Hear me out. It would only be for 2 years. I could write an essay on the pros and cons of each school but I'll try to keep it brief.
School A:
More convenient for next 2 years due to particular circumstances. DC1 already attends. Is a 10 minute drive away (unwalkable). Would be nice for them to attend the same school, even if only for 2 years.
School B:
Potentially very inconvenient for 2 years (will have 3 drop offs some days!) but will be more convenient for the following 10 years (also have DC3 to consider) as is only a 2 minute walk from our house. Also more likely to make friends/have play dates in the village which would be nice.
Both are a similar vibe, village schools, one form entry so I'd be happy with either although only have direct experience with school A.
What would you do?