Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Darlington Nurses" vs County Durham and Darlington NHS Trust Tribunal Thread 9

432 replies

ThreeWordHarpy · 16/01/2026 12:36

Thread 1, 7-Oct to 23-Oct
Thread 2, 23-Oct to 28-Oct
Thread 3, 28-Oct to 29-Oct
Thread 4, 29-Oct to 31-Oct
Thread 5, 31-Oct to 04-Nov
Thread 6, 04-Nov to 05-Nov
Thread 7, 05-Nov to 11-Nov
Thread 8, 11-Nov to 16-Jan (last thread with the schedule and abbreviations)

Five nurses working at Darlington Memorial Hospital filed a legal case against their employer, an NHS trust, for sexual harassment and sex discrimination. The nurses objected to sharing the women’s changing facilities with a male colleague, Rose, who identifies as female. The hearing was held between 20th October and 11th November and was live tweeted by Tribunal Tweets who have comprehensive information regarding this case on their substack, including archives of the twitter threads, lists of people involved and press releases.

At the time this thread was started, the judgment had not yet been published on the Courts website but was widely reported in the media that the NHS was found to have discriminated against the nurses, but the claims against Rose were not upheld.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
ProfessorBinturong · 22/01/2026 11:12

Cross posted. If you don't think any paperwork is needed, and are only proposing including gender ideology in the EA belief protection, that requires no legislative change. The EA doesn't set out a list of protected beliefs with definitions.

Someone simply has to bring a legal case - as Forstater did for GC belief - showing that GI belief meets the Grainger tests. This is for a believer to do, not government.

ProfessorBinturong · 22/01/2026 11:08

FWSsupporter · 22/01/2026 08:52

I agree she should not have been able to change sex. But I am saying gender identity should be a belief that is protected.

Once you are clear sex is real and immutable and no one can change sex having gender identity as a belief pc is a reasonable option. I do not think it is realistic to think we can eradicate everything e.g the GRA and gender reassignment pc.

I appreciate your point of view as it has been awful for women who have lost jobs, careers and been subjected to vile abuse. However, there is a small core of people who have also been harmed by TRAs and that are those who are not activists but have gender dysphoria. I don’t want it to be legal to not give them a job or to provide a service just because they have gender dysphoria.

As Emmy said, you're still mixing up 2 (or 3) totally separate things - and 2 bits of legislation - and therefore proposing incoherent measures that you can't explain a need for.

Someone can hold a belief in 'gender identity' as a concept regardless of whether or not they believe they personally are 'trans'. Believing in gender ideology doesn't require having a gender identity. They may simply believe that some other people have one. The EA already protects people from being fired for their beliefs. No other belief gets any sort of government certificate. Why should this one?

Gender dysphoria/dysmorphia is a mental health condition related to other dysmorphias such as anorexia and people who believe they have the 'wrong' number of limbs. These may count as disabilities under the EA, but one of the people with other dysmorphias get a special category all of their own and a certificate. Why should this particular dysmorphia be treated differently?

Gender reassignment already has its own category (very poorly defined - that needs fixing) in the EA. The EA doesn't provide a mechanism for certificating this category. The GRA does, but does so by overriding the documentation of sex, because it was brought in as a stupid fudge to comply with European human rights law without allowing same-sex marriage. Now that we do have same-sex marriage the GRA has no practical effect other than making it impossible to check someone's sex.

I agree with you that the confusion over documentation of sex needs reversing. But you've not made a case for why documentation of gender is needed at all. You're starting from the assumption that it does, but why?

FWSsupporter · 22/01/2026 10:55

@EmmyFr I am saying keep Gender reassignment pc making it clear you can’t change sex and add gender identity belief as part of the existing Religion and Belief pc. It would obviously include not having a GI and the right not to be discriminated against for not believing in GI.

I am not wedded to the actual words used to describe GI belief that is for those who write the legislation to consult on and decide.

@MistyGreenAndBlue is god real?

MarieDeGournay · 22/01/2026 10:33

EmmyFr · 22/01/2026 10:17

No no no ! She knows she's a woman because that's her gender. She's unsure about her sex (aren't we all?) but it's of little consequence anyway. And she knows a midwife decided for some reason to put her down as a girl. Hence she's not trans

ETA sorry double with @nauticant

Edited

It is for this that the word 'beclowning' was invented🙄

EmmyFr · 22/01/2026 10:17

Coatsoff42 · 22/01/2026 09:54

I thought Isla Bumba wasn’t sure if she was a man or a woman. I’m pretty sure she was waiting for a genetic test to tell her conclusively and until then she was neither one sex or the other.

