Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Awful Psychic Reading

111 replies

whatanidiotIam · 04/11/2022 21:39

Has anyone ever had a really good psychic reading where predictions have come true?

I've just wasted £30 on a phone reading. The reader got quite a few things wrong and was patronising. She said I need to work on self love. I've recently never felt so good about myself and confident.

The reader was supposed to be a medium and I was hoping for a message from a Grandparent.

What an idiot I have been!

OP posts:
MonsteraDeliciosa · 05/11/2022 12:26

I went to a spiritualist centre for an evening show some 30 years ago. I also went to see Darren Brown on stage about 9 years ago.

One of these was very impressive and “spooky” in what they told about strangers in the audience. They told a young woman what her late father’s nickname (not common) was, and also his hobby/passion (also not common). She cried. The other was laughably rubbish and inaccurate.

The rubbish one was the “genuine” psychic. DB on the other hand could make your jaw drop with his accuracy, whilst simultaneously telling you it was all baloney and he was using various tricks he’d learnt.

GrimDamnFanjo · 05/11/2022 12:27

There are no genuine mediums who converse with the dead. There are some people who are good readers with people skills. Many of whom genuinely believe they are psychic.
Tarot cards are just tools for thinking about issues. Nothing to do with being psychic.
There's a very large prize out there for a genuine psychic to claim - no one has.
A famous illusionist, was it Houdini? - had a deal with his wife that they would contact each other if one died, code words etc. that never happened either.

EmmaAgain22 · 05/11/2022 12:36

MonsteraDeliciosa · 05/11/2022 12:26

I went to a spiritualist centre for an evening show some 30 years ago. I also went to see Darren Brown on stage about 9 years ago.

One of these was very impressive and “spooky” in what they told about strangers in the audience. They told a young woman what her late father’s nickname (not common) was, and also his hobby/passion (also not common). She cried. The other was laughably rubbish and inaccurate.

The rubbish one was the “genuine” psychic. DB on the other hand could make your jaw drop with his accuracy, whilst simultaneously telling you it was all baloney and he was using various tricks he’d learnt.

This was literally a show though.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

MonsteraDeliciosa · 05/11/2022 12:39

EmmaAgain22 · 05/11/2022 12:36

This was literally a show though.

Yes, in which DB displayed amazing “psychic” talent.

He was using the self same TRICKS as so called mediums do during readings, albeit, much better.

Psychic mediums have stage shows, too.

Quveas · 05/11/2022 12:39

Shade17 · 04/11/2022 21:43

“for every true, honest and talented medium”

There’s no such thing, only predators who pick on gullible and vulnerable people.

I agree with this. I am sorry for people desperate for any means to communicae with loved ones, but the dead are dead. Whether you believe in an afterlife or not, they aren't going to be communicating with anyone. Even those that appear good are actually just very, very clever at reading cues in people. You would be amazed at what you give away to a talented fraud artist when you think you haven't told them anything. It's a bit "gooey pulp crime drama" for some (although I enjoyed it!), but watch The Mentalist if you want to see it explained in detail!

For the more intellectual:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cold_reading
www.ljmu.ac.uk/about-us/news/features/debunking-psychic-abilities

Your loved ones would prefer you saved your money and spent it on something for yourself.

HermioneWeasley · 05/11/2022 12:39

@EmmaAgain22 the point is that Derren Brown can replicate what the “best” psychics and mediums do, and is very clear it is all trickery. There is no supernatural explanation required.

LowbrowVictoriana · 05/11/2022 12:47

I actually find it quite depressing that grown adults, who have received at least a basic high school education, can believe in this rubbish and defend the cynical exploitation of bereaved people.

EmmaAgain22 · 05/11/2022 12:48

MonsteraDeliciosa · 05/11/2022 12:39

Yes, in which DB displayed amazing “psychic” talent.

He was using the self same TRICKS as so called mediums do during readings, albeit, much better.

Psychic mediums have stage shows, too.

Oh I know they do, I'd not go to that either

but I tend to imagine most of this stuff is literally staged - the audience people will be plants etc.

I have seen two psychics who were good and there were no "tricks". Also, a lot of this cold reading stuff is just pants.

I'm not ignoring replies btw, but off out now.

LowbrowVictoriana · 05/11/2022 12:57

but I tend to imagine most of this stuff is literally staged - the audience people will be plants etc.

Yes, in the so-called psychic shows. But Derren Brown literally explains how it's done, so doesn't need plants. Don't forget, he's debunking, not trying to pass off something impossible as true!

pompomdaisy · 05/11/2022 13:11

You would have had more success giving a pudge on your £30 and reading its poop! Why do people pay for this shit? Honestly?!

pompomdaisy · 05/11/2022 13:12

Pidgeon

TheFreaksShallInheritTheEarth · 05/11/2022 13:26

My granny read my tealeaves when I was about 11. She said I would marry a man whose name began with J, and have a son first.
I did!
Was she psychic? No, of course she bloody wasn't.

Taradiddled · 05/11/2022 17:03

ilkleymoorbartat · 04/11/2022 22:19

I'm really interested to know what draws people to visiting a psychic in the first place?

