Which kitten heels?

[slithytove]

Asking for a friend who can’t decide
Which are nicer? Thicker strap or thinner strap?

Thick

Thin

Pic didn’t show, thin

The thin strap looks better but kitten heels always look pointlessly uncomfortably. Either go higher or go flat.

I prefer the thicker strap (and I'm not fat )

I love the thicker ones.

I like the thicker ones too

The thinner straps make her leg look a little more long & slender than the thicker strap ones. But both are very nice and would advise wearing the ones that are more comfortable.

No such thing as a flattering kitten heel but if I really had to choose I'd say thicker.

She isn’t fat! Haha
Thanks for the responses so far

I’ve been asked to give more context

Has to be a heel because she is 5 foot
It’s a holiday on a luxury train (v. Formal) so she can’t be tottering around in high heels

We're just moving this over to chat at the OP's request.

I'd say the thicker ones are better.

The answer is none, as ALL kitten heels are hideous.

What bitch queen said

Personally I think the ones with the thinner strap look more elegant and more formal.

The toe strap on the thin ones looks uncomfortable, as if it is too tight and the toes have been squashed in. It looks ok side on but not from the front. However I do think they look more formal than the thick ones.

I don't like either but thicker pair are marginally less hideous.

😂 agree
Kitten heels suck

Hive mind... what about these?

www.debenhams.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/prod_10701_10001_58605+06891701_-1

(Friend has said “fucking mumsnet, opinionated lot, now I have to return my kitten heels”) 😂😂

The higher heel is much better.

Yes, the latest Debenhams ones are nicer. Not too high, but more attractive than the kitten heels

Mn and kitten heels?
Christ almighty what's wrong with kitten heels? most mn'ers only wear flats. I love wearing heels and wear kittens for work all the time. any heel height is better than flats, mostly.

We are having a wobble
Heels need to be appropriate for walking through cape town so not too high! Need 4-5cm black straps sandals....

Back to the kitten heels we go