AIBU to oppose housing 1,000 undocumented young men near Piddington?

Who?

"I've been repeatedly cross questioned by some of you for adding my RELEVANT experience with one of them."

So you live in the Piddington village and have had a bad experience with one of the men given accommodation nearby? Is this what you're saying?

The USA has immigration detention centres.

Is there a reason you can’t answer the question that was asked?

https://www.deccanchronicle.com/nation/world/indians-top-uk-chart-for-rise-in-sexual-offence-convictions-report-1900036

Is there a reason you can’t read that response and understand what vetting means?

A woman from a refugee camp is less likely to rape someone, what do you think? Is that difficult to get still.

Now to you. Why are you against that system?

I’d like to see polling on this. I think most people would be in favour.

They’d be treated humanely, and being in camps they’d have outside space to exercise, and thought should be given offered jobs on site to alleviate boredom (cleaning, cooking, basic maintenance etc)

Why don't people understand risk profile and that some nations have societies and men which abuse women are egregious rates?

You've really have a had a good dig haven't you, to have to drag up some dubious article from a minor Indian regional newspaper. That will be because there is no data to support that people if Indian origin are disproportionally represented in sexual violence in the UK. In fact, most estimates point to the opposite, as you will know if you looked at ONS estimates - and it will only be estimates because this data is not even recorded.

And to reiterate -people from India do not need to come here illegally on boats!

They understand - they just pretend not to. It's a game to some bored people.

No it's not a game at all. It's that most people understand that things are a lot more complex and nuanced than predictable Reform propaganda that just operates through fear-mongering, selective and polarising information dissemination and cheap slogans.

But this is the equivalent of cheap slogans. People are able to discuss this outside what you’ve put here.

They are using data taken by the CMC which is directly from the Ministry of Justice. This has also been reported on other Indian news sites.

This isn't ethnicity (which isn't always recorded) but nationality.

Why do you say it's all fake? Would an Indian newspaper make up that Indian nationals are commit crimes at higher elevated rates?

Papers say all kinds of things. God only knows.

I would ask you this, do you honestly think that people of Indian origin in the U.K., many of whom have been here for generations and are extremely successful in all walks if our society, are more likely to perpetrate sexual crimes than the average population. Do you really believe this?

You've just used all those things you describe, in your own post.

So you're just ignoring the data when it goes against your narrative then. Stick fingers in ears.

She ignores data exactly that proves her wrong

Undocumented migrants are not Indian. Indian people have been intrinsic to British life since the 1960s - part of my husband's family came here then. The people arriving in boats nowadays are mainly Eritrean, Somali, Afghan or Iranian. All very different countries with very different issues that people are fleeing from, or being trafficked from.

When Farage goes on about a surge in Eritreans coming in with radicalised Islamic views, does he realise that over half of the population of Eritrea are in fact Christian?

It's too many men for the size of the parish.

I think large groups of men, even "nice" men, are a bad idea. I mean, ever seen a bunch of "nice" men on a football day? They can be bloody intimating when they turn into a mob.

Can't they be spread over more locations? I'm not saying I'd be delighted to have them where I am, but it would make more sense if the bigger cities took more.

Plus, if you spread them around more places, surely they have more of a chance of integrating?

I do agree it's a stupid idea to put them on the edge of a tiny village, when they could just house them in a city or larger town and nobody would notice or care. No drama needed.

A couple of years ago a 16 year-old asylum seeker was stabbed to death outside a college near to me. It didn't even make local news. Nothing.

I'm not sure I believe that. There were numerous articles in the national press when a 16-year-old Syrian refugee was stabbed to death in West Yorkshire, similarly when an 18-year-old Afghan refugee and college student was stabbed to death on playing fields in south-west London for example.

@Clavinova. It is 100% true. It happened at Richmond-Upon-Thames College a few years ago. I know this for a fact as my niece was at the college that very day. All parents of students were obviously informed. The murder was in broad daylight, just outside the doorway of the college, and witnessed by school pupils and their teachers playing football on the field. They saw the poor Afghan boy, who was 16 or 17 and trying to get his GCSE Msths and English, surrounded by 3 other boys and fall to the ground. When they got him to hospital it was too late. Nothing in the local press. Nothing in national news. Absolutely horrific and shocking. The boy was in his own here. Had nobody to fight his cause.