Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AMA

I'm a practising Muslim, ask me anything...

216 replies

tt9 · 02/06/2023 12:20

For context, I am late 30s female practising Muslim medical professional and have been practising for most of my adult life (to varying degrees).

Feel like a lot of people have questions that they don't ask as they fear causing offence. also there are some commonly held beliefs regarding muslims/Islam that are urban myths... so ask away. no question too offensive

OP posts:
tt9 · 10/06/2023 23:40

BenandGerrys · 09/06/2023 20:40

As a medical professional do you agree with this article by a Muslim Cleric which says that circumcision should be done for both males and females?

https://islamqa.info/en/answers/9412/circumcision-in-islam-compulsory

I have to tell you this fills me with absolute rage. this practice is not permitted in Islam. this 'scholar' is a salafi by the look of it. salafism is a sect that has broken off from mainstream Islam and 'inspired' crazy people such as the taliban and Al qaeda. unfortunately saudi oil money has been used to spread their version of 'islam' across the world.

any kind of body mutilation is forbidden. male circumcision is prescribed and has a lot of health benefits. FGM (because its not circumcision it is mutillation) is extremely harmful and makes intercourse torturous and childbirth life threatening. I have had to deal with patients in the delivery suite with FGM, and it was so awful.

islamic teachings encourage both men and women to fulfil their partners need for intimacy. men specifically are given guidance on this.

i mean essentially FGM is child abuse. most of the time it is done without anaesthetic and with dirty implements. little girls die from infection and bleeding... or later when giving birth. interestingly it is a practice perpetrated and perpetuated by women (often the girl's mother). it's essentially a passing down of trauma from one generation to the next.

OP posts:
tt9 · 11/06/2023 00:01

mids2019 · 10/06/2023 11:38

Do Muslims as a whole support our armed forces as defenders of our security and state interests? one local (and unfair) criticism of Muslim communities is lack of presence in such community events such as remembrance day and poppy wearing.

I suppose a parallel question is what are Muslim thoughts about history in UK schools being dominated by UK history which ultimately has a Christian cultural influence e.g. the reformation, formation of the CofE, conflict between Protestantism and Catholicism? Similarly literature in English schools is dominate by the titans of British literature (Shakepeare, Dickens, Milton etc.) so would you think Muslims would like our curricula to extend towards literature from Islamic cultures and the history of such regions as Saudi Arabia?

thank you for your question :-)

First thing to mention perhaps is that Muslims come from all over the world, including being white British, so would have differing views. and no one can speak as to views of "Muslims as a whole". also, Muslims were part of the British army in a massive way in both world wars as well as many muslims serving in recent history.

currently, there is a feeling in both Muslim and non Muslim communities that the UK government went into two unjustified wars that resulted in millions of Muslims dying and the whole of the Middle East + Afghanistan being destabilised. So there is a reluctance understably to be part of armed forces events. i realise that young soldiers didn't choose to go to war and many lost their lives/were injured. which only adds to the tragedy of the whole thing. the people that decide to go to war are funnily the least affected by it. maybe if we started sending prime ministers to the front line, there would less armed conflict?

tbh I feel like wearing a poppy is a bit of an own goal. allows us all to pretend we care, and we feel we have done our bit so we stop thinking about it. in the meantime, we have veterans on the streets, veterans who have come back with PTSD and not getting any support, disabled veterans who are starving etc.

I don't think Muslims as a whole have a view on the type of history being taught. definitely a lot of the content varies from school to school. I don't think there are any strong views on this. I personally feel it would be good to have more modern history, world history (with bits of history of all main religions) and maybe some stuff about colonialism. but that's a personal opinion.

OP posts:
mids2019 · 11/06/2023 07:35

@tt9

Thank you for the reply.

I think this does chime with my own experience in that there is divided opinion on some of the wars we have participated in.

I do feel the poppy is important as the second world war ensured the freedoms that we all enjoy in our democracy and I actually feel it can be something that binds us a nation whilst giving respect to those millions diagnosis down their lives for freedom.

Personally I feel having more Muslims in our armed services would be a good thing as the armed forces should represent the whole of UK society as quite simply the defence of the UK is in all society's interests.

Action in Afghanistan was taken to prevent the. environment that allowed 9/11 and so many would argue there was a legitimate use of force in our national interest.

