Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Sarah Harding (Girls Aloud) has died

95 replies

plodalong12 · 05/09/2021 14:22

Following a battle with breast cancer, aged 39. RIP

OP posts:
Mrsorganmorgan · 05/09/2021 16:16

badlybehavedwoman.
I agree with everything you have said. I think you are amazing.

wellbehavedwomen · 05/09/2021 16:22

Sorry, didn't mean to derail about Sarah Harding, whose family will be suffering so much today. Just a bit evangelical about wanting people to check their own breasts.

Love to her family and friends, and may she rest in peace.

DifficultPifcultLemonDifficult · 05/09/2021 16:25

Sorry, didn't mean to derail about Sarah Harding, whose family will be suffering so much today. Just a bit evangelical about wanting people to check their own breasts.

Sarah, herself, wanted to use her pain to help others, so you haven't derailed at all, you're honoring her wishes.

I, for one, have been reminded to check my breasts today (haven't done it for a while) so thank you.

NorthernPlights · 05/09/2021 16:59

@wellbehavedwomen thank you very much for your posts. So eloquent and very moving. I am absolutely going to follow the examination process you set out, and that quote is beautiful ❤️

Defaultuser · 05/09/2021 17:19

@relentlessforwardprogress cancer is such a complicated individual thing. I would take the advice/prognosis from your loved one's medical team and try not to look at the stats. Easier said than done i know.

RelentlessForwardProgress · 05/09/2021 17:21

@wellbehavedwomen thank you for taking the time to reply and for the really helpful information.

In other times I'm sure I would have been able to go in with my family member and be better informed, but at the moment due to covid they must go to appointments alone, their hearing isn't great and the doctor talking to them is also wearing a face mask and sitting 2m away so its very hard for them to hear everything and take it all in, and the family get all information very much second hand.

It is incredibly useful to know that being really upbeat for someone with cancer can in itself be isolating, I am going to concentrate on being a listening ear and try not to jolly them up. And the lemon pictures you linked to are much better than anything I've seen before about breast examination. Thank you

Anotheruser02 · 05/09/2021 17:22

Thank you for the info wellbehaved, if I could pick your brains would you be able to elaborate on the info about mammograms missing things? I had a mammogram last week, I thought they were very thorough, is an ultrasound more reliable generally do you know? I am early 40's.

RelentlessForwardProgress · 05/09/2021 17:23

@Defaultuser, sorry xposted with you, I'm a slow typer! As I said above we aren't really clear what the medical prognosis is.

RelentlessForwardProgress · 05/09/2021 17:27

@Passmeamenuatthetottenham and @Mamamia7962 Thank you.
It is hormone positive and herceptin positive breast cancer.
detected as an early cancer, no spread to lymph nodes, but 1 year later scans have found it in the lungs and bones, which seems to suggest that the drugs so far have not been effective. I appreciate you taking the time to reply to me.

wellbehavedwomen · 05/09/2021 17:30

@Anotheruser02

Thank you for the info wellbehaved, if I could pick your brains would you be able to elaborate on the info about mammograms missing things? I had a mammogram last week, I thought they were very thorough, is an ultrasound more reliable generally do you know? I am early 40's.
Hi there.

As women get older, breast tissue becomes less dense. It's an average, as with all things around human bodies, but mammograms work a lot less well on younger women. In our 40s, they tend to work better, and they work very well on women in 50s plus on the whole, but it depends a lot on individuals.

In my case, I won't have a mammogram until I am in my 50s as my breast tissue is dense - and so with my history, I have an annual MRI and ultrasound, instead. Mammograms didn't work on me at all well (it was very deep in the tissues, but also very, very large and I was not overweight, just large breasted).

If the scan was standard, I wouldn't worry. If it was due to symptoms - skin changes or something similar - I would contact the screening centre and ask how dense your breast tissue was, and I would strongly consider having a private ultrasound done. They don't work as well as an MRI, but are minimally invasive and a lot cheaper, and do work well enough.

