Which boots do I want???

[lucysmam]

I can't decide .

My friend says the black Barbour ones. The tan pair are very similar to the last pair of decent boots I had.

Someone make my mind up!

The Barbour ones look a funny shape... very wide at the top.
The brown ones are nice.

Second are really nice 

The Barbour ones look like pantomime boots. The brown ones are much nicer.

The black ones look very old lady to me I’m afraid.

Definitely the second ones.

Tan ones are much nicer than the black.

@SuperstarDJ , pantomime boots made me laugh. Do you really think so?

I much prefer the second pair.

I agree the first pair are a little Puss in Boots/Principal Boy.

Yes that's the word I was looking for - pantomime Boots!!

Definitely the second pair!

The first pair don't look long enough, the second pair are much more stylish.

The first pair are rather odd and frumpy. Are you sure your friend actually likes you?

The second pair are lovely.

I agree with the pp who wondered if your friend actually likes you! The black ones are weird. Brown ones all the way!

The black ones are awful, sorry! The second ones are much nicer.

Another vote for the second pair. What do they cost?

Second pair are lovely. @Tawdry is spot on with the Puss in Boots comment!

Brown gets my vote.

I really dislike mixing black and brown so dont like the band on 1st pair. Plus the bagginess of them seems bit 80s to me if im honnest.

If you have to purchase one, get the second. What would you wear them with?

Definitely the second pair, the other ones look very odd way to wide at the top yy dislike black & brown together.

The brown ones 😊

One's that fit.

Neither (but the brown if you must).