What is needed to recruit more Muslims into our armed forces (and police for that matter) of both sexes?

mids2019 · 11/06/2023 07:43

The history question is an interesting one as I have heard that some are arguing that the current history curriculum doesn't cover the history of some immigrant groups to the extent they would like. An example would be of someone of Afro Carribean descent learning about Henry 8th, Mediaeval monarchs etc. and being bettered as it was 'not their history'. I was thinking with many Muslims being immigrants whether a similar perspective prevails?

I suppose an expansion on the question is whether Islamic faith schools should be increased in number to ensure curricula sensitive to the local community. Due to history and demography in my town we have C of E schools with significant numbers of Muslims with a Christian ethos and associated teaching. I think there is a question of sustainability in those model.

mids2019 · 11/06/2023 07:47

Deterred not bettered......bloody autocorrect

tt9 · 11/06/2023 16:58

BenandGerrys · 11/06/2023 14:57

Thank you for your reply to my previous question.

What is your opinion on Non-stun Slaughter ?

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/oct/12/what-is-non-stun-slaughter-and-how-is-it-treated-in-uk-law

hey, thank you so much for your question. halal slaughter is a very complex topic, and one that has divided opinion amongst islamic scholars. mild stunning which makes the animal unconscious is fine. where the scholars differ is that some say the voltage used is too high and there is a high likelihood of animals being killed hence it shouldn't be used. I eat stunned halal meat myself but some in my friend circle do not.

however.... and this is much more important than the above (and often something Muslims conveniently forget) - the animals have to be well treated and not suffer at all during their upbringing or slaughter. hence the method of halal slaughter is to quickly sever the carotid artery so as to remove oxygen supply to the brain. animals are not even allowed to be slaughtered in front of other animals. pregnant animals cannot be slaughtered. there are a myriad other such rules. added to this, Muslims have a huge responsibility to the planet and as such should behave in a manner that doesn't cause harm eg. intensive farming. our generation of Muslims are becoming more aware and there are now a few options for free range/organic/grass fed/ethically slaughtered animal products... but very difficult to access.

generally animal slaughter by both Muslim and non Muslim organisations is abyssmal. absolutely disgusting. as I am sure you are probably aware, the stunning often isn't adequate and/or extremely traumatic (remember we used to give humans ect without Anaesthesia and it was awful) not to mention the mechanical slaughter process (which Muslims aren't allowed to use incidentally) can cause horrible injuries. tbh I'm looking forward to the day, where people mainly eat meat alternatives.

OP posts:
tt9 · 11/06/2023 17:29

mids2019 · 11/06/2023 07:35

@tt9

Thank you for the reply.

I think this does chime with my own experience in that there is divided opinion on some of the wars we have participated in.

I do feel the poppy is important as the second world war ensured the freedoms that we all enjoy in our democracy and I actually feel it can be something that binds us a nation whilst giving respect to those millions diagnosis down their lives for freedom.

Personally I feel having more Muslims in our armed services would be a good thing as the armed forces should represent the whole of UK society as quite simply the defence of the UK is in all society's interests.

Action in Afghanistan was taken to prevent the. environment that allowed 9/11 and so many would argue there was a legitimate use of force in our national interest.

What is needed to recruit more Muslims into our armed forces (and police for that matter) of both sexes?

hiya, first of all, I respect your perspective. but just wanted to mention a few things and we may have to agree to disagree. the poppy is a symbol of the fallen soldiers in WW1, not WW2. you can check out the Royal Legion website, which describes it in more detail.

I think wars are often romanticised by countries... perhaps as a way of dealing with the trauma? WWI was a result of the heavy handed response of the Allies to a not very significant assassination and really was an excuse to "put Germany in it's place" as the Allies were threatened by its rapid rise following the unification of Germany in the late 1800s. Remember European nations have always fought each other, this was just a new excuse. sadly due to advances in technology, it led to huge numbers dying... mainly young men from lower socio-economic classes.

WW2 was a direct result of too harsh reparations imposed on Germany by the Allies. this allowed Hitler to come to power. To romanticise the above history and simplify it so we can be "proud of winning the world wars" is not very accurate in my mind. the Allies also committed some war crimes eg. Russians carrying out total destruction and mass rape in certain German cities following the war and not to forget Hiroshima and Nagasaki. in war, both sides ultimately lose. the best war is the one not fought.

