Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Yet another person killed from a dog attack.. what is going on

877 replies

icelolly12 · 13/01/2023 08:32

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-surrey-64254413

Something needs to be done...reports of dog neglect taken more seriously, harsher prison sentences... any other ideas?

Awful, awful way to die, and makes me think twice about passing dogs off lead on walks.

OP posts:
FourTeaFallOut · 13/01/2023 10:06

Well yes, every dog has the potential to bite but not every dog has the potential to maul an adult to death.

Megifer · 13/01/2023 10:10

Whitney168 · 13/01/2023 09:53

My dogs insurance is £50 pm because I have the public liability and legal fees added on. Not a lot of people could afford that. That's with no claims!

I have never come across any dog insurance that didn't include third party cover, so that's nothing unusual.

For those who don't think they can afford third party insurance, annual membership of the Dog's Trust will give you £1,000,000 public liability insurance for the princely sum of £25. (Not sure if there is any restriction on the more dubious breeds.)

Its not standard, I know this because I have to tick the box that says id like it to be included. A quick Google confirms this too.

£25 is a great starting price, excess of £200 not bad either. Althoug it would be a lot to someone suddenly finding themselves out of work.

yorkshirepudsx · 13/01/2023 10:13

@Iam4eels exactly, I love that you rescued also by the way!!

But that was another point of what I said, the only thing that seems regulated openly is by the kennel club (which let's face it, all kennel clubs are in it for money) - the way a dog is bred and why it was bred has a part to play, so occasionally the kennel club can be useful in the sense that with some dogs, you can go bad decades of generations and see exactly where each dog came from, etc.

However, I strongly think that the upbringing of a dog and how an owner handles them is something that needs to be focused on. It's such a tricky thing to navigate - good owners of 'bad breeds' do exist, but it's sad to see things going the way they are

User359472111111 · 13/01/2023 10:18

Actual consequences for dangerous dog behaviour would be a start.

Newtrick · 13/01/2023 10:20

I agree theres no way to enforce dog licences. It will only be the responsible people that do it.
There are already dogs off lead in banned places, dogs without tags or dogs with tags without the right information, and dogs that aren't microchipped. All that's illegal but common

I agree that lots of dogs theres no record of. Think your bloke in the pub selling puppies, your average doodle breeder, it's all backyard breeding that are sold on via unofficial routes to friends of a friend.

The only place you could regulate it is vets but a huge chunk of dogs never see the vet. it's hard enough to convince some people to take them to vets because of the cost, let alone if there was a risk that they would be fined or have the dog removed etc. Watch anyform of dog rescue programme, its full of dogs with medical needs being treated with home remedies to avoid vet bills. If a dog needs medical care, you don't want to make people avoid vets as that will increase suffering

Kevinyoutwat · 13/01/2023 10:20

FrangipaniBlue · 13/01/2023 09:55

That's my point though @Kevinyoutwat

As a society we've normalised almost every household owning a dog WITHOUT those households doing their breed research and making absolutely sure they are choosing the right dog for their circumstances.

We've made unsocial dog behaviour socially acceptable. It is NOT ok for dogs to be running amok in public spaces with zero to little recall, harassing families and other dogs, jumping at people for attention "because he's friendly dontchya know!"

All of these things along with little to no regulation or enforcement has made it easier for the people you are referring to to own the more dangerous dogs in plain sight.

You are right, they won't give a shit about complying but if the MAJORITY of people are complying and there is appropriate enforcement in place, it highlights those who don't comply.

Yes, there will be some who "go underground" and do it anyway (the same as there will always be those who drive cars without licenses or insurance) but there will also be some who become disincentivised.

It's about taking multiple measures to ensure life is a lot more pleasant and safer overall, not trying to eradicate something completely because let's face it, that's unrealistic.

Honesty, we aren’t speaking about a tiny minority of people here. And they wouldn’t care about anything. It’s not just dogs, it’s every aspect of life. Like a PP said, taking drugs in the high street on an afternoon would horrify a lot of people - in a lot of places, it’s normal. You wouldn’t put them off doing anything.

And these people KNOW their dogs aren’t friendly. They aren’t the sort of people who would say “oh, don’t worry, they are friendly!” if they jumped up at you.