No no no ! She knows she's a woman because that's her gender. She's unsure about her sex (aren't we all?) but it's of little consequence anyway. And she knows a midwife decided for some reason to put her down as a girl. Hence she's not trans

ETA sorry double with @nauticant

nauticant · 22/01/2026 10:16

I thought Isla Bumba wasn’t sure if she was a man or a woman.

Isla Bumba knows she is a woman. She had to pretend she wasn't sure in order to uphold the ideological position she was advancing in her testimony.

MistyGreenAndBlue · 22/01/2026 10:15

FWSsupporter · 22/01/2026 08:52

I agree she should not have been able to change sex. But I am saying gender identity should be a belief that is protected.

Once you are clear sex is real and immutable and no one can change sex having gender identity as a belief pc is a reasonable option. I do not think it is realistic to think we can eradicate everything e.g the GRA and gender reassignment pc.

I appreciate your point of view as it has been awful for women who have lost jobs, careers and been subjected to vile abuse. However, there is a small core of people who have also been harmed by TRAs and that are those who are not activists but have gender dysphoria. I don’t want it to be legal to not give them a job or to provide a service just because they have gender dysphoria.

Gender dysphoria is a mental health condition not an identity or a belief system or religion. On what basis is it a PC? You are not making any sense. No one has a gender identity in any real sense. It's not a real thing.

MarieDeGournay · 22/01/2026 09:58

The intrusion of the concept of 'gender', meaning anything other than a grammatical term or an alternative to the word 'sex', has been very damaging for the law, and as a result, for society.

Legislation such as the GRA was drawn up and debated without a clear, unequivocal definition of the central concept: gender. Is it an inner feeling? is it an outward manifestation? is it a mental disorder? is it a social construct? is it a soul?

Who knows? Certainly not the legislators and the legal system! But hey, here's a law and certificate enforcing it it anyway!

Coatsoff42 · 22/01/2026 09:54

EmmyFr · 22/01/2026 09:50

@FWSsupporter To be clear, are you supporting the recognition of gender identity as a belief PC or of gender reassignment ?

Those are fully different things. Isla Bumba has a belief in gender identity because she believes Upton is a woman. She does not have gender reassignment because she thinks she is female, knows she was recognized female at birth, and thinks she is a woman.

I thought Isla Bumba wasn’t sure if she was a man or a woman. I’m pretty sure she was waiting for a genetic test to tell her conclusively and until then she was neither one sex or the other.

RhannionKPSS · 22/01/2026 09:52

The best solution is to reform the ERHC , get rid of “ gender” substitute with “ sex” , abolish the GRC, it’s a lie which Labour should never have introduced

EmmyFr · 22/01/2026 09:50

@FWSsupporter To be clear, are you supporting the recognition of gender identity as a belief PC or of gender reassignment ?

Those are fully different things. Isla Bumba has a belief in gender identity because she believes Upton is a woman. She does not have gender reassignment because she thinks she is female, knows she was recognized female at birth, and thinks she is a woman.

Chersfrozenface · 22/01/2026 09:35

Then a reasoned evidence based debate on how we can recognise trans and non-binary people, including detransitioners, and ensure they are treated with dignity and respect.

Recognise them? Officially? By giving them a document, say a little plastic card, with their (current) name and (current) gender?

So, remembering that gender is a totally made-up thing which only exists in the mind, the card would be have to be given on request, as no tests or criteria would be possible.

And then, to what end? What rights, or rather privileges, would that give them vis à vis non-card-holding citizens?

Also, which gender identities would be officially recognised? Male, female, non-binary only? Just those which are, in fact, based on the observable, provable, factual mammalian biological sexes?

FWSsupporter · 22/01/2026 08:58

Easytoconfuse · 22/01/2026 08:20

I agree we need to, but there are 2 sides to a conversation, as you see whenever someone decides to vist and tell us all how wrong we are while asking for sympathy and pity and, basically, to shut up, run along and give them what they want. The conversation has to start with 'the law is single sex spaces are only for people who belong to that single sex. If you don't, then it's not our responsibility to give up our rights for you, so stop demanding that we do and go and ask for some for yourselves. Think of all the trans-friendly loos that could have been bought with the money wasted by Fife and Darlington.

Absolutely.
What doesn’t help are both the UK and Scottish governments trying to undermine FWS.

What we need is a reset that makes it clear sex is real and immutable and that SSS and women’s rights are sacrosanct.

