Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

My formerly estranged brother has transitioned and wants back in mine and my mother’s lives.

213 replies

Rimding · 14/10/2026 14:50

I will preface this with the fact that I do not believe that humans can change sex in any meaningful way and I find men appropriating the female experience profoundly offensive.

I have two toddlers and I don’t know how to move forward with this. My mother feels she has to accommodate his name/pronoun changes because she worries about his mental health and doesn’t want to be cut off, despite not buying in to the whole trans ideology.

I don’t know how to approach a discussion with him re his new identity and my personal beliefs and boundaries. I am not going to lie to my children and say he’s their Auntie or use his frankly ridiculous new name. I will not describe him or his female partner as lesbians.

For background his behaviour towards other family members in the past has been callous and personally I’m not too bothered if I ever have a close relationship with him again but it must be at least functional for my mother’s sake. Whether I like it or not he’s back in our lives and I have to navigate it. Advice or just any experience of the situation welcome.

OP posts:
Whatshitnow · 14/10/2026 16:16

I'd be avoiding him like the plague. Wouldn't even entertain the suggestion of any "discussions" Your mum can make her own mind up. Don't get drawn into anything you don't want to. Keep your life calm and drama free.

Summerstuff · 14/10/2026 16:17

GreyskySexRealistsky · 14/10/2026 16:16

This is the very opposite of drama, providing she keeps her cool.

She's allowed to have boundaries and state them clearly.

No. The very opposite of drama is to be civil, not expose her children to him and just be there for her mother.

Rimding · 14/10/2026 16:18

alcovecupboards · 14/10/2026 15:13

You don't have to have a relationship with anyone you don't want to. You have no right to dictate who your mother has a relationship with. It's really that simple.

I’m not dictating anything, I support my mum. I was asking if anyone had experience of navigating a similar situation because it is not something I ever thought I’d experience. I concède my post isn’t super clear on this, my bad.

OP posts:
Summerstuff · 14/10/2026 16:18

Whatshitnow · 14/10/2026 16:16

I'd be avoiding him like the plague. Wouldn't even entertain the suggestion of any "discussions" Your mum can make her own mind up. Don't get drawn into anything you don't want to. Keep your life calm and drama free.

Exactly

and having some kind of showdown with him is ridiculous. He’s not going to listen and take on board is be. Just drama and squawking.

nicepotoftea · 14/10/2026 16:19

As with any relationship, you can set your own boundaries, but he can also choose not to have a relationship with you.

Summerstuff · 14/10/2026 16:19

You have toddlers and you have been estranged for years. So your kids have not even met him. Keep it like that.

Nihongo · 14/10/2026 16:21

Sounds like he only wants involvement now so that he can bask in the validation of having you use his new ladyname etc etc.

I honestly wouldn’t bother with him, keep away from the drama. He hasn’t suddenly morphed into a wonderful person..

nicepotoftea · 14/10/2026 16:22

For background his behaviour towards other family members in the past has been callous

Is this not also a potential problem?

brownbootsandhats · 14/10/2026 16:24

Yes that does sound hard

its all very well who you have in your own home , but there will be family occasions that your mother would like both of you there

sorry nothing helpful other than I understand.

Rimding · 14/10/2026 16:25

Summerstuff · 14/10/2026 16:18

Exactly

and having some kind of showdown with him is ridiculous. He’s not going to listen and take on board is be. Just drama and squawking.

I was going for more open and honest statement of my position rather than a dramatic showdown. The intention was clarity not trying to change his mind or attack his beliefs. As i’ve said i’m thinking this through for the first time and saying absolutely nothing is an attractive option.

OP posts:
GreyskySexRealistsky · 14/10/2026 16:26

Yes, do remember not to "squawk" OP

LowlandLucky · 14/10/2026 16:27

Why should you have him back in your life if he has been an obnoxious twunt in the past? Tell you mother that you are not in the sliightest bit interested in having any relationship with him. Remind her your feelings matter too and that she shouldn't be expecting you to whitewash the past.

Summerstuff · 14/10/2026 16:28

Rimding · 14/10/2026 16:25

I was going for more open and honest statement of my position rather than a dramatic showdown. The intention was clarity not trying to change his mind or attack his beliefs. As i’ve said i’m thinking this through for the first time and saying absolutely nothing is an attractive option.

But what did you expect from him?

I don’t even know him but from what you describe - massive drama ensued.

You have had no relationship with him for years so just keep at a distance and be civil

Rimding · 14/10/2026 16:28

nicepotoftea · 14/10/2026 16:22

For background his behaviour towards other family members in the past has been callous

Is this not also a potential problem?