They wouldn’t notice or care, or they would think it was hilarious and if you said anything, you’d be verbally abused and/or followed and intimated for a laugh. I’ve been there and it’s why I can’t take my toddler out to parks.

With respect, I don’t think you have had much contact with the sort of people I am talking about, and thank god for that. I wish I didn’t.

Wheresthebeach · 13/01/2023 10:21

Def more regulations around breeding and selling of animals is needed.

I'd bring back dog wardens. There's a dog in our local area that has attacked numerous dogs. The owner switches parks regularly following an attack. The police are in the parks asking if anyone has seen the dog, naturally the owner refuses to give her details. There's very little chance of sorting this as the owner isn't bothered. Maybe dog wardens wouldn't solve a case like this, but if people got fined for having uncontrolled dogs off lead, their microchips and insurance checked (like cars), things would be better. Also any dog that bites, should go on the breeders record.

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 13/01/2023 10:23

Pp have said big dogs should be banned does that include labradors, old English sheepdogs, afghan hounds, just pulling names off the top of my head other breeds exist. How are you judging big breeds, what criteria are you using for declaring them big dogs. I do think xl bully should be added to the banned list for starters.

tulips27 · 13/01/2023 10:23

Dog owners are out of control in this country. Only the other day I had a dog walking woman bitching about cyclists to me, all while walking seven small chihuahuas that she had spread across the "shared" path. Just oblivious to criticism, they are blinkered and deluded. They place dogs above human safety and hygiene.

JanusTheFirst · 13/01/2023 10:24

ChiefPearlClutcher · 13/01/2023 09:08

Don’t be ridiculous.

Almost every report I have ever read about a person being killed by a dog, it was in their own home by a dog known to them or the family.

We need
a total crackdown on backyard breeding and the selling of dogs.
dog licences - tracking ownership and rehoming ( as is intended for chipping)
mandatory training
mandatory pet insurance (like car insurance) with third party liability.

When I was young my parents had our dog licence and rabies vaccine displayed in the window (abroad) as the dog warden was around so often it was just easier!

It isn't me that's ridiculous. Every day on MN and also in FB forums are reports of random attacks by dogs on strangers.

Wakes up. Is it OK if people don't die just get bitten? Muzzle them and no one gets bitten outside the home.

You are the ridiculous one.

RestingMurderousFace · 13/01/2023 10:25

Wheresthebeach · 13/01/2023 08:59

Breeds like American XL Bullies need banning, dog walkers need a much lower limit on the number of dogs they can walk and they should have to be licensed in some way. I’ve had issues in our local park with walkers not in control of 5 large dogs. Saw one the other day with 7 dogs all off leash.

for large dogs, that have the strength to kill, there should be compulsory training for dogs and owners

Report them to the local council. All areas have a different limit on the amount of dogs a walker is allowed to walk at one time. Around here it’s 5.

tulips27 · 13/01/2023 10:26

They leave dog poo anywhere and everywhere, they festoon the countryside with their discarded plastic bags of faeces that will take thousands of years to be destroyed, they don't control their dogs and allow them to jump up at people, they let them bark all day at home alone and attack people, even kill.

Banbigdogs2023 · 13/01/2023 10:26

Yes ban all big breeds and working dogs for the general public. They are so bad for the environment.

I was attacked by a Labrador as a child. Was a nice dog but it snapped - as they do!

Alltheprettyseahorses · 13/01/2023 10:27

I'd go further than PPs saying dogs should always be on a lead and muzzled (absolutely yes to this). I'd like to see dogs phased out as pets and just kept for assistance or working roles. Controversial opinion - dogs make bad pets compared to the variety of much better companion animals available. The fewer of them around around the better.

tulips27 · 13/01/2023 10:27

tulips27 · 13/01/2023 10:26

They leave dog poo anywhere and everywhere, they festoon the countryside with their discarded plastic bags of faeces that will take thousands of years to be destroyed, they don't control their dogs and allow them to jump up at people, they let them bark all day at home alone and attack people, even kill.

But remember everyone: cyclists are the real problem!

Banbigdogs2023 · 13/01/2023 10:28

Dog shit everywhere too.

smooshed · 13/01/2023 10:31

I see a certain type of person with XL bullies and the like. And they seem to be exactly the type who don't properly socialise them or train them and often seem to have little control over them, even on lead.

The problem dogs at any point in time are always the breed that is currently popular with those type of people. Once upon a time it was rotties and dobermans, then staffies, pitbulls, and now XL bullies.

My bigger dog is enormous, over 85Kg. If he even tried to go for a person then the police wouldn't need to take any action, I'd have him PTS myself. You have to wonder how many of these dogs that have attacked have previously shown aggression towards people and the situation could have been resolved before a serious attack happened.

caramac04 · 13/01/2023 10:32

@FourTeaFallOut yes I completely agree and recognise that my dogs have the bite strength to kill an adult. I am a responsible owner and am as confident as possible that they wouldn’t.
Other popular breeds, think cockerpoo, are unlikely to kill but unfortunately many are poorly trained and nervy. They can present a danger albeit a smaller one.
As for xxl bullies, I think unregulated cross breeding has created a ticking time bomb. Soon the rescue centres will be overcrowded with them and who will rehome them?
I don’t know the answer but the problem lays squarely at humans - poor breeding and poor ownership.
All breeders, even of one litter, should be regulated and proper consequences for back yard breeders and puppy mills. I can’t see it happening though.

yorkshirepudsx · 13/01/2023 10:39

Banbigdogs2023 · 13/01/2023 10:28

Dog shit everywhere too.

I see a lot of small poo's about too though

yorkshirepudsx · 13/01/2023 10:40

tulips27 · 13/01/2023 10:23

Dog owners are out of control in this country. Only the other day I had a dog walking woman bitching about cyclists to me, all while walking seven small chihuahuas that she had spread across the "shared" path. Just oblivious to criticism, they are blinkered and deluded. They place dogs above human safety and hygiene.

Not just this country, it's rife in America and Canada etc too.

There's a group on Facebook 'Oh look another clueless dog owner' and it highlights how stupid people can be

dameofdilemma · 13/01/2023 10:44

Two things struck me about the incident (I read the Guardian article on this incident):

A member of the public died, in public. Not the dog owner and not in the owners home. This is significant. Another member of the public is in hospital.

Seven dogs were rounded up by police. Seven. This wasn’t one rogue dog.

Bear in mind that the articles we see in the press are the tip of the iceberg. Over 8000 hospital admissions annually. And that’s just the people who go to hospital - lots more than that are actually bitten.

There is an odd indulgence for dogs in the UK - let your kids outside to scream at 6am and you’re a pariah but complain about dogs barking outside at 6am and you’re an evil animal hater.
Even the Queen indulged her snappy Corgis….

As others have said, too little regulation and next to no enforcement.

No requirement to train dogs (in some European countries dog training classes are mandatory and enforced but not the UK).

Little accountability within the police force - they’re supposed to have specialist dog units but many don’t and will look blank if you ask.

Of course people are going to be injured or worse. But who dares lobby for reform when so few voters will support it.

GoingtotheWinchester · 13/01/2023 10:46

Dog licences were scrapped because they were so cheap they were a nonsense and they were hard to police. Of course it wouldn’t solve everything but it would go a long way to making dog owners more responsible about all aspects of owning a dog.

It’s not just openly awful dog owners who are the problem it’s also just clueless dog owners - and there are so fucking many of those now. Think that dogs turn up fully trained, or that others find it cute when their dogs throw themselves at us 🙄. The “he’s only being friendly” brigade. Dogs are really expensive so if you can’t afford a dog license you can’t afford a dog.

Banbigdogs2023 · 13/01/2023 10:47

Oh yeah I’d personally get rid of all dogs. Smelly things! but I do have friends with little dogs and they love them to bits and I see why they have them as companions.

I think it’s best to concentrate on the main problem. Big dogs are really bad for the environment and totally unnecessary for the general public . We simply should not have them in this day and age when we are trying to tackle climate change.

Small dogs bite yes, but I’m not sure I’ve heard of a small dog killing….

LordSugarTits · 13/01/2023 10:48

"You are right, they won't give a shit about complying but if the MAJORITY of people are complying and there is appropriate enforcement in place, it highlights those who don't comply."

Highlights it to who exactly? And how are you going to get a majority of scumbags to comply? They simply won't even listen to you and if they did they'd think you were a twat and instantly forget what you said

Banbigdogs2023 · 13/01/2023 10:50

I’ve just written to my MP. This needs to stop. That poor woman.