Then a reasoned evidence based debate on how we can recognise trans and non-binary people, including detransitioners, and ensure they are treated with dignity and respect.

I know women have not been treated with dignity and respect by TRAs etc. but I would rather not sink to their level.

FWSsupporter · 22/01/2026 08:52

EmmyFr · 22/01/2026 06:19

Sorry, that was clear from your message. What I meant is: she shouldn't have been able to change sex, full stop. There's no need for any alternative gender recognition at all.

Unless you're suggesting it as a bone you could throw "No, we won't change your sex, but you can have a gender change instead" ? I would have said yes a few years back, but not now that we've seen the damages of a pseudo recognition of gender everywhere, used liberally for and by people who usually do NOT have a GRC.

I agree she should not have been able to change sex. But I am saying gender identity should be a belief that is protected.

Once you are clear sex is real and immutable and no one can change sex having gender identity as a belief pc is a reasonable option. I do not think it is realistic to think we can eradicate everything e.g the GRA and gender reassignment pc.

I appreciate your point of view as it has been awful for women who have lost jobs, careers and been subjected to vile abuse. However, there is a small core of people who have also been harmed by TRAs and that are those who are not activists but have gender dysphoria. I don’t want it to be legal to not give them a job or to provide a service just because they have gender dysphoria.

Easytoconfuse · 22/01/2026 08:20

FWSsupporter · 21/01/2026 17:54

It is incredibly easy to only think about this in relation to men with AGP.

Keira Bell was observed female at birth. She decided she was transgender, took cross sex hormones, had a double mastectomy and went through the process to get a GRC. Her sex on her birth certificate was legally changed to male. Keira later realised she was not transgender. Nothing can repair the damage to her body but she has been left in legal limbo because there is currently no legal route to change her legal sex on her birth certificate back to female. I think that is appalling and is why I would like legislative change to allow Kiera to be able to correct her birth certificate.

Had the legislation distinguished between sex and gender identity Keira would still legally be female as she would never have changed her sex because it’s real and immutable. Gender Identity could be far more flexible and allow people to change or to not have a GI.

Baroness Cass found there were different routes to children becoming gender questioning, for some it was CSA. I can believe an abused child may have PTSD which includes gender dysphoria I.e. if I am a boy the abuse will stop. Baroness Cass found gender questioning often resolved by adulthood but for those adults where it persists the ability to change their Gender Identity (not their sex) may offer some relief without locking them into a permanent change.

I have been clear sex is biological, real and immutable and the legislation must reflect that. SSS are a red line and must be respected.

I hate terms like birthing parent and chest feeding and disagree with the terms being used instead of mother and breast feeding. However, on an individual human level a pregnant trans identifying female asking for these terms to be used for them whilst giving birth is something I would do.

I agree the focus is always on men, I am thinking about this from a woman’s perspective. The SC was clear there may be times where a trans identifying females masculine presentation may make it lawful to exclude them from female SSS. At the same time it is not lawful for them to use male SSS nor does that give them privacy and dignity. Employers and service providers need to make provision for these trans identifying women under the gender reassignment protected characteristic.

TRAs stance of no debate was punishing for women, we need to have open and difficult conversations that consider all the options and don’t stereotype all trans people as men with AGP.

I agree we need to, but there are 2 sides to a conversation, as you see whenever someone decides to vist and tell us all how wrong we are while asking for sympathy and pity and, basically, to shut up, run along and give them what they want. The conversation has to start with 'the law is single sex spaces are only for people who belong to that single sex. If you don't, then it's not our responsibility to give up our rights for you, so stop demanding that we do and go and ask for some for yourselves. Think of all the trans-friendly loos that could have been bought with the money wasted by Fife and Darlington.

EmmyFr · 22/01/2026 06:19

FWSsupporter · 21/01/2026 23:08

That is what I am saying should happen,

Sorry, that was clear from your message. What I meant is: she shouldn't have been able to change sex, full stop. There's no need for any alternative gender recognition at all.

Unless you're suggesting it as a bone you could throw "No, we won't change your sex, but you can have a gender change instead" ? I would have said yes a few years back, but not now that we've seen the damages of a pseudo recognition of gender everywhere, used liberally for and by people who usually do NOT have a GRC.

FWSsupporter · 21/01/2026 23:08

EmmyFr · 21/01/2026 21:10

@FWSsupporter there is a much better solution to the Keira Bell example : she shouldn't have been allowed to change her legal sex in the first place. Lies have no place on official documents.

