Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

What do the Labour party need to do to stop their slow death?

632 replies

flashbac · 25/04/2021 10:34

I'll start:

Starmer needs to stop acting like a rabbit in the headlights and actually stand for something. He has no charisma or gravitas. We want someone with a personality. Stand for something Starmer!

Stop pandering to the 'red wall'. Inspire people to vote for the party with some good policies instead of flip flopping about.

Have some inspiring and uplifting policies like:

  • Free childcare for working parents
  • making public transport normal and affordable
  • subsidised green energy initiatives to help householders lower energy bills eg solar panels etc

And they NEED to distance themselves from that anti science TWAW stance. I'm all for being kind but a blanket dilution of what 'woman' means is regressive.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
BronwenFrideswide · 25/04/2021 20:55

you can't win anyone's vote by making them feel small or insignificant or stupid, even if they are

You were doing so well up until this last line TeacupDrama, perhaps stop sneering at and treating people you want to vote for you with such patronising contempt.

Graphista · 25/04/2021 20:59

The Labour Party emerged from the trade union movement to represent the economic interests of working people in Parliament. Now, it represents the cultural & ideological attitudes of an unrepresentative ‘woke’ middle-class metropolitan sect

I agree with this but I don't think it's a recent development it goes back to mid 90's and Blair etc

@MrsPeacockInTheLibrary I'm in Scotland, for the first time in my life I am seriously considering not voting. Will never vote Tory, Labour have long abandoned their traditional voters (working class, not woke!), SNP are being fuckwits on twaw, women's rights generally, Lib Dem's a combo of twaw and Tory lite with an appalling set of policies and voting record, I have literally no idea who to vote for!

I genuinely believe if Labour had the balls to come out as the anti-Brexit party when it would've made a bloody difference they could well have had a victory, they seemed to forget that the majority of those eligible to vote DIDN'T vote for Brexit and from a purely pragmatic point of view it was stupid not to capitalise on that. Yes previous Labour voters who were pro Brexit may have shifted to Tory but I strongly believe they'd have not only retained those who vote Labour and were anti Brexit but would have had a lot of people who were anti Brexit and either floating voters (like myself) or even normally Tory voters but strongly anti Brexit voting for them. They definitely missed a trick there from pure cowardice!

Unfortunately, this applies to all but right wing parties.

See this said SO MUCH on mn and it's just not true. Why do you think all this nonsense is happening while we have tories ruling? They started it all, and Lib Dem's (previously more centrist now most definitely to the right of centre) are also vehemently twaw its bloody all of them!

Keir absolutely needs to get off the fucking fence! The man has so many splinters up his arse he's practically turned into a tree!

They need to have people from genuine working class roots in not only the party but most especially the shadow cabinet/government level. Shocking how many of them have never done an honest days graft in their lives!

They need to get the papers on their side. It's the only way they will get anywhere. Policies etc don't really matter, it's all about the media.

Never had and never will happen because the papers are owned by wealthy, right wing people. The only time they came close was during Blair's first election campaign but that was because they correctly ascertained that new Labour was Tory lite

or for Mr Johnson to fuck up before the election Johnson has fucked up MANY times - sex scandals, Dv suspicion, corruption... all things that would previously have ended an MP's let alone a PM's career! He's fucking Teflon cos idiots buy that "bumbling Bozo boris" crap! Hell even priti Patel has got away with shit Mps pre say 2000 would NEVER have got away with and not been deselected! They're brazenly corrupt and they don't care.

My snp Mp is a good, sensible down to earth man who's done a lot of good here, but as a party they're a bloody mess!

I was never a huge TB fan and wish that John Smith hadn't died

Best PM we never had Sad my ex whom I had just met when this happened and was politically illiterate at this point was shocked at my tearful reaction, when he became more politically literate much later he understood it better.

Like many on the thread I think we need a new social Democratic Party that truly represents the working class and the genuinely oppressed people of this country - not privileged people who've "identified" themselves into an oppressed class. Who will address the real problems real people are having on a daily basis with health and social care, education, law and order, transport etc - not holding my breath though

Stasiland · 25/04/2021 21:02

There's an aspirational thing about voting tory - people feel they've made it, they are doing ok and are never going to be reliant on in work benefits. They can therefore feel ambivalent about voting for a party which will undoubtedly cut those benefits and lower taxes.
Labour can't win either way. The party is either full of m/c hand wringing liberal elite types (bit of an oxymoron there Confused) or benefit scroungers...

