · 13/12/2024 06:57

Employers don’t have to give you time off for your child’s medical appointments. You can apply for parental leave which is limited and unpaid but then what’s the point of going to work if you’re having to constantly take time off without pay?
I have disabled children. I can work now but I couldn’t for years and I appreciate that for some families paid work will never be possible. No idea why people insist it always is.

A lot of employers, all government sector, do give time off for appointments.

I agree work is not always possible. But this is at least 6.5 hours 5 days a week when the child is in school. So if you wanted to you could fit some work in.

Don't get me wrong, I am often exhausted and would much rather not work! But I can so I go because I want to pay for the kids to do things, I have a motivational reason.

ThereIsALifeOutThere · 13/12/2024 09:46

The OP is having 3~4 appointments A WEEK with her dc.

I can’t think of any employer that would be happy to give some time off as often as that.
On paper, Flexible working from home might make it possible as long as her dh can step in. But clearly 1- there aren’t many of those jobs and 2- I suspect evenings are still taken with running the house with 2 compétents adults.

ThereIsALifeOutThere · 13/12/2024 09:47

GabriellaFaith · 12/12/2024 23:06

I have 2 children. 1 I would describe the same as yours and throw in adhd and immunosuppressed. However, I still work, part time so within school hours. Hospital appointments an employer has to let you take so no issue. And I work for the NHS so some understanding. If your fed up of the consequences of not working, do some work. And you can't moan about your parents nine wouldn't cope with the kids, but they aren't their kids so not their problem. I chose to have them, my responsibility.

Maybe make more use of his HF to fully appreciate him too. I won't say not hard work, it is, but I focus on different because she has her own gifts.Found my daughter is amazing at some hobbies as her brain suits it and it also means we have something for her to enjoy and we can enjoy with her .

Do you have to attend 3~4 appointments A WEEK?

If not, it’s simply not comparable

FestiveFruitloop · 13/12/2024 10:25

GabriellaFaith · 12/12/2024 23:06

I have 2 children. 1 I would describe the same as yours and throw in adhd and immunosuppressed. However, I still work, part time so within school hours. Hospital appointments an employer has to let you take so no issue. And I work for the NHS so some understanding. If your fed up of the consequences of not working, do some work. And you can't moan about your parents nine wouldn't cope with the kids, but they aren't their kids so not their problem. I chose to have them, my responsibility.

Maybe make more use of his HF to fully appreciate him too. I won't say not hard work, it is, but I focus on different because she has her own gifts.Found my daughter is amazing at some hobbies as her brain suits it and it also means we have something for her to enjoy and we can enjoy with her .

Oh good lord, the nightmare continues. 🙄

WouldiwantThat · 13/12/2024 10:31

FestiveFruitloop · 13/12/2024 10:25

Oh good lord, the nightmare continues. 🙄

I’m sure there will be a poster along soon who has 7 disabled dc, a full time job and has been dead for 3 months to show us all how lazy we are not working

SleeplessInWherever · 13/12/2024 10:39

GabriellaFaith · 12/12/2024 23:06

I have 2 children. 1 I would describe the same as yours and throw in adhd and immunosuppressed. However, I still work, part time so within school hours. Hospital appointments an employer has to let you take so no issue. And I work for the NHS so some understanding. If your fed up of the consequences of not working, do some work. And you can't moan about your parents nine wouldn't cope with the kids, but they aren't their kids so not their problem. I chose to have them, my responsibility.

Maybe make more use of his HF to fully appreciate him too. I won't say not hard work, it is, but I focus on different because she has her own gifts.Found my daughter is amazing at some hobbies as her brain suits it and it also means we have something for her to enjoy and we can enjoy with her .

How dismissive.

I love my stepson to death, he’s a wonderful little boy who brings us much happiness and is the light in every room he’s in.

He’s also had about half an hour’s sleep in the last 8 years, leaves teeth marks in peoples arms and smashes things when he’s angry.

Let’s not pretend it’s all sunshine and butterflies, and all we need to do is appreciate them.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 13/12/2024 10:44

GabriellaFaith · 13/12/2024 09:23

A lot of employers, all government sector, do give time off for appointments.

I agree work is not always possible. But this is at least 6.5 hours 5 days a week when the child is in school. So if you wanted to you could fit some work in.

Don't get me wrong, I am often exhausted and would much rather not work! But I can so I go because I want to pay for the kids to do things, I have a motivational reason.

I actually did work until recently where I was being pulled into alsorts of capability meetings for my below entry level job that required no skill because I was just at my physical capacity to perform. I wasn't just exhausted.

I hallucinate spiders, wood grain warping, floors moving, people calling my name and crying, people stepping into the road that aren't there. I find myself looking at something, blinking and 10 minutes have passed. Or an hour. Or two hours, where I am pretty much catatonic because it's the only reprieve from my caring duties.

My son doesn't have nearly as many appointments as OPs child, and technically has full time provision, but can only access it on a part time basis. Sure I could dump him at the school gates at 8:45am and come back at 3:15pm if I and the school didn't give a shit about his social, emotional or physical wellbeing or how that impacts other children, because we all know how sympathetic other parents are when they find out their kid has been thumped or bitten by the overwhelmed autistic kid.

He doesn't sleep though. Sometimes 2 hours sometimes 4 hours but never in one go. Maybe a few naps in the car because travelling in car is one of the only ways he's regulated enough to sleep. I don't drive, so we rely on someone else for transport so that is few and far between.

Good for you that you COULD physically work. You can swivel if you think your experience is universal.

Halible · 13/12/2024 13:39

GabriellaFaith · 12/12/2024 23:06

I have 2 children. 1 I would describe the same as yours and throw in adhd and immunosuppressed. However, I still work, part time so within school hours. Hospital appointments an employer has to let you take so no issue. And I work for the NHS so some understanding. If your fed up of the consequences of not working, do some work. And you can't moan about your parents nine wouldn't cope with the kids, but they aren't their kids so not their problem. I chose to have them, my responsibility.

Maybe make more use of his HF to fully appreciate him too. I won't say not hard work, it is, but I focus on different because she has her own gifts.Found my daughter is amazing at some hobbies as her brain suits it and it also means we have something for her to enjoy and we can enjoy with her .

I think you and I have very different children, which probably explains why you work and I don’t. My child is amazing at nothing, yet I’m sure would be described as high functioning by many. Frankly I wouldn’t even give him a satisfactory for basic things like eating a meal or putting clothes on. I can appreciate him all I like or change my focus from one part of him to another but it isn’t going to magically make him easier to live with or parent.

I’m happy for you that you enjoy your family and can have a career, but don’t for a minute assume that every child and every family set-up is like yours, or could be like yours if only they did what you do.

Rosscameasdoody · 13/12/2024 13:50

When I was working as a disability adviser, I actually had to sit people down and explain the Motability scheme to them. So many people happy to criticise when they actually don’t know how it works or why it was set up. Or, in fact, how long it has actually been running - since 1978. I’m quite shocked by the number of people who also think that the claimant gets the mobility allowance and the car. The concept of handing over the allowance in return for leasing the car seems to be beyond some people. It’s only the most severely disabled people who have significant mobility problems who qualify for the scheme - it’s beyond me why anyone would begrudge them a car if it helps.

Rosscameasdoody · 13/12/2024 13:52

ChallahPlaiter · 13/12/2024 06:57

Employers don’t have to give you time off for your child’s medical appointments. You can apply for parental leave which is limited and unpaid but then what’s the point of going to work if you’re having to constantly take time off without pay?
I have disabled children. I can work now but I couldn’t for years and I appreciate that for some families paid work will never be possible. No idea why people insist it always is.

Under the Equality Act you can be allowed time off if your child is considered disabled under the Act. Employers don’t have to pay you, but they do have to allow you the time off.

Rosscameasdoody · 13/12/2024 14:15

WouldiwantThat · 13/12/2024 10:31

I’m sure there will be a poster along soon who has 7 disabled dc, a full time job and has been dead for 3 months to show us all how lazy we are not working

And don’t forget how we’re robbing the tax payer for the luxury of a motability car !!

the7Vabo · 13/12/2024 15:05

GabriellaFaith · 12/12/2024 23:06

I have 2 children. 1 I would describe the same as yours and throw in adhd and immunosuppressed. However, I still work, part time so within school hours. Hospital appointments an employer has to let you take so no issue. And I work for the NHS so some understanding. If your fed up of the consequences of not working, do some work. And you can't moan about your parents nine wouldn't cope with the kids, but they aren't their kids so not their problem. I chose to have them, my responsibility.