Afghanistan as a use of legitimate force? the only people that were harmed were civilians. millions of children died. not to mention the taliban were put in place by the Americans during the cold War to push back the Russians and Osama bin Laden was following Wahabism which was instituted in Saudi Arabia by the British in order to push out the Ottomans in the early 1900s. the taliban are back in Afghanistan, no worse off for the war. the women are just as oppressed. and now, the whole country is much worse off. they were just about surviving before the war. if you really think its a legitimate use of force, I recommend perhaps to do some reading (not mass media) on the impact of war in Afghanistan and neocolonialism. In terms of the terrorism... if anything it made things worse! Britain only suffered terrorist attacks the war started, not before. the war gave fresh fodder to terrorist recruiters. and together with the Iraq war, it led to the formation of ISIS.

let's not forget that largest group of victims of this sort of terrorism are Muslims. the taliban are killing Muslims. isis is killing Muslims. attacking those who are already facing all of this can only make things worse. and also let's not forget that the armies who have had real success against these terrorist groups such as the SDF and the Turkish army are locally based. fighting a complex war, on an unknown and difficult terrain by heavy handed tactics by a foreign army trained to fight in northern europe was never going to work. and finally it was a colossal waste of money. if only that money was given to the NHS, think of how many would have benefitted.

tbh Muslims in this country have always joined the army. but after these two wars, it will take a long time before most Muslims will consider the army as a career. I have to point out that Muslims have very severe restrictions as to when they are permitted to go to war and are absolutely forbidden to kill any civilians, to destroy any crops/property. so this restricts truly practising Muslims from joining the army (in pretty much any country in the modern day).

the lack of Muslims in the police force is more due to widespread racism as we are aware. also certain cultures/ethnicities push their children towards more academic professions eg medicine which might also be a factor.

sorry I couldn't provide you with any solutions.

OP posts:
tt9 · 11/06/2023 17:35

mids2019 · 11/06/2023 07:43

The history question is an interesting one as I have heard that some are arguing that the current history curriculum doesn't cover the history of some immigrant groups to the extent they would like. An example would be of someone of Afro Carribean descent learning about Henry 8th, Mediaeval monarchs etc. and being bettered as it was 'not their history'. I was thinking with many Muslims being immigrants whether a similar perspective prevails?

I suppose an expansion on the question is whether Islamic faith schools should be increased in number to ensure curricula sensitive to the local community. Due to history and demography in my town we have C of E schools with significant numbers of Muslims with a Christian ethos and associated teaching. I think there is a question of sustainability in those model.

I definitely feel the curriculum can be more diverse. but not to promote inclusion, but more because I feel all children should have the opportunity to learn about the history of the whole world and not just of the country they are in.

I don't really have an opinion on faith based schools. I went to a methodist school and had no issues. Christian ethos is very similar to Muslim ethos, so I don't see a problem with Muslims attending C of E schools.

OP posts:
WhatWhereWho · 11/06/2023 18:33

I would ask this to any religious person not just Muslims. Why do you believe in god? How do you reconcile yourself to all the evil and pain in the world? An omnipotent deity creates it all and is responsible for it. That makes it a deeply unpleasant and cruel being does n't it? As a believing person you worship the being responsible for all that misery. Again those are questions I would ask of any faith.

DevonHills23 · 11/07/2023 12:41

What does it mean "i do not practice traditionally but I may practice symbolically " mean for a Muslim? In context the individual's mother is actually Christian and European and his father Muslim and Middle Eastern parents divorced and he neither feels either half European or half Middle Eastern, he has been married before to someone that then chose to convert her religion but it did not work out, dont think he is at the age he wants kids but met at an online social event, am the same nationality as his mum and somewhat confused if it is a friend thing or not. I am not sure what a sufi orientation means but gather he is open minded but am not sure if the symbolic practice means avoiding alcohol, pork, abstaining sexually or what and am not sure if it is even appropriate to ask....thoughts? I am more spiritual than religious and find myself strangely attracted to this person though am not sure if it is doomed from the start...

MarleneH · 15/07/2023 21:45

Hi lovely I have msg you x

Zanatdy · 15/07/2023 22:31

What is it about dogs that many Muslims don’t like? I’ve noticed that my children’s Muslim family don’t like my dog near them, and my ex said it was something in the Quran. Cats they are fine with, but dogs no. Interested in a proper explanation as my ex brushed over it

EmpressaurusOfCats · 15/07/2023 23:16

50450750q · 02/06/2023 14:28

What's the significance of the term "same sex attracted people" and not gay or bisexual people? Is it an islamic thing? I've heard a similar phrase from Christians who think gay people should still marry the opposite sex.

An increasing number of lesbian & gay people, me included, are using this for clarity because of the push by various dodgy organisations to make being LGB all about ‘gender’ instead.

EmpressaurusOfCats · 15/07/2023 23:17

Sorry to derail OP - thanks for a fascinating thread!

tt9 · 16/07/2023 17:00

Hi guys, oh my gosh, completely missed the responses until today, will get right on it :-)

OP posts:
tt9 · 16/07/2023 17:10

Zanatdy · 15/07/2023 22:31

What is it about dogs that many Muslims don’t like? I’ve noticed that my children’s Muslim family don’t like my dog near them, and my ex said it was something in the Quran. Cats they are fine with, but dogs no. Interested in a proper explanation as my ex brushed over it

we don't dislike dogs (some Muslims might, can't speak for every one). but dogs' saliva is considered 'impure'. now before dog lovers jump down my throat. remember dogs' saliva transmit rabies and dogs can be asymptomatic while carrying rabies. and islamic laws are for all people for all time. so where pet dogs in this country may not carry rabies, in most of the world dogs are not well cared for/vaccinated. many Muslims keep dogs, but we keep them outside so often Muslims who live in colder countries don't have them. I had lovely dogs as a child when I lived in bangladesh. I would go out and play/cuddle with them and then come in and wash up.

OP posts:
tt9 · 16/07/2023 17:32

WhatWhereWho · 11/06/2023 18:33

I would ask this to any religious person not just Muslims. Why do you believe in god? How do you reconcile yourself to all the evil and pain in the world? An omnipotent deity creates it all and is responsible for it. That makes it a deeply unpleasant and cruel being does n't it? As a believing person you worship the being responsible for all that misery. Again those are questions I would ask of any faith.

Hi, I am so sorry that this took so long! I completely missed your post. Thank you for your questions.

  1. I gave a pretty detailed explanation earlier in the thread about why I believe in God.. but here is a short version. As I grew up and looked around me, and studied science - it became more and more clear that the only logical explanation is that there must be Creator. and when I studied different religions, Islam is the only one that made sense to me. But as well as the logical conclusions, I certainly felt a connection to something greater.
  2. Most of the bad things that happen on this are done by humans. In the Quran, it is written that the angels questioned God when humans were created saying "humans will wreak havoc on earth". But God replied "I know what you know not". Humans have the potential to be the best of the best and the worst of the worst. we are given free will to decide what we want to be and this allows for a process of self realisation and connection to the Divine.
In terms of 'bad things' that happen outside our control: if we look at our time on this earth or our corporeal experience as all there is then of course it appears catastrophic. But suffering be it due to humans or otherwise, is a part of our lived experience. this world is a place of transformation, our souls come into it to be shaped and elevated and our bodies are the vessels for that. Hazrat Rumi says that gold to be smelted, needs fire (I am paraphrasing). this world is the fire. of course I understand that this may be difficult to accept and many people of faith also struggle to accept this. not sure if I have answered your question... feel free to pick me up on any points I haven't addressed :-)
OP posts:
tt9 · 16/07/2023 17:33

EmpressaurusOfCats · 15/07/2023 23:17

Sorry to derail OP - thanks for a fascinating thread!

glad you are enjoying it :-) love your username, wish I had thought of it!

OP posts:
Zanatdy · 16/07/2023 18:23

tt9 · 16/07/2023 17:10

we don't dislike dogs (some Muslims might, can't speak for every one). but dogs' saliva is considered 'impure'. now before dog lovers jump down my throat. remember dogs' saliva transmit rabies and dogs can be asymptomatic while carrying rabies. and islamic laws are for all people for all time. so where pet dogs in this country may not carry rabies, in most of the world dogs are not well cared for/vaccinated. many Muslims keep dogs, but we keep them outside so often Muslims who live in colder countries don't have them. I had lovely dogs as a child when I lived in bangladesh. I would go out and play/cuddle with them and then come in and wash up.