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

TeacupDrama · 25/04/2021 21:06

@Bronwenfrideswide you misunderstood me that was precisely my point (even if you think they are stupid which is what a lotof the elite labour party think) you don't sneer because that isn't how you win votes

I wasn't sneering at them I think their view is valid but even if you don't think it is not valid you will not get them to vote by making them feel you hold them in contempt for their views

FaceyRomford · 25/04/2021 21:10

@Eyevorbig0ne

Stop being the pseudo Tories.
Just the attitude that will get floating voters putting their "X" in the Labour box. Labour needs workable policies. What it offers is name calling of all those who do not agree 100% with the speaker's views.
Letsgetreadytocrumble · 25/04/2021 21:10

@AgeLikeWine

Next week, in Hartlepool, Labour are going to lose yet another ‘Red Wall’ seat to the Tories, and they are going to lose it badly. They will continue losing until they actually start listening to the people who live in such places.

The Labour Party emerged from the trade union movement to represent the economic interests of working people in Parliament. Now, it represents the cultural & ideological attitudes of an unrepresentative ‘woke’ middle-class metropolitan sect.

If Labour wants to win again it must start listening to the ordinary working people outside the M25 who it is supposed to represent. Lecturing and patronising white working class voters who feel ignored and abandoned about Trans rights or Palestine or the benefits of globalisation is not the route to success. Nor is sneering at their patriotism and desire for law & order, or telling them that the feral criminals who disrupt their communities are ‘marginalised victims’, or telling them that their concerns about unlimited immigration are racist.

This basically.

They have alienated their core electorate, and for what?

Plus I can't vote for a party who think that male rapists should go to a women's prison if they feel like it.

stackthecats · 25/04/2021 21:12

As other have said above. Its not rocket science. Stand up Starmer and look serious and decisive! And:

-- women's sex based rights. I'm a lifelong labour supporter and I'm veering towards voting tory if this rubbish doesn't stop. Never thought I'd see the day Sad
-- none of this shilling for pimps and punters. Dump all the decriminalise prostitution rubbish on the so-called "left" of the party. Prostituted sex with trafficked vulnerable women is not "sex work", and "sex work" is not like working in Tesco, even if you hate Tesco. You are a grade A idiot if you think decriminalising it is going to transform it into a lovely safe job with unionised benefits.
-- stop messing about with the gen Z identity politics. Your voters don't care about the rights of trans furries. Just sit down hard on the lunatic wing of the party which thinks pronouns are more important than anything else.
-- Childcare
-- Healthcare
-- Education
-- And ultimately HOUSING. Young and poor people can't afford to live or bring up their children in this country. House prices and rents are insane. Stop propping the fuckers up and start taxing the assets of profiteering landlords and rich old people.

There Keir, fixed your manifesto for you. Thank me later.

Stasiland · 25/04/2021 21:28

Fwiw Yougov found that labour's policies polled well during the 2019 campaign. What lost them the GE was Brexit and the leadership, namely Corbyn. Many of their policies have since been pilfered by the tories - green industrial revolution albeit heavily diluted, moving parts of the treasury to the north of England and the creation of a National infrastructure bank.
Don't know why Starmer is suddenly getting the hate, even from those who welcomed him over Corbyn.

stackthecats · 25/04/2021 21:37

Stasiland -- he's getting the hate because people thought as a lawyer and a sensible person, he might stand up for some kind of decent sensible centrism and rein in the lunatic TWAW/Owen Jones wing of the left. But he seems to have collapsed and has been barely visible since becoming leader. A real disappointment. Not that any of the other candidates would have been better. TBH Harriet Harman is more likely to have been the best leader we never got.

PronounssheRa · 25/04/2021 21:40

Don't know why Starmer is suddenly getting the hate

Sitting back and saying nothing while Rosie Duffield is getting a shit load of abuse is pretty high up on my 'why I think Starmer is a awful Labour leader' list.

TruelyWonder · 25/04/2021 21:41

@stackthecats

Stasiland -- he's getting the hate because people thought as a lawyer and a sensible person, he might stand up for some kind of decent sensible centrism and rein in the lunatic TWAW/Owen Jones wing of the left. But he seems to have collapsed and has been barely visible since becoming leader. A real disappointment. Not that any of the other candidates would have been better. TBH Harriet Harman is more likely to have been the best leader we never got.
Totally agree with this

Plus people stopped voting labour mostly because Corbyn was the leader. They have done surveys that said that. However since then the labour policies have also gone wacky too

dubyalass · 25/04/2021 21:46

For those of you who previously voted Labour but now vote or are considering voting Tory - why? Genuine question, not intended to be inflammatory or goady. I can't see myself voting Labour again (despite coming from staunch Labour background) but I would never vote Tory in a million years, I find them reprehensible.