Maybe make more use of his HF to fully appreciate him too. I won't say not hard work, it is, but I focus on different because she has her own gifts.Found my daughter is amazing at some hobbies as her brain suits it and it also means we have something for her to enjoy and we can enjoy with her .

I find this attitude brutal.

I don’t consider my children a grandparent’s responsibility in general. But if I had a child with additional needs and my parents were in a position to assist me I would hope they would. Because they are my family & my child’s family. Not burn themselves out or work to the bone but just be of the mind frame to help.

Should I therefore adopt the attitude that my elderly mother is not responsibility either because it was her decision to have me so she shouldn’t expect anything from me?

I think it’s great that you can work if that what you need/want to do and it’s great you have a flexible role.

Nobody has to push themselves to burn out, that shouldn’t be an expectation of parents of children with additional needs.

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/12/2024 15:25

Nobody has to push themselves to burn out, that shouldn’t be an expectation of parents of children with additional needs.

But all too often it is - maybe not an explicit expectation but the result of constant questioning about benefits and why parents aren’t working while their kids are at school. Comments that parents have a higher income than “me” and maybe I should stop work too for all that free money drives parents to take on work they don’t have capacity for on top of caring responsibilities.

There’s also the expectation from school, health care and other various professionals that you can just be available during normal working hours, often at the drop of a hat because your child has additional needs. They way transport for specialist schools is arranged, the absolute dearth of wrap around care once your child reaches 12, despite them still needing supervision, the absence of respite care all places pressure on parents who care for children with additional needs.

To put this in context, the Scottish government announced an increase in funding for the short breaks scheme for carers in Scotland, bringing it to £13 million. There are around 750,000 carers in Scotland so that’s about £17 per carer, out of those 750,000 only 88,000 received carers allowance supplement payments last year so 10% approximately of carers were in receipt of carers allowance with the rest presumably balancing caring responsibilities with paid work. The reality is many carers live in deep poverty - which adds to the pressure and leads to burn out. It’s not about whether grandparents help or not, it’s the value we place on informal caring.

the7Vabo · 13/12/2024 15:47

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/12/2024 15:25

Nobody has to push themselves to burn out, that shouldn’t be an expectation of parents of children with additional needs.

But all too often it is - maybe not an explicit expectation but the result of constant questioning about benefits and why parents aren’t working while their kids are at school. Comments that parents have a higher income than “me” and maybe I should stop work too for all that free money drives parents to take on work they don’t have capacity for on top of caring responsibilities.

There’s also the expectation from school, health care and other various professionals that you can just be available during normal working hours, often at the drop of a hat because your child has additional needs. They way transport for specialist schools is arranged, the absolute dearth of wrap around care once your child reaches 12, despite them still needing supervision, the absence of respite care all places pressure on parents who care for children with additional needs.

To put this in context, the Scottish government announced an increase in funding for the short breaks scheme for carers in Scotland, bringing it to £13 million. There are around 750,000 carers in Scotland so that’s about £17 per carer, out of those 750,000 only 88,000 received carers allowance supplement payments last year so 10% approximately of carers were in receipt of carers allowance with the rest presumably balancing caring responsibilities with paid work. The reality is many carers live in deep poverty - which adds to the pressure and leads to burn out. It’s not about whether grandparents help or not, it’s the value we place on informal caring.

The minute something costs anything in society people start to question it.

Regarding grandparents and wider family members, bearing in mind that grandparents are often elderly and other relatives probably work I also think we also should push for/normalise a society where the village helps those that needs it. People were better at it years ago.

ChallahPlaiter · 13/12/2024 16:40

Rosscameasdoody · 13/12/2024 13:52

Under the Equality Act you can be allowed time off if your child is considered disabled under the Act. Employers don’t have to pay you, but they do have to allow you the time off.

I know.
Who can afford multiple unpaid time off, and how many employers are going to remain sympathetic to someone who needs to attend frequent appoints - despite what the law says?

ChallahPlaiter · 13/12/2024 16:42

GabriellaFaith · 13/12/2024 09:23

A lot of employers, all government sector, do give time off for appointments.

I agree work is not always possible. But this is at least 6.5 hours 5 days a week when the child is in school. So if you wanted to you could fit some work in.

Don't get me wrong, I am often exhausted and would much rather not work! But I can so I go because I want to pay for the kids to do things, I have a motivational reason.

I’m not sure “wanting to” comes into it for a lot of people. And there’s no moral imperative here.