What is the ultimate sandwich toaster recipe?

[SquirtleSquad]

I've bought myself a deep fill sandwich toaster, what is the ultimate toasted sandwich / omelette / other sandwich toastable food!?

Nutella. It'll change your life

Cheese and marmite. Appreciate 50% of the population will baulk at that though!

Cheese and mash potato.

I find one ingredient + cheese with or without a condiment is the best formula.
Although mixing whatever is left over from a fried breakfast (usually some sausage, scrambled egg, mushrooms and beans) with some cheese and a little ketchup or brown sauce is pretty freaking amazing

@whitewineandmagnums I was just about to say cheese and marmite!

Ham, cheese and onion

Agree with pp, cheese and marmite with seeded bread.

Would marshmallows and Nutella work, I'm wondering . . .

Cheese and onion, occasionally with either mushroom, bacon or ham.

For the ultimate you need more than one variety of cheese. Eg layer of extra mature cheddar, onions, mozzarella, mushrooms, layer of Edam.

Both dc also love cheese & tomato purée with whatever leftovers are to hand for a pizza type toastie.

(FYI, we're all tiny and bird like and one toastie feeds all 4 of us for a week, we definitely don't eat two each or anything)

Savoury, tuna mayo and cheese.

Sweet, no need for bread. Make triangular cakes! One egg, 50g of sugar, flour and butter.

Leftover chilli or spag bol with cheese is also good.

Chicken, cheese and pesto

Baked beans and peanut butter

If you aren't a fan of butter then brush bread with olive oil instead.

Droooooooling

Can not wait to try these

OH goes mad for cheese and chorizo, I like cheese and tomato.

Apple. If you can be bothered, cook and purée some real apple yourself with a bit of sugar. If you can’t, buy tinned ‘pie filling’ apple. White bread. Dust liberally with icing sugar when cooked. Heaven.

Cheese and beans. Use the pre-grated cheddar/mozzarella cheese packs

Definitely cheese and marmite!

Smoked salmon and egg.

I love you all 🐷

Ham, cheese, mushrooms (no need to precook) and garlic salt
Brie and a bit of red currant jelly

Pah....now I’m really hungry!

There was an absolute humdinger of a thread about this a couple of years ago if you can be arsed to torture yourself with MNs absolutely terrible search function.

Boosted sales of toasters no end and had hundreds of ideas including cake!

If you Google cheese postie and look at images, you will see a ton of really great recipe idea cards. For some reason, since they shut down I can't find all the recipes on any website.
My kids are desperate for the Jaffa cake one.

I like mushrooms, corned beef and cheese with Tabasco. You can add thin slices of onion to this too if you wish.

I love cheese tuna and Mayo with cheese and onion crisps.

Strong cheddar and kimchi. Proper zingy and great for your guts.