BronwenFrideswide · 25/04/2021 21:49

[quote TeacupDrama]@Bronwenfrideswide you misunderstood me that was precisely my point (even if you think they are stupid which is what a lotof the elite labour party think) you don't sneer because that isn't how you win votes

I wasn't sneering at them I think their view is valid but even if you don't think it is not valid you will not get them to vote by making them feel you hold them in contempt for their views[/quote]
Sorry TeacupDrama, I totally misunderstood.

More to the point though, you shouldn't be holding them in contempt or sneering at them in the first place and that's a lesson the needs to be learnt on all sides of politics.

Letsgetreadytocrumble · 25/04/2021 21:51

The thing is, I do often wonder what it is in the wider world that is making Labour so unappealing right now. For me, its the misogyny, the tribal politics, the 'if you don't agree with me on everything you are an evil bigot' stance, and the ridiculous identity politics pandering. I know lots of people on MN feel the same, and obviously women's sex based rights are a huge thing in here and Labour are doing fuck all to make it look like they give a shit. And that's why I can't vote for them.

But in 'the real world' is that how lots of people feel? There is obviously something major stopping people wanting to vote for them. I guess it's different for different people as well?

Echobelly · 25/04/2021 21:54

Get one of the young women voted in during last election to be leader.

Need to take a strong line that what the Tories are doing to the country and the economy is unsustainable in every sense - make it clear to people who may be doing well for themselves under the Tories are ensuring a far worse world and worse prospects for their kids if they keep voting for them just because they are doing OK.

Stop being scared to ask for more tax from those who can afford it (yes, people like me) and from businesses that can afford it.

Stop parroting Tory 'tough on scroungers' bullshit and actually be clear that 'scroungers' are exceptionally rare - it's that businesses don't pay workers enough, and also that punitive benefits regimes are expensive and wasteful as well as cruel.

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 25/04/2021 21:57

Get rid of their no back bone Tory arse licking leader for a start. What's the use of an opposition that doesn't oppose anything their opposition does. Confused. Mind you no scratch Confused I'm more AngryAngry.

SirVixofVixHall · 25/04/2021 22:00

Labour are no longer the party for the working class and people who care about equality. They have become the party for the guilty privileged. The whole Momentum thing was like school playground politics. They knew that most people loathed Jeremy Corbin and his God complex, they must know that the majority of working class women very much know what a woman is, yet they persist . Starmer was on here trying to wriggle out of answering any questions on women’s rights ! When we are half the electorate !

BronwenFrideswide · 25/04/2021 22:06

Starmer was on here trying to wriggle out of answering any questions on women’s rights ! When we are half the electorate!

Yes that was a lamentable performance.

tanguero · 25/04/2021 22:08

Graphista Sun 25-Apr-21 20:59:25
'majority of those eligible to vote DIDN'T vote for Brexit'

And 'the majority of those eligible to vote', didn't vote to remain either - did they ? Another example of the arrogance - you didn't vote, but we'll assume your support anyway - of Labour's disconnect with its core support.

tobee · 25/04/2021 22:09

Understand what a woman is.

Realise there's fuck all point coming up with policies if no one is going to vote for you

tobee · 25/04/2021 22:11

They're probably fucked while Len McCluskey and his ilk are in charge of so much power.

Stop appealing to 18 year olds with blue hair

Stop shutting down debate

Justanotherlurker · 25/04/2021 22:17

The problem with labour is that they claim to be the vote of the working class, in true Orwell style they die hards have become uniroic orwell memes.

The red wall has fallen not because of the likes of the daily mail, but because the terminally online types have no self awerenss

Letsgetreadytocrumble · 25/04/2021 22:19

They have become the party for the guilty privileged.

Yes - the guilty privileged, that's exactly it!

BrilliantBetty · 25/04/2021 22:26

Admit they know what a woman is. And accept that those with female bodies (biologically) need sex segregated spaces sometimes.

Also, I work for a LA and the labour councillors that 'work' there are just pathetically shit. Compared to the tory councillors they are just ridiculously disorganised/ irrational / unintuitive... attempting to 'people please' but causing more of a mess and get nothing done. I'll never vote for them again.

ceilingsand · 25/04/2021 22:28

They need to develop some actual concrete principles and stop chasing what they think will be popular with the electorate.