That is what I am saying should happen,

FayeRC · 21/01/2026 22:02

CarefulN0w · 19/01/2026 13:15

I don't suppose anyone has a subscription to the Health Service Journal?

I've just seen a headline about Streeting sending an NHS England Director to investigate the trust, but I don't have access to read further.

This is very interesting. If anyone has access to HSJ can they see if there is more information in the article on who NHSE have sent and/or which directorate (department) the person is from?

EmmyFr · 21/01/2026 21:10

@FWSsupporter there is a much better solution to the Keira Bell example : she shouldn't have been allowed to change her legal sex in the first place. Lies have no place on official documents.

EmmyFr · 21/01/2026 21:06

Couldn't have phrased it better than @ProfessorBinturong

I Agree Yes Yes Yes GIF by Tracey Matney - Victory Points Social
ProfessorBinturong · 21/01/2026 20:43

Gender Identity could be far more flexible and allow people to change or to not have a GI.

There is no need for legislation or paperwork for a personal belief. Nobody has a government issued certificate to say they believe in Tarot cards, or transubstantiation. Nor do they need an official revocation process if they change their minds.

FWSsupporter · 21/01/2026 17:54

It is incredibly easy to only think about this in relation to men with AGP.

Keira Bell was observed female at birth. She decided she was transgender, took cross sex hormones, had a double mastectomy and went through the process to get a GRC. Her sex on her birth certificate was legally changed to male. Keira later realised she was not transgender. Nothing can repair the damage to her body but she has been left in legal limbo because there is currently no legal route to change her legal sex on her birth certificate back to female. I think that is appalling and is why I would like legislative change to allow Kiera to be able to correct her birth certificate.

Had the legislation distinguished between sex and gender identity Keira would still legally be female as she would never have changed her sex because it’s real and immutable. Gender Identity could be far more flexible and allow people to change or to not have a GI.

Baroness Cass found there were different routes to children becoming gender questioning, for some it was CSA. I can believe an abused child may have PTSD which includes gender dysphoria I.e. if I am a boy the abuse will stop. Baroness Cass found gender questioning often resolved by adulthood but for those adults where it persists the ability to change their Gender Identity (not their sex) may offer some relief without locking them into a permanent change.

I have been clear sex is biological, real and immutable and the legislation must reflect that. SSS are a red line and must be respected.

I hate terms like birthing parent and chest feeding and disagree with the terms being used instead of mother and breast feeding. However, on an individual human level a pregnant trans identifying female asking for these terms to be used for them whilst giving birth is something I would do.

I agree the focus is always on men, I am thinking about this from a woman’s perspective. The SC was clear there may be times where a trans identifying females masculine presentation may make it lawful to exclude them from female SSS. At the same time it is not lawful for them to use male SSS nor does that give them privacy and dignity. Employers and service providers need to make provision for these trans identifying women under the gender reassignment protected characteristic.

TRAs stance of no debate was punishing for women, we need to have open and difficult conversations that consider all the options and don’t stereotype all trans people as men with AGP.

RedToothBrush · 21/01/2026 16:43

Easytoconfuse · 21/01/2026 15:53

In principle, yes. In practice, if you go for that, then guess which group will be at the bottom of the list and expected to compromise. I don't think I'm the only person here who's fed up with compromising. Everyone else is having tantrums and saying they'll do it later so why should we have to be the adults in the room?

Perhaps we should start from this point.

Expecting women to undress infront of males is not even beginning to be compromising.

Peregrina · 21/01/2026 16:42

What ever you think about DrU and RH, legally they were not entitled to use the women’s changing room but legally their employer was obliged to find a suitable solution for where they could get changed and their dignity and privacy was respected.

For either of them, was it ever established that they had met with hostility or opposition in the men's changing rooms? As far as I am aware it wasn't - they chose the women's for their own gender affirming purposes.

As an aside how many people of either sex don't like communal changing rooms? Should they also be requesiting another place where their dignity and privacy is respected?

Easytoconfuse · 21/01/2026 15:53

FWSsupporter · 21/01/2026 15:07

@Easytoconfuse I agree following the law as it stands is the first step. There are then a lot of intervening steps which centre women and girls but ultimately we need a long term solution that is reasonable and proportionate for everyone.

In principle, yes. In practice, if you go for that, then guess which group will be at the bottom of the list and expected to compromise. I don't think I'm the only person here who's fed up with compromising. Everyone else is having tantrums and saying they'll do it later so why should we have to be the adults in the room?

Swipe left for the next trending thread