Desperation, in my case, the only time in my life I let myself be persuaded by a friend to go to someone her sisters had laced was uncannily accurate. I was at a really low point —- had dropped out of an MA, returned from a stint living in the US after a run of bad luck knocked my confidence, then had an accident that meant I couldn’t walk for six months and had to move out of the flat I shared with my boyfriend (inaccessible) back in with my parents and claim benefits. I was applying for postgraduate places overseas but feeling spectacularly low and stalled when I saw the psychic. I’m a total skeptic and I knew I was being an idiot, but I think I thought that any grain of fake hope for the future would keep me going.

Of course it was a combination of bollocks and the Barnum effect, but what strikes me now is that she predicted me the kind of future she clearly thought was great — I’d asked if I would ever live overseas or study again, and she said a firm no to both, as she clearly didn’t think either was a ‘good future’, and probably also I looked poor and ground-down and unhealthy and unambitious and she thought I was deluded, and felt that someone of 24 should be ‘settling down’ — but that I would start a business with my boyfriend, buy a house and have a baby within the year, and settle in my home city.

Within eight months, I’d been offered and accepted a major scholarship to Oxford, did two further degrees, and lived abroad for the best part of the next 20 years. My boyfriend and I have never had a business, our first property was a London flat years later, and we only had a child fifteen years after the ‘reading’.

If I’d presented as more middle-class, and had looked less neglected and unwell, I’m sure the nature of the bollocks would have been a bit different.

ldontWanna · 05/11/2022 17:20

Technically yes. I say technically because I don't believe in that stuff. It was free , not done as a "business" and no possibility of future meetings so it was just fun value. The lady did it as a thank you for looking after her on a train trip and to pass the time.Strangely accurate in her insights.

APJ1 · 05/11/2022 17:24

But Derren Brown literally explains how it's done, so doesn't need plants

I suspect otherwise. At one of his stage shows I attended years ago, there was a segment where, blindfolded, he asked the audience to merely think of a question and he'd pick out people and tell them what the answer was. If anyone saw that show and I've got the setup wrong, correct me!

Anyway, Derren asked for 'Kath' in the balcony. A woman in the row in front of me called out in response, loudly and clearly. Derren ignored her and asked again for "Kath", until another supposed Kath further away responded and he went into his 'mind-reading' with her.

APJ1 · 05/11/2022 17:28

^ Not that I'm trying to differentiate between Derren's trickery and that of 'psychics', I'm just veering off topic.

Oldbutwiser · 05/11/2022 17:40

No. They've always been really vague and there's nothing they've said that couldn't have been taken lots of different ways. Like astrology. I used to be a believer in these things and I've wasted money on them. We aren't pre ordained if we were we wouldn't need to do anything to achieve or change our lives as it would just happen without us making any effort. So there's no way to accurately see the future. I was told once that with things like tarot cards 'they' aren't telling the already set future they are telling you things that whatever supernatural powers 'they' are will make come true by manipulating events. It creeped me out when I thought about it. Also how can you bee 100% certain that what the so called mediums say they're in contact with isn't harmful? Or that they aren't just making things up for the money? Isn't there an open challenge that who ever can prove that mediums,supernatural, ghosts,tarot,telling the future etc are real under scientific conditions will get $1,000000. Lots have tried to but have been debunked.

mumarewenearlythereyet · 05/11/2022 18:19

@MidnightConstellation @Shitfather @EmmaAgain22 I've pm'd you. Please feel free to ask me any questions x

Herejustforthisone · 05/11/2022 18:26

mumarewenearlythereyet · 05/11/2022 18:19

@MidnightConstellation @Shitfather @EmmaAgain22 I've pm'd you. Please feel free to ask me any questions x

Why do you believe in it?

mumarewenearlythereyet · 05/11/2022 19:57

@Herejustforthisone because I have received too much evidence to be able to deny that it is possible to contact those who have died. I think most likely it's the continuation of the soul, but could be a form of collective consciousness.

I'm not religious but I do have spiritual beliefs. Those beliefs give me comfort. I'm happy to admit I might be wrong, but if I am I'm never going to know am I? Hardly going to wake up after I've died and say "damn it, I was wrong, there is no life after death"!

As for mediums, I believe there are a lot of people faking it, but I also believe there are some who are not. I'd never phone someone advertising in the back of a magazine, but I think someone who works in a spiritualist church is less likely to be a con artist.

It's just my belief. Those who believe it's all rubbish are just as entitled to their beliefs as me. I wouldn't want to try and convince them of "my truth" any more than I expect them to try and convince me of theirs.

MissMarpleRocks · 05/11/2022 20:00

Would you mind pming me please @mumarewenearlythereyet unless he’s who I already said as I have his number 😃thank you

mumarewenearlythereyet · 05/11/2022 20:08

@MissMarpleRocks pm sent

MissMarpleRocks · 05/11/2022 20:19

Thank you x

Thymely · 05/11/2022 20:27

I had a very scary old gypsy lady come to my door many years ago, wanted me to cross her palm with silver for a fortune telling. I wouldn't do it, but as I was closing the door she said there was someone with a certain name in my life which there wasn't, but a few months later there was. I was and still am a bit spooked by that.

EmmaAgain22 · 05/11/2022 20:37

Thank you for DM
ha e replied

re Derren Brown, it’s a show to get punters in. There will likely be plants even if he is trying to debunk stuff. Just because he’s trying to debunk stuff, that doesn’t mean he isn’t putting on a show.