The problem with scans when healthy is that they can lead to investigations you don't need, which have risks in themselves, which is why the breast screening programme doesn't start earlier. But it's also because mammograms don't work well on younger breasts.

I hope that helps. Breast Cancer Now have a free helpline if you have technical questions - they are lovely and have answered many of my own.

wellbehavedwomen · 05/09/2021 17:34

[quote RelentlessForwardProgress]@wellbehavedwomen thank you for taking the time to reply and for the really helpful information.

In other times I'm sure I would have been able to go in with my family member and be better informed, but at the moment due to covid they must go to appointments alone, their hearing isn't great and the doctor talking to them is also wearing a face mask and sitting 2m away so its very hard for them to hear everything and take it all in, and the family get all information very much second hand.

It is incredibly useful to know that being really upbeat for someone with cancer can in itself be isolating, I am going to concentrate on being a listening ear and try not to jolly them up. And the lemon pictures you linked to are much better than anything I've seen before about breast examination. Thank you[/quote]
@relentelessforwardprogress my relative recorded sessions so he could remember what was said - the clinicians were very happy to have that happen, and in these times especially I am sure they would be open to it. A lot easier with phones now recording so well, too! I can't remember anything about most of the consults when I was diagnosed, and wish I had done the same.

Did she have chemo, at all? If early, hormone responsive, and not in the nodes then I imagine that her team may have decided against?

Elisebev · 05/09/2021 17:38

@Mamamia7962

Relentless - Some women do live with secondary breast cancer for years, it all depends on what type it is and how aggressive it is, and where abouts in the body it has spread to. Also how well somebody responds to treatment as we are all different.

New drugs are being tested all the time and there are a lot of treatment options available. I wish your family member all the best.

I was going to say the same

I’m 3 1/2 years since my diagnosis. Mine had spread to the bones by the time I was diagnosed. I’m still on my first line of treatment and still able to work full time and do most of what I was doing before. Having said that I have lost a few friends this year that I had made since diagnosis which kind of makes it harder to cope as it brings home how serious it is. I feel like I’m walking on a tightrope and it’s a case of how long I can stay on the tightrope for, I was very sad to hear the news this morning about Sarah Harding, so young, She wrote a book about her diagnosis. I’ve got it lying to read but so far haven’t managed to bring myself to read it,

Escourtie · 05/09/2021 17:41

So Sad

Thoughts are with her Family X

RelentlessForwardProgress · 05/09/2021 17:42

@wellbehavedwomen oh that is a brilliant idea about asking if it can be recorded, it never occurred to me it would be allowed, I'll definitely ask, thank you.

She did not have chemo last year because it was felt the risk of her getting covid outweighed the advantages (this was last summer, before vaccines). I think they are going to offer her some now following these scans that have picked up the stage 4, but we aren't sure yet as it has to be decided at a meeting where different departments (?) talk about patients together (this bit is hazy, she's not sure she understood).

cushioncovers · 05/09/2021 17:44

Feel so sad for SH and her family. 39 is no age at all.

Passmeamenuatthetottenham · 05/09/2021 18:03

[quote RelentlessForwardProgress]**@Passmeamenuatthetottenham* and @Mamamia7962* Thank you.
It is hormone positive and herceptin positive breast cancer.
detected as an early cancer, no spread to lymph nodes, but 1 year later scans have found it in the lungs and bones, which seems to suggest that the drugs so far have not been effective. I appreciate you taking the time to reply to me.[/quote]
The positive thing about this is that being hormone and HER2 receptive means there are still hopefully lots of options to throw at it, especially if she hasn't had any chemo at all yet. Hopefully she will respond to her next lot of treatment x

BrilloPaddy · 05/09/2021 18:03

Rest in peace, Sarah.

DH's mum died of breast cancer in her early 50s, he was only 18. And his sister has just been diagnosed at the same age. Such a fucking awful cruel disease.

Mrsorganmorgan · 05/09/2021 18:20

badlybehavedwoman.
I agree with everything you have said. I think you are amazing.

tempester28 · 05/09/2021 18:31

Oh good god! so young.