Yes I personally don’t like him very much for his past behaviour but equally I’m not going to be callous towards him. Very clear to me now my original post is insufficient! 😅

OP posts:
Summerstuff · 14/10/2026 16:28

GreyskySexRealistsky · 14/10/2026 16:26

Yes, do remember not to "squawk" OP

There won’t be any squawking if the Op doesn’t have a full and frank discussion about her thoughts and boundaries!

AralVorkosigan · 14/10/2026 16:33

So this is not somebody you want in your life, regardless of the trans stuff?

I’d be civil but distant - sort of like you would with an acquaintance that you don’t much like and don’t want to become friends with. Think of him as one of your mum’s faintly annoying friends from church (or bingo, or whatever it is she might do that doesn’t involve you!).

For the sake of your mum it’s good if you can avoid drama or actually cutting him off in a big row, but there’s no need for you to have him in your life or have your kids around him.

If challenged on him wanting more time with you, wanting to see your kids etc, I would just say that given the history between the two of you, you’re taking things slowly, and at the moment this is the amount of contact you’re happy with. Don’t make big pronouncements they can argue with, and leave it open that if he behaves well then in future the relationship may improve.

Never never get dragged into a conversation about the trans stuff, because if you do not completely toe the line he will likely get explosive and cause a huge row.

You can use his chosen name (I think people are allowed to choose their own names however much you don’t like their choice!) and avoid using any pronouns. If he notices you’re not using he/she, just say you don’t want to get it wrong so it’s easier to use his name.

If directly asked for your views on the trans stuff you can simply respond that you know it’s a controversial topic, it’s obviously important to him, and in the interests of family unity and building your relationship you don’t want to get into any big debates.

FWIW I have a sibling I don’t like, and tolerate occasionally in the interests of family harmony. If they came out as trans I’d roll my eyes, but it wouldn’t change anything about our existing relationship.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 14/10/2026 16:33

Hope you find a way, OP.

@RedToothBrush is the poster with brother experience IIRC. Hopefully she will see this thread.

SpryCat · 14/10/2026 16:34

Your brother has been estranged from you and mum and wants to have a relationship with you all but you don’t like him as he’s awful.
He is transgender now and you want to support your mum.
You can make it clear you do not want a relationship with him, you do not want him in your children’s lives.
You can’t support your mum with accepting he is transgender because you don’t believe in it.
Your only option is to stay away when he goes round because your mum wants to have a relationship with him and let her accept him being transgender by herself because it will break down if you are involved.

OneNewEagle · 14/10/2026 16:36

Try the stately homes threads, we are all very supportive as NC or LC with our families or only certain members.

in this case support your mum but don’t have anything to do with the estranged person. Think about yourself and your kids.

PinkPhonyClub · 14/10/2026 16:36

Hmm. Ok. Well I would start here - you have a callous sibling you dislike to the extent you went no contact. So what has changed? Unless sibling is claiming their gender identity was the reason they were an awful person’s md now they are their true selves they are delightful, the transition is pretty much a red herring?

Sibling can want what they want but that doesn’t mean you have to agree to contact. That sounds by far the easiest solution.

Rimding · 14/10/2026 16:36

GreyskySexRealistsky · 14/10/2026 16:26

Yes, do remember not to "squawk" OP

?

OP posts:
murasaki · 14/10/2026 16:37

alcovecupboards · 14/10/2026 15:13

You don't have to have a relationship with anyone you don't want to. You have no right to dictate who your mother has a relationship with. It's really that simple.

Alcove is right.

Tell your mother you're happy for her to have a relationship with him, you won't be talking about him to her, you'll be polite when you see him (no need for names or pronouns if you're in the same room speaking to him), and you will be choosing when to visit if he is there (possibly less than usual) and the kids may or may not be available (they won't).

GreyskySexRealistsky · 14/10/2026 16:37

Rimding · 14/10/2026 16:36

?

A previous poster mentioned "drama and squawking". It sounded a bit odd.

aCatCalledFawkes · 14/10/2026 16:37

Rimding · 14/10/2026 16:25

I was going for more open and honest statement of my position rather than a dramatic showdown. The intention was clarity not trying to change his mind or attack his beliefs. As i’ve said i’m thinking this through for the first time and saying absolutely nothing is an attractive option.

But it could turn into a dramatic showdown, you haven't seen him in years, now he's living as a woman and the first thing you want to do is to clarify what you think about his situation? Why would he respect that? I think not saying anything in this case would be a lot better.

AIiswatchingyou · 14/10/2026 16:37

Just keep him as you have previously - estranged.

The best you can do for your mum is listen patiently to her as she discusses what is going on.

Your example of not engaging might actually show her that she too can step back if she wants to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread