Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to say no to sisters request for no alcohol over Xmas?

560 replies

ChristmasDrinking · Yesterday 03:29

My sister has been in a relationship with a man since May. He used to have alcohol issues but has apparently been sober for 3 years. He seems nice and they seem happy.

We take it in turn to host Christmas and this year is our year. Everyone usually comes on Christmas Eve and goes home on Boxing Day. We have a party on Christmas Eve which includes alcohol, Christmas Day which includes drinks with dinner and a few drinks through the afternoon/evening and then a chilled out Boxing Day, which is usually a long walk with our dogs and a late lunch before everyone leaves.

My sister has requested that there be no alcohol this year due to her partner. I’m not particularly bothered as I don’t drink much, but my husband, adult children, my brother and his wife and my adult nieces would like to be able to have a drink.

I have suggested that my sister and her partner just come for Christmas dinner and we’ll have it with no alcohol, but she wants to be here for as long as everyone else. She is saying her partner is family and we should all be willing to have no alcohol for him.

AIBU to say no to her and that they can either just come for an alcohol free dinner, or accept that there will be some alcohol around due to it being our house, Christmas and other people wanting it.

OP posts:
Spirallingdownwards · Today 16:56

If he is 3 years sober he will have been in situations where alcohol is served and yet he remains 3 years sober. What a shame your sister is being so unsupportive in believing he won't be able to remain sober!

My father was an alcoholic who went sober and not once expected other people to not drink in his presence nor did he suddenly start drinking again just because alcohol was present and available. Why does your sister believe her bf would?

Letsgonowthen · Today 17:01

Bellyblueboy · Today 15:06

What about other guests? I know a lot of people who would politely decline a dry Christmas. The champagne on Christmas morning, the brandy by the fire. Even my non drinking g great grandmother used to love a glass on port on Christmas Eve.

I would struggle to change so many people’s experience and enjoyment of Christmas to suit one person, particularly someone who is a practical stranger. Would you be okay with not seeing other family members on Christmas to comply with this request?

Yes I would (but tbh I don't think I know anyone who'd decline being with their family and friends because it was a dry event so it's easy for me to say).

Bellyblueboy · Today 17:10

Letsgonowthen · Today 17:01

Yes I would (but tbh I don't think I know anyone who'd decline being with their family and friends because it was a dry event so it's easy for me to say).

😂 Clearly you aren’t Irish, or French.

LilyBunch25 · Today 17:11

Letsgonowthen · Today 13:16

But in the OPs scenario she's been asked. So if I was the host and agreed, which I would, I would have no resentment. I'd just be happy I could meet him and he and sister were there.

So what about everyone else? OP has already offered a dry Christmas lunch. Making it a completely dry Christmas for one person is unreasonable.

LilyBunch25 · Today 17:13

CrazyMidget · Today 02:15

Beef? For Christmas dinner? 😢 Dinner on the 25th should always, always be 🦃

Turkey is horrible. I haven't had it at Christmas since I was a child. I tried to cook it one year for my children, a beautiful free range expensive one with all the basting instructions carefully followed. Still hated it.

CatSquirrelDuck · Today 17:28

MrsClatterbuck · Today 16:51

Now that it's just me and dh at Christmas we now have fillet steak with roasted veg, salad, chips and baby boiled potatoes. So relaxing and miminal clearing up.

That sounds perfect!

CatSquirrelDuck · Today 17:29

LilyBunch25 · Today 17:13

Turkey is horrible. I haven't had it at Christmas since I was a child. I tried to cook it one year for my children, a beautiful free range expensive one with all the basting instructions carefully followed. Still hated it.

Same, can't stand it x

JHound · Today 17:33

Alondra · Yesterday 08:30

I'm lost for words reading the majority answers on this thread. Many of you have a toxic relationship with alcohol if you can't enjoy a family celebration without it.

It doesn't matter how many months the OP's sister has been with her partner/boyfriend. She's made the request because he's a recovering alcoholic and wants to help him enjoy the family get together without addiction triggers.

If he was celiac or had an alergy to certain foods, the OP would adjust the menu. But because it's alcohol, the sister is being unreasonable.

Some of you really need to think about why you can't have fun without alcohol.

If he was coeliac or had an allergy she would like likely adjust the menu FOR HIM. Not ban everybody else from eating items he is allergic too / cannot tolerate.

She is not forcing him to drink alcohol so your comparison does not hold.

CandyCrushLevel14809 · Today 17:43

Alondra · Yesterday 08:30

I'm lost for words reading the majority answers on this thread. Many of you have a toxic relationship with alcohol if you can't enjoy a family celebration without it.

It doesn't matter how many months the OP's sister has been with her partner/boyfriend. She's made the request because he's a recovering alcoholic and wants to help him enjoy the family get together without addiction triggers.

If he was celiac or had an alergy to certain foods, the OP would adjust the menu. But because it's alcohol, the sister is being unreasonable.

Some of you really need to think about why you can't have fun without alcohol.

Most people have said that they wouldn't want to have Xmas w/o alcohol. That is very different to people saying they can't, so you are wrong to say the majority have a bad relationship with alcohol.

thing47 · Today 18:07

MonsterRottenLoony · Yesterday 23:22

I think it’s sad if the value of the holiday is more linked to alcohol than who’s there. You’re welcome to think differently.

I might well agree with this if we were talking about an elderly, much loved aunt, for example.

A boyfriend of 5 months? Not so much

New posts on this thread. Refresh page