[quote TisTheSeasonToEatLots]@Persipan why would you want to send your child out with cash to buy you a gift so you can pretend they bought you something? Children make things in school, Christmas cards, decorations etc for their parents as a present, I'm far more appreciative of this than a box of bubble bath my mate picked for me with my child in tow. My parents still put our tree decorations we made in primary school on the tree to this day and we are in our 30s and 40s!!! The best gifts you receive as a parent are the ones your child has made, when they are actually old enough to make them.[/quote]
Well right here, once again, we have the problem of the thread: people deciding that the thing they like trumps the thing someone else has straight-up said they'd enjoy.
For me, I love giving people presents, and I love those presents to be thoughtful and something that person would enjoy. That's not a skill you develop overnight; it's something you continue to hone over a lifetime. I'd like, to some extent, to instill that love (and that skill) in my child, if I can. When he's old enough to be writing to Santa I fully intend that his list will also include a suggestion of what kind of charity he'd like to support or what help he'd like to send to someone in need, as well as just stuff he wants for himself. (And then I'll make that happen for him, if I can.) I'll let him have some say in what gifts he gives to close family. And so yes, I'd also like him to choose something for me. Getting to give someone a present that you chose is a great feeling, done right, and it's worth ten quid to give him that experience. And over time, I'd hope to get him thinking about what gifts people will actually like (not me specifically, but all recipients of gifts) and how to judge and determine that. So hopefully he'll never end up in a story like this, as the hapless partner of a sad OP.
There's just as much of an argument that stuff made at school is impersonal, too, given that making it has been set up by the teacher and the thing being made has been predetermined by them. And yet yes, I'm sure I'll love those things too.