Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

If you’ve got a good relationship with your MIL...

90 replies

Lavinia1 · 11/05/2021 22:18

...what are the main reasons for that?

I’ve got 3 sons and no daughters. They are all lovely kind affectionate little boys and one day (I hope) they’ll grow up, get married and have kids of their own. I hope that I’ll have a good relationship with their future little families but there are so many negative MIL / DIL relationships on Mumsnet it seems like the norm and that worries me.

It doesn’t help that I also have a terrible relationship with my ILs and DH and his sister have very little meaningful contact with their parents (although their childhood was ok)- For us I think that’s down to the IL’s behaviour since we had our first DS and I’ve certainly learnt how not to behave towards a future daughter-in-law from them.

On the flip side, my own mum has two DILs and my DH and has a great relationship with all three of them. Trying to pinpoint why, I think it’s because she genuinely cares about them and it shows. She’s open minded, easy going, selfless and helpful. She’s got a good sense of humour and it all makes for a very relaxed relationship.

Is it the case (as in my experience) that a good or bad relationship with adult children is earned (whether they are male or female) or is there something in the old saying “a son is a son until he meets his wife...”?

I’d love to hear from people who get on well with their MILs, you don’t hear so many of those stories on Mumsnet but maybe that’s because people don’t post as much if everything is fine.

OP posts:
Rainybows790 · 12/05/2021 20:26

Just to add- I’m also a very easy going/ thick skinned person!

iklboo · 12/05/2021 20:28

She brought her sons up to be respectful & self sufficient
She never interferes
She's a great listener

timtam23 · 12/05/2021 20:36

My MIL is a kind and thoughtful lady. She was elderly when I met DH, so there is more of a "grandmotherly" feel to the relationship but she has never interfered in my life or tried to muscle in with child-bearing advice. We have some shared interests and she is very interesting to chat to as she travelled widely when holidays abroad were less accessible. She's very laid-back with fussy eaters and general child behaviours, having had 4 of her own children.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

timtam23 · 12/05/2021 20:36

*child-rearing advice

thistimelastweek · 12/05/2021 20:39

I got on great with my MIL.

It was easy. I didn't want to be his mum. She didn't want to be his wife.

Now I'm the MIL. It's working for the same reasons.
.

Bells3032 · 12/05/2021 20:43

My mil and I both adore each other. She's kind and generous and strong and I suspects she likes me cos she knows how much I love her son and am there for him no matter what.

I think it's not a secret. Just be kind and respectful and respect their boundaries. Don't pretend like your son is a Saint Prince who can do no wrong and who she doesn't deserve

imaterriblepersonarenti · 12/05/2021 20:46

She treats me like her child...and I mean in all the best ways. She's incredibly loving and genuine, always has my back. She showed me a photo not long ago of DH, SIL and I and said "look at this gorgeous photo of my babies, all three of you." I love that she cares.

I think it's also because she's been so welcoming since the first time I met her. She didn't wait until I had a grandchild and then suddenly wanted a relationship like some MILs do.

She cares about me as an individual and I know that if DH and I ever separated she'd want nothing to change between us and to maintain our relationship.

Plus she's an incredible cook Grin

Mammyloveswine · 12/05/2021 22:57

My mother in law is lovely! Genuinely one of the nicest people I know!

I have 2 sons so I hope my future daughter in laws (or son in laws) love me back like I love my mil!

Moonlaserbearwolf · 12/05/2021 23:04

Mine is fun and generous and treats me like a daughter. She’s the kind of person I’d be friends with anyway - we’re quite similar in fundamental ways (although on the surface we are quite different personalities).

Thecurtainsofdestiny · 12/05/2021 23:05

My MİL is great. Tells me that she loves me (well all of us really!), and she acts like it too.

Over the years I suppose there have probably been some things that I haven't liked. Maybe vice versa also as we're very different people in some ways. But I know she means well and I think that makes a difference.

Defender90 · 12/05/2021 23:10

I'm married to the eldest of three boys. I was the first DIL (but the last married) I get on fine with her, aye she moans and she's made my eyebrows shoot off my face several times, but we've never fallen out (even when she regifted in front of me) I find her less emotional, I don't want to say colder because she would do anything for any of us in a heartbeat but she's no a hugger, she didn't have the easiest life Ana I like to think we've got a mutual respect.

RampantIvy · 12/05/2021 23:13

...what are the main reasons for that?

Sadly my MIL is no longer with us, but we got on so well when she was alive.

We started off on the right foot. She was determined to make me feel welcome, and she hugged me the first time we ever met. She was a lovely woman.

I think a lot of problems arise when MILs and DILs seem to view each other as the enemy, both competing for the son’s/husband’s attention. Whereas both MIL and I had decided to like each other before we even met, and were happy to share the man we both loved. I was like a second daughter to my MIL and we loved doing the same things – having a mooch round the shops, drinking wine and enjoying good food. She sounds very much like your MIL @saraclara.

DH had already left home and had been living independently for several years, so the apron strings had already been cut, and I wasn’t viewed as the woman who took her son away from her.

Saladd0dger · 12/05/2021 23:28

Iv been lucky with mother in laws. DHs mum is lovely. Always been great and treated my older DD like the rest of her grandchildren. My ex mother in law was lovely to. She often pops around for a cuppa and chat to see DD. She is the only person on DDs dads side that has stayed in her life continuously and never lets her down

NotVeryChattySchoolMum · 12/05/2021 23:32

I get on with MIL better than my own opinionated mum who I love :)

  1. she is incredibly wise, patient and unassuming - soothing presence in any community she is in
  2. so supportive, without pushing views on parenting and takes mutual respect seriously
  3. adores grandkids
  4. I enjoy spending time with her

But relationship is two way too. I am quite a bit of people pleaser as well, so slotted in easily. My MIL was v patient and didn't show it but she did have harder time with other DIL who was more used to doing things her way and did bad job of hiding her disdain for lower middle class ways. (SIL is much nicer and humbler now, but she definitely had to go through some growth)

Heleavesreviews · 12/05/2021 23:44

Not overstepping is soooooo important.
I have seen my mil biting her tongue and I appreciate it!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread