Which coat is nicer?

[Lolita55]

This one in black:
onenationclothing.com/collections/outerwear/products/harper-luxe-quilted-longline-hooded-puffer-coat-with-faux-fur-trim-belt-in-black?variant=16444637904962

or this one in burgundy:
onenationclothing.com/collections/outerwear/products/mila-longline-quilted-hooded-puffer-coat-with-black-oversized-faux-fur-trim-half-belt-in-burgundy?variant=31208138440770

Feel free to suggest similar alternatives too (I am looking for something waterproof, with a hood and preferably has a cinched in waist and plenty of zippable pockets)

Thanks

The burgundy one, definitely. Looks nicer and such a beautiful colour. The black one looks cheaper.

thanks - more responses welcome :)

Burgundy

Burgundy definitely. It looks lovely and a nice length.
Not keen on the first one, I think there are quite a few different brands that all look the same it’s quite generic.

Burgundy for me too. Gorgeous colour!

Second one is nicer.

The burgundy style (longer) but in black!

The second one

Black. The burgundy is a strange shade and I don’t like the colour of the fur. Looks cheap.

Neither are waterproof.

I like the first one tbh but then I dress up less casual/sporty so the first one is more suitable.

I would choose the black one, but that's because I don't wear burgundy or any colours it goes with. Do you wear bottoms that would go with burgundy? Black seems more flexible.

Agree neither are waterproof.

bergundy one

Burgundy- far too much black around in winter, so a bit of colour is great

Are you able to try them on? I often find pics can be very deceptive and you wont know for sure till you try it on yourself.

Vote for the burgundy from me.
The black looks cheap despite the price.

Burgundy one is nicer, but neither are waterproof.