Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Robert Jenrick on women's rights

107 replies

HerGorgeousMajestyArabellaScott · 30/10/2024 08:48

From the webchat yesterday:

Justine MN: 'women's rights

@Ereshkigalangcleg bit of a mouthful - says: hi Robert, thanks for doing this could you explain how you would seek to protect the rights of women to
female only spaces when we need them e.g. Rape Crisis service prisons Etc she says transgender identity is one thing but biological sex is more important on some occasions for reasons of safety but also for reasons of privacy and
dignity.

Robert Jenrick:

Thank you well look let let me be very clear - basic biology and common sense matters - of course we must treat people with kindness and compassion but
we've got to be very clear about what a woman is. How we can ensure that female spaces are protected and the rights of women are properly uh supported whether that's changing rooms prisons competitive sport we've got to protect women's rights.

For my part I've always tried to do that - when I was a minister who had responsibility for example as housing secretary I changed the law so that no new public building can be built in this country unless it has female toilets, and I've always stood up uh for what has I say what I would call Basic biology and common sense. I'm a dad after all to three young daughters I want to ensure that they grow up in a country which recognizes those things and that we
don't blur the lines here and ensure that biology sometimes gets you know
falls by the wayside.

Justine Mumsnet:

'What about those who medically transitioned and have a gender recognition certificate though I mean you are you suggesting they should also be excluded on the basis of the biological sex they were born with or ...

Robert Jenrick: 'you this is where it becomes tricky. Right, well I think we have to be clear what what a woman is, and what a transman is. I think we have to treat people with kindness and compassion and it is right that people find happiness and dignity in their lives however they wish but that does not mean that a trans man should be using women's toilets, changing rooms, should be alongside women in prisons, should be competing alongside women in competitive Sports.

I take a strong view on this I appreciate that this is a contentious issue and not everyone will agree with me but that is my position. I think that is the best way that we can protect women like my daughters my wife my mum, the women that
I want to see have their rights protected now and in the future.

Justine Mumsnet:

'Okay. just to be clear I think you mean trans women not trans man yeah you mean, you know you you mean a - a woman, someone who transitioned to be a woman.'

Robert Jenrick:

'Yeah'.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/mumsnet_live_events/5197593-zoomchat-with-robert-jenrick-mp-tuesday-29th-october-5pm

Zoomchat with Robert Jenrick MP - Tuesday 29th October, 5pm | Mumsnet

Hi all, We’re pleased to announce a Mumsnet Asks Zoomchat with Tory Leadership candidate Robert Jenrick MP on Tuesday 29th October at 5pm. Pleas...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/mumsnet_live_events/5197593-zoomchat-with-robert-jenrick-mp-tuesday-29th-october-5pm

OP posts:
BarberBealShaw · 30/10/2024 09:09

Thank you. When did this exchange take place, roughly? MN should chapter such long videos.

AlisonDonut · 30/10/2024 09:08

Jesus H Christ.

Yeah. Absolutely bloody clueless. That's what using incorrect language gets. Total utter bafflement.

DaisysChains · 30/10/2024 09:07

You know how sometimes you are weighed down like the proverbial camel?

and then a little ridiculous mote of straw of no weight whatsoever comes floating down

you watch fascinated as it twirls around and you think ‘oop, hope that’s not coming my direction’

and it’s just so utterly ridiculous that your knees do a wobble as you try not to start laughing

because you have that on-the-verge-of-demented feeling that you won’t be able to stop

That.

interestingly tho I have begun to feel that breaking into hysterical laughter at every stupid utterance might actually be the appropriate response

borntobequiet · 30/10/2024 09:07

Jenrick is a poundshop Farage, lacking his intellect, wit and charm.
Which is really saying something.

Datun · 30/10/2024 09:02

It doesn't fill you with optimism when he can't get the sex right of the people he's saying should be excluded on the basis of that sex.

ATowerOfGiraffes · 30/10/2024 08:59

A PM (or potential future PM) should be someone who is well briefed, with an in depth understanding of the issues under consideration and an ability to debate those issues thereafter. Coming on to Mumsnet, where undoubtedly the topic of women's safety will be brought up, and being confused about basic definitions smacks of "fail to plan, plan to fail"

Hoosemover · 30/10/2024 08:57

Typical clueless Tory,
middle-aged, middle-class, mediocre man.

Swipe left for the next trending thread