Thanks for explaining. Can I ask what the difference is with cats, as I assume they can transmit rabies too. That’s what I struggled to understand as they have cats living in their home and I wondered why a cats saliva is different. I thought there was something in the Quran about a dog’s saliva, but I might have completely made that up in my head! I’ve been asked a few times lately because my children can no longer have their pet dog at their dad’s home due to his new wife not wanting him around her (she’s a Muslim, so is my ex, but he’s not a strict Muslim and has never had a problem with the dog so I had no idea there was an issue until more recently). Thanks for explaining, I certainly wouldn’t jump down your throat, I totally understand people are raised with different rules / belief’s etc, I just wanted to understand it a bit more in my own mind and the difference with dogs / cats.

tt9 · 16/07/2023 18:37

Zanatdy · 16/07/2023 18:23

Thanks for explaining. Can I ask what the difference is with cats, as I assume they can transmit rabies too. That’s what I struggled to understand as they have cats living in their home and I wondered why a cats saliva is different. I thought there was something in the Quran about a dog’s saliva, but I might have completely made that up in my head! I’ve been asked a few times lately because my children can no longer have their pet dog at their dad’s home due to his new wife not wanting him around her (she’s a Muslim, so is my ex, but he’s not a strict Muslim and has never had a problem with the dog so I had no idea there was an issue until more recently). Thanks for explaining, I certainly wouldn’t jump down your throat, I totally understand people are raised with different rules / belief’s etc, I just wanted to understand it a bit more in my own mind and the difference with dogs / cats.

yes although both cats and dogs can get rabies, 99% of human infections are due to dogs (according to the World Health Organisation). maybe because the disease progresses faster in cats? and cats tend to scratch rather than bite? but your guess is as good as mine as to the reasons.
cat saliva is antibacterial as well (this is irrelevant to the rabies question) and they generally are cleaner animal. but that's a separate point.

wasn't expecting you to jump down my throat lol but I can imagine how a dog lover reading my post can become offended and get the wrong end of the stick.

I guess in your situation, I would keep the doggie away. if their stepmum has not grown up with dogs, she might also be scared? plenty of Muslims I know in this country are terrified of dogs just because they haven't ever interacted with them. funnily, not the case in Muslim majority countries as people commonly keep them.

OP posts:
Jongleterre · 16/07/2023 18:38

How do you feel about pet dogs or pets in general.

tt9 · 16/07/2023 18:42

@Zanatdy sorry to keep ranting on... just to emphasise the point that Muslims should not 'dislike' dogs and have to treat them with kindness as with ALL living beings/the environment- there is the story of a lady who had lived her life in sin... and one day she passed a well with a very thirsty dog next to it. she filled her slippers with water and gave it to the dog and its life was saved. because of this one act of kindness, all her sins were forgiven and she entered her afterlife in a state of grace. we believe that animals also pray for us, so we will be rewarded for their good treatment and punished for ill treating them.

OP posts:
Guineapigwoes · 16/07/2023 18:49

This is such an interesting thread op. Does the Quran/your culture say that drugs are prohibited the same as alcohol?
There seems to be a big issue with kids taking laughing gas and getting harmed in car accidents and I wondered how the community would react to this?

Zanatdy · 16/07/2023 18:53

tt9 · 16/07/2023 18:42

@Zanatdy sorry to keep ranting on... just to emphasise the point that Muslims should not 'dislike' dogs and have to treat them with kindness as with ALL living beings/the environment- there is the story of a lady who had lived her life in sin... and one day she passed a well with a very thirsty dog next to it. she filled her slippers with water and gave it to the dog and its life was saved. because of this one act of kindness, all her sins were forgiven and she entered her afterlife in a state of grace. we believe that animals also pray for us, so we will be rewarded for their good treatment and punished for ill treating them.

Sorry I didn’t mean to imply all Muslims dislike dogs as my ex’s family definitely do not dislike my dog. They just don’t want one living in their home, which is obviously not religious linked always anyway. I was just interested in the background around it, and why dogs over other animals. Thanks for explaining

Swipe left for the next trending thread