Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Ukraine Invasion: Part 17

998 replies

MagicFox · 27/03/2022 07:23

A new place for us to convene, thread 17.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
33
TheABC · 27/03/2022 14:57

Longer term, I am sure leaving the EU will lead to an erosion of London as a global finance centre. The government have some bizarre plans to pre-empt this, but nothing makes sense really.

@TargusEasting, they don't have any plans. Longer term there will be some kind of reapprochment with the EU. They are simply too big and too close to ignore. It's lily to be the next generation of politicians that does it, though.

TargusEasting · 27/03/2022 15:27

I agree and am confident of that too. Watching our Prime Minister at the Nato meeting, shuffling, not knowing where to put his hands and looking very lost was quite telling. It was Nato of course, but nonetheless he is not a relationship man. At the same time I was thinking just how it would be if Ukraine joined the EU and Zelensky was in a leaders' photo but our PM was not there. How bizarre would that look? What would the Brexiteers be thinking then I wonder? In my 60 odd years I have experienced a range of strange things, but the world has never been in this state of flux in so many ways in my memory.

Tuba437 · 27/03/2022 16:15

3 days of talks in Turkey are interesting.

Ukraine Invasion: Part 17
theyhavenothingbuttheaudacity · 27/03/2022 16:18

Just heard about fires in near Chernobyl 😕

Tuba437 · 27/03/2022 16:42

3 days of in person talks in Turkey I would guess will be hopeful of some sort of document signing. Especially considering they have been continuing via video link. No need to do them in person otherwise.

Not suggesting a full peace deal but hopefully a partial one with the caviat of a ceasefire while negotiating on Dombass. This would fit in well with russia withdrawing troops in sumy and from the North on top of them saying phase 1 was complete.

On a totally different issue, I have seen some horrific videos circulating of Ukrainian army shooting Russian POWs in the legs after being captured. While I know Russia is the aggressor and has been Brutal with war crimes. I do hope those who commit war crimes from both sides are bought to justice.

Ijsbear · 27/03/2022 16:43

Agreed there. The videos are genuine? (has to be asked)

Tuba437 · 27/03/2022 16:49

@Ijsbear

Agreed there. The videos are genuine? (has to be asked)
I'm not sure on the authenticity. They are widely circulating on twitter though. I think we all learnt from Iraq etc that regardless of who are considered the good guys and the bad guys. Human beings can be cruel cruel people regardless.
Ijsbear · 27/03/2022 16:49

Skillful video of the retake of Olkhovka.

With the use of small drones being so vital, I could imagine boys' catapults making a comeback!

Post edited by MNHQ

notimagain · 27/03/2022 16:53

@Ijsbear

Agreed there. The videos are genuine? (has to be asked)
Lots of questions being asked elsewhere about those videos …I think opinion seems to be is they are genuine in terms of what they show but comments made that their origin can be tracked back to a pro-Russian site/source..

…so who knows? could be Ukrainian Forces misbehaving - not good at all even if slightly understandable in the context of recent events…OTOH possibility could also be a false flag operation..

UltimateFoole · 27/03/2022 16:56

[quote BoreOfWhabylon]Some really interesting analysis and insights on BBC Radio 4 The World This Weekend, not least from Khruschev's grand daughter

www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0015tpb[/quote]
That was a really good listen. Highly recommend it. With the lovely James Naughtie and so many great guests.

MagicFox · 27/03/2022 17:48

Enjoyed the Naughtie prog but was confused / perturbed by the blanket statement from the ex Russian govt official (forgot his name) who said towards the end that if Ukraine doesn't win there will be a global war. Couldn't figure out his reasoning

OP posts:
BoreOfWhabylon · 27/03/2022 18:10

Glad you enjoyed it @UltimateFoole Smile. They packed a lot into a short programme.

Ijsbear · 27/03/2022 18:27

China has considerable home problems it seems ... www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-60893070

This is pretty big all on its own, China's economy is the 2nd biggest priority after stability.

DGRossetti · 27/03/2022 18:31

@Ijsbear

China has considerable home problems it seems ... www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-60893070

This is pretty big all on its own, China's economy is the 2nd biggest priority after stability.

We have a China office, and one of my tasks is to get (and keep) the VPN twixt them and us up. They've just come out of one lockdown.
DFOD · 27/03/2022 18:54

@MagicFox

Enjoyed the Naughtie prog but was confused / perturbed by the blanket statement from the ex Russian govt official (forgot his name) who said towards the end that if Ukraine doesn't win there will be a global war. Couldn't figure out his reasoning
He was an ex Russian Prime Minster and was basically saying that giving Putin a face saving opportunity is effectively appeasement and he will come back emboldened - elsewhere - as he will see the West as weak.

He was saying that he needs to be visibly defeated - total regime change and will take 2 years.

MagicFox · 27/03/2022 19:00

@DFOD thanks for clarifying, I was listening whilst cooking dinner for the kids so couldn't concentrate as much as I'd have liked!

OP posts:
EsmaCannonball · 27/03/2022 19:14

I'm hanging fire on the video of the Russian pows being shot, partly because people are already questioning the source and the people circulating it, partly because I've already seen several debunked videos purporting to show grateful Ukrainians arriving in Russia, and partly because - although it does happen - mistreating pows is bad strategy because you want to encourage your enemy to surrender. It's a video I'd like to see verified before I take it as gospel.

DGRossetti · 27/03/2022 19:17

.

