Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Oxford 'Students Condemn ‘Transphobic’ St Hilda’s Professor' allegations against Professor Selina Todd, WPUK. Julie Bindel, "McCarthy is alive and well and living in a posh university:"

37 replies

R0wantrees · 01/05/2019 08:09

article in The Oxford Student:
'Students Condemn ‘Transphobic’ St Hilda’s Professor

29th April 2019 by Grace Davis
(extract)
"Professor Selina Todd, a professor of Modern History and tutor at St Hilda’s College, has been accused of being ‘transphobic’ by St Hilda’s students, after she was found to be retweeting transphobic groups on Twitter.

Amongst these include the parody twitter account ‘British Gay Eugenics’. She retweeted a tweet from this group which joked: “Please join our MASSIVE thanks to @stonewalluk, @ruth_hunt, Gendered Intelligence, & Mermaids UK for helping #transawaythegay.

“Parents, there is an alternative to having an embarrassing gay son or lesbian daughter! All it takes is timely intervention!” (continues)

As well as this, Professor Todd has retweeted several tweets from the group Women’s Place UK, and Fairplay for Women, which have previously been condemned by Oxford SU LGBTQ+ Campaign for being “transphobic” and “threatening trans people’s rights and safety”.

She is set to speak at the third London meeting of Women’s Place UK on 20th May this year, alongside Meghan Murphy, Julie Bindel, Nina Malik, and Ruth Serwotka.

On her website, Professor Todd describes herself as a “a gender critical feminist, [who faces] intimidation via social media about expressing my views, sharing the evidence that informs those views, and calling for a debate.”

She then goes on to claim: “Like every other gender critical feminist I know, I encountered the current debate about whether transgender people should be able to self-identify as such (without fulfilling other legal and medical requirements) from the instinctive standpoint that I wanted to support transpeople’s rights. But after months of research, I concluded that this position would harm the rights of women, because so often what is being asked for is free access to women-only spaces.

“I then began to question the whole premise that someone can ‘transition’ from being a man to a woman or vice versa.”

She adds: “You can’t change sex – biologically, that is impossible. And the notion that people can ‘feel’ like a woman or like a man seems socially conservative, implying as it does that being a woman rests on dressing or behaving in a ‘feminine’ way. Being a woman rests both on certain biological facts and on the experience of living in the world as a woman, from birth, an experience that is shaped by particular kinds of oppressions.

“A movement that claims to be advocating a liberating kind of ‘fluidity’ is in fact reinforcing and promoting highly conservative gendered stereotypes.” (continues)
www.oxfordstudent.com/2019/04/29/oxford-professor-found-tweeting-transphobic-tweets/

I heard Selina Todd speak a few years ago about her recent book, 'The People: the Rise and Fall of the Working Class 1910–2010'. She's brilliant & an inspiring speaker

Background Wiki
"Selina Todd was born in Newcastle upon Tyne in 1975 and, after schooling at a state comprehensive, she completed her undergraduate degree in history at Warwick University. After working in Canada and Cuba, she took a master of arts degree and then a doctor of philosophy degree in history at the University of Sussex.

Career
After holding a Scouloudi Fellowship and Economic and Social Research Council Post-doctoral Fellowship at the Institute of Historical Research, Todd was elected to the Ottilie Hancock Research Fellowship in History at Girton College, Cambridge, in 2004. The following year, she was appointed a lecturer at Warwick University, and in 2007 took a lectureship in modern British history at the University of Manchester. In 2010, she was appointed a Fellow at St Hilda's College, Oxford, and a lecturer in history at the University of Oxford In 2015, she was awarded the title of Professor of Modern History by the university. She is a fellow of the Royal Historical Society and, as of 2016, is vice-principal of St Hilda's.

Todd's research focuses on the history of the working-class, gender and feminism in modern Britain.

In July 2017, it was announced that Todd had accepted nomination as the President of the Socialist Educational Association."

Oxford 'Students Condemn ‘Transphobic’ St Hilda’s Professor' allegations against Professor Selina Todd, WPUK. Julie Bindel, "McCarthy is alive and well and living in a posh university:"
OP posts:
Ereshkigal · 01/05/2019 09:54

Buying the book, thanks Lang for the recommendation.

R0wantrees · 01/05/2019 09:53

Anyway. Selina Todd is fab and she wrote a wonderful book about all the ordinary people who told elite power structures - and their fucking idiot brats - where to go over the last century. Everyone should buy it and read it in support! Only £3.99 on Kindle!

Just to second that its a great book & worth reading!

Here's some lectures by Professor Selina Todd:
'keynote address to the Social History Society's 2017 conference at the UCL Institute of Education on 5 April 2017, debunking 'The Myths of Social Mobility'.

'Selina Todd Spks on her book "The People" at Dangerous Times Festival 2014'

February 2018, Social mobility and education: DISCUSSION - BBC Newsnight

OP posts:
Annasgirl · 01/05/2019 09:37

@BeansandRice I had this same discussion with some young students a few weeks ago. I'm a mature student who went back and am now completing a Masters in a new field. You would not believe (well you would because you are in it) the level of cognitive dissonance. And total disregard for women - even amongst young women. they totally believe the fight is over and they will sail merrily along, not needing those awful old fashioned feminists. They can be Kim Kardashian type feminists. And I am in psychology.

I also find it terrifying that a University group puts the rights of Transwomen before the rights of Women.

