I think it's less ludicrous to thud over a character than over an actor, as the character is usually far more knowable than the actor. Slightly more crazy to thud over a person you don't even know.
Definitely agree with that, Twigs.
The swooning and thudding over the Man himself is understandable because he has a pretty face, decent body and lovely voice ::being deliberately understated here:: but no one knows anything more about him than what he chooses to share in interviews. The conviction on the crazy fan sites that he is their ideal man stems from them creating the idea of who he is in their heads so of course he fits the bill.
My Fantasy Richard never leaves the toilet seat up, puts his dirty clothes in the laundry basket, tidies up after himself, will mow the lawn without being nagged for the previous 2 weeks and knows a dirty plate belongs in the dishwasher instead of the sink. Oh, and he wipes his toast crumbs up when he makes his lunch.
Those are attributes I wish for in my ideal man but I doubt Real Richard does have those attributes because 95% of the men I know certainly don't. It's all projection, isn't it?