Ukraine Invasion: Part 17
BringBackCoffeeCreams · 27/03/2022 19:26

Regarding the forest fires around Chernobyl, DH (nuclear scientist) says it's not something to worry about. They'll increase the radiation levels within the exclusion zone but not enough to be threat to the public outside the zone.

EsmaCannonball · 27/03/2022 19:31

Apparently there is also a video of Ukrainians who were shot in the back of the neck after surrendering but that wasn't amplified by pro-Russian accounts on Twitter.

I've just seen a second video of Ukrainians abusing Russian pows. Again, it has yet to be debunked but there's something about the way it is shot that is making me suspicious. The Russians are bloody but unwounded and the camera seems to be determined to get close-ups of Ukrainian insignia.

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 27/03/2022 19:40

I've seen lots of videos of captured russians being fed and being allowed to phone their families to let them know they're ok.

If they are being mistreated that's terrible but they could stop it happening immediately by fucking back off to Russia.

RedToothBrush · 27/03/2022 20:00

Kevin Rothrock @kevinrothrock
lol Russia’s federal censor has just prohibited the Russian news media from publishing interviews with Zelensky.

Zelensky just posted the whole interview.

Zelensky says Ukrainian forces are still in control of part of Mariupol. He’s told them they can retreat if they see a way to do so and survive, but the troops insist on remaining, until they can leave with their dead and wounded.

He says Moscow has refused to claim their dead. They’re just kids, says Zelensky. But Russia won’t move on this, apparently afraid of revealing the true number of soldiers dying in Ukraine. They’ve offered “[body] bags” not even fit for dead pets, he says.

He says whole suburbs around Kyiv and towns like Volnovakha have been razed to the ground. “No more homes. No more streets. We can’t even show these images to Ukrainians [they’re so awful].” Russia’s invasion has been brutal beyond imagination.

Zelensky says there’s been enormous disappointment in Russians and Russian society for the nation’s support for the war. It can’t be denied, though dialogue is still possible.

Zelensky endorses boycotts against Russian athletes, saying they’re instruments of the Kremlin whether they know it or not. Russian athletes should be made to feel uncomfortable for their state’s actions, he says.

Zelensky says he’s instructed Ukraine’s negotiators not to discuss any “de-Nazification” or “de-militarization,” rejecting these terms out of hand as vague and unacceptable.

Zelensky says Ukraine’s language policy has been discussed in negotiations, but Kyiv demands the same rights for the Ukrainian language in Russia as Russia demands for Russian in Ukraine.

Changing Ukraine’s national security posture would require a national referendum, which would take at least a year to arrange and conduct. Moscow doesn’t appreciate any of this, says Zelensky. Refugees would also be voting.

Nobody can guarantee Ukraine’s security while Russian troops still occupy Ukrainian soil. “Who’s going to do it? Johnson? Biden?” says Zelensky incredulously.

Any referendum is utterly impossible until Russian troops leave, otherwise it’s a repeat of the illegitimate nonsense that took place in Crimea in 2014.

Are there side negotiations going on outside the public spotlight? Zelensky says a lot of people are talking. Officially, unofficially. (He’s not really answering this question, leaving it open.)

This whole interview is happening in Russian, btw. (Zelensky occasionally turns to an aide off screen and asks how to say a Ukrainian word in Russian.)

Question: Moscow says Ukraine planned a preemptive attack against the Donbas. What’s Kyiv’s response?

Zelensky: Cmon, guys, this is fake.

Any documents produced by Moscow that claim Ukraine had such plans are 100% phony baloney.

Zelensky does a “Solovyov but not this one but that one.” There are so many (including one of the editors in this interview), but the infamous one is infamously the pro-Putin pundit and epic dirtbag. I love these jokes. Never gets old.

About the Snake Island soldiers: some died, some were taken hostage. (There’s been some confusion about what happened here, but this incident birthed the famous slogan “Russian warship, go fuck yourself.”)

Asked about Ukraine’s supposed secret bioweapons program, Zelensky says this is another Russian fake. Furthermore, he would never have approved such a ridiculous research program.

Ukrainians wouldn’t deploy such weapons even against their worst enemies, says Zelensky.

Zelensky says he never even considered sending troops into Donbas or Crimea because the loss of life would have been simply unacceptable. (Quite a difference from the decision making we’ve seen from Putin.)

LNR and DNR will likely seek annexation by Russia soon. What’s Zelensky think about this? Zelensky says it’s a question of legitimacy and legality. Russia doesn’t have it in these occupied territories.

Zelensky refuses to say anything about the dozen or so attempts on his life since the full-scale war began.

Appealing to Russians who live behind the “information curtain,” he urges these people to reach out to their friends and relatives in Ukraine to learn the truth about the war.

The war will end when Russians accept that this has been a catastrophe for the nation and for relations with their neighbors in Ukraine.

Adults today will never forgive what’s happened, but it’s still worth fighting for the children and future generations, says Zelensky.

Zelensky says there will be no retaking of Crimea by force. Ukrainians are sick of war and destruction. This isn’t a hoorah war; it’s a national tragedy.

Zelensky’s value for life is such a contrast to the way Putin speaks. Night and day.

Question: Why did Putin do all this?

Zelensky: Putin isn’t being strategic. That would mean planning five presidencies ahead. Putin has tried to achieve by force what can’t be. A grave error. God forgive him.

DGRossetti · 27/03/2022 20:09

They’ve offered “[body] bags” not even fit for dead pets, he says.

Well surely that's one thing the west can provide ? All the ones we didn't need for Covid maybe.

If the Russians are leaving rotting corpses around, it's a form of biological warfare anyway.