BillyJoe111 · 05/09/2021 18:38

Oh she was so young. It’s just heartbreaking.

I wanted to say, so many people don’t realise this, but if you have private healthcare (with certain providers) you don’t even need a referral for a breast clinic.

I was having breast pain with nipple discharge earlier this year. I looked at my health insurance though axa and they cover a one stop breast clinic.

You just have to call the insurance company and they make you an appointment at your closest private hospital that does it. No GP referral needed. I called on the Monday morning and was seen by a consultant on the Tuesday evening. Consultant examination, mammogram, ultrasound scan then back to consultant for the results there and then - it was all done in under two hours.

I know so many people with health insurance either personal or through work who don’t know that this service is offered. So it’s worth checking.

KhoshkaKatya · 05/09/2021 18:40

So young Flowers

strugglingwithlife · 05/09/2021 18:44

I feel very sad about Sarah, it's so sad. My step mother survived stage 3 breast cancer and my step father's sister died from it quite young. I read Sarah's book earlier in the year. It's so devastating Sad Flowers to all affected by this horrible disease

tjayjay14 · 05/09/2021 18:51

Terrible news😞 RIP Sarah, so young as well, praying for her family xxx

Eyesofdisarray · 05/09/2021 18:53

Too young
RIP

wellbehavedwomen · 05/09/2021 18:53

[quote RelentlessForwardProgress]@wellbehavedwomen oh that is a brilliant idea about asking if it can be recorded, it never occurred to me it would be allowed, I'll definitely ask, thank you.

She did not have chemo last year because it was felt the risk of her getting covid outweighed the advantages (this was last summer, before vaccines). I think they are going to offer her some now following these scans that have picked up the stage 4, but we aren't sure yet as it has to be decided at a meeting where different departments (?) talk about patients together (this bit is hazy, she's not sure she understood).[/quote]
Yes, a Multi-Disciplinary Team Meeting, with the surgeon, oncologist, endocrinologist (if hormone responsive) a radiologist (or radiographer? Can't remember the name - the person who offers views on radiotherapy, anyway) and her key nurse(s) all present - if reconstruction is at issue, then a plastics surgeon too. Those meetings are completely standard and essential at putting together the very best plan possible for that patient. She understood perfectly.

I am going to assume that she's had a PET-CT scan, and possibly some biopsies since?

The reason I ask re. chemo is that even before Covid, people with low recurrence risk (and in terms of what you've said, that would have by all expectations have been her) often don't have chemo, as of course it carries its own risks. Small tumour, hormone responsive, no lymph node involvement, is all good news so they wouldn't have expected a spread.

I think that that's actually good, being a chemo virgin, because if she had had a recurrence that swiftly after chemo, I'd worry that her cancer doesn't respond to it. Most people do respond, so for her, that option is fully on the table, and could arrest things I hope. Definitely worth calling Breast Cancer Now and asking, but that would be my hope for her.

Also, please don't be as scared of chemo as I was! Chemo's not nice, in the way no illness is nice, but it's no different to being ill more generally. The fear of it was so much worse than the actual treatment. Chemo's reputation is from ten or twenty years ago. It's not fun - think 2 or 3 days of proper flu for every cycle - but perfectly doable, too. They have amazing drugs to remove the worst of the symptoms now- very few women feel sick at all. It's the exhaustion that's the worst part.

I think trying to open-listen, and not jolly her along, would be a godsend. It can be very lonely, facing your own possible mortality while everyone around you declares that they just know you'll beat the odds. I mean, the odds already beat you, in getting it. And honestly, if your relative's got a dark sense of humour, then laughter is so important. I still grin, remembering a group of us sharing notes on inappropriate songs on the radio while you're getting radiotherapy, or an MRI. (Think: If I Was You (I'd wanna be me too); This Girl Is On Fire; Live and Let Die... Grin). She may not find that stuff funny, but if she does, there's nothing better at lifting morale than finding life funny.