LangCleg · 01/05/2019 09:33

The Oxford Student can't even spell "principal" or get its punctuation style consistent. Christ. This is the elite youth in the UK, quite aside from trans issues? Embarrassing.

Mind you, what do we expect from the privileged? They've always been more interested in improving the poor than they have in the ways in which top down policies have fucked up the lives of ordinary people.

Anyway. Selina Todd is fab and she wrote a wonderful book about all the ordinary people who told elite power structures - and their fucking idiot brats - where to go over the last century. Everyone should buy it and read it in support! Only £3.99 on Kindle!

www.amazon.co.uk/People-Rise-Working-Class-1910-2010/dp/1848548818?tag=mumsnetforu03-21

BeansandRice · 01/05/2019 09:31

This shit has huge traction in elite circles. A niece, who was privately educated and is currently at Oxford, is the only member of my family who isn't gender critical

This is really interesting - I think it's that such people recognise their own privilege, and in an attempt to deny that privilege, or mitigate it away, pick a cause in which they think they can "win" the Top Trumps game of "Who is the most oppressed?"

And that it's élite/successful young women - they no longer see the need for feminism, because - well, they've made it haven't they? So clearly feminism is no longer needed, and they don't need to be feminists.

When I encounter this with my undergrads, I say - well, come back and tell me about your experience after a couple of maternity leaves, and the guy who started with you is now your boss, and you're paid around 75% of what he's getting ...

JessicaWakefieldSV · 01/05/2019 09:28

Oxbridge is really pushed at my DD’s school, it’s all they bloody talk about once you get to senior school. We are not remotely considering it, for a number of reasons. This makes me glad of it.

Rubidium · 01/05/2019 09:22

Heartening tweet from Selina Todd:

"I'd like to thank all those students @ UniofOxford who have contacted me over the past months to express horror at the attempts on Facebook and now in the student press to smear me. Very brave."

twitter.com/selina_todd/status/1123285732284665858

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 01/05/2019 09:15

It's no coincidence that it's Oxford. The combination of extreme privilege and open misogyny makes a fertile breeding ground.

R0wantrees · 01/05/2019 09:08

Oxford seems to be a particular hotspot for student TRA extremism:

Michael Biggs
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3406042-Oxford-Student-newspaper-doxes-Twitter-account-by-possible-criminal-unauthorised-use-of-a-comptuer-system

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3433485-Prof-Michael-Biggs-How-Queer-Theory-Became-University-Policy-re-Oxford-Gendered-Intelligence

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3433245-No-wonder-there-are-so-many-woke-students

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3257819-Michael-Biggs-Sociology-Dept-Oxford-Free-speech-at-Oxford-Do-women-have-the-right-to-meet-to-discuss-legislation

Jenni Murray
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3416980-Oxford-students-going-after-Jenni-Murray-again

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/2893950-LGBT-activists-try-to-stop-Jenny-Murray-speaking-at-Oxford-University

Also:
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3234661-Condemnation-of-the-shameful-campaign-of-bullying-intimidation-against-WPUK-meeting-by-founder-of-TransOxford

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3241624-dirty-protest-over-somerville-college-oxford-s-gender-neutral-loos

Here's how some students responded to serious whistle blown Safeguarding & Duty of Care concerns from senior HCPs including Professor Carl Heneghan head of Evidence Based Medicine:

(extract)
"Oxford SU LGBTQ+ Campaign has condemned the statement from the professor, saying: “Transphobic, fear-mongering articles being given priority in national news is unacceptable. Although the article includes information and statements from the Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS) that refutes its own main line of argument, emphasis is still placed upon unsupported and dangerous viewpoints.

“The prominence of this article within the issue of The Times clearly means to stir up misinformation which will exacerbate the difficulties transgender and gender nonconforming children and teenagers face in the UK.

“The article additionally relies on a statement from Carl Heneghan, who is a senior tutor at Kellogg College. His words attempt to give credibility to a transphobic rhetoric which is harmful to transgender people both within and outside of the University. It is deeply concerning that Dr Heneghan’s attempt to sow confusion about the treatment of trans children by conflating different treatment methods and rejecting information from the GIDS itself is being legitimised by the name of the University in this way." (continues)

www.oxfordstudent.com/2019/04/08/oxford-professor-describes-the-use-of-hormone-blockers-on-transgender-children-as-an-unregulated-live-experiment/

Context re Safeguarding & Duty of Care concerns:
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3518188-BMJ-Prof-Carl-Heneghan-Evidence-Based-Medicine-Oxford-Panorama-Trans-Kids-Gender-affirming-hormone-in-children-and-adolescents-Evidence-review-concludes-There-are-significant-problems

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3553935-Times-article-calls-to-end-transgender-experiment-on-children

OP posts:
Ereshkigal · 01/05/2019 08:43

Not very kind to women though, are they?

Fantasisa · 01/05/2019 08:32

The ‘Be Kind’ message is strong with the student generation.

Prawnofthepatriarchy · 01/05/2019 08:26

This shit has huge traction in elite circles. A niece, who was privately educated and is currently at Oxford, is the only member of my family who isn't gender critical.

She's very sporty. One of the sports is rugby. She thinks men who identify as women should be allowed to play on women's teams. DB told her she could be seriously injured playing against males, however they identify.

Fairness normally means a lot to her but trans apparently overrides everything. DB hopes she will eventually learn some common sense, preferably not the hard way.

Swipe left for the next trending thread