Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think we now live in a society where nobody cares about other people’s experiences in social spaces?

113 replies

Hellobuttercup · 12/09/2026 21:49

I used to do a daily commute by train into another city for work. I did this for several years, stopped for a few years as I was on maternity leave, then got a more local job. I now work from home most of the time but have started commuting in again once a week.

One thing I’ve noticed now in contrast to doing the same route a few years ago is the amount of people that just listen to music, watch TikTok videos, football matches etc out loud on their phones with no headphones. Am I being crazy to think this is so selfish? It’s not just occasionally either it’s every single journey I travel on that there’s a least 1 person doing it, but often more. Train staff never say anything, I’ve never said anything either as I’m quite non confrontational but there have been other passengers before that have called it out and 9 times out of 10 they are met with a mouthful of abuse. I do put my own headphones on to try and drown it out but it’s more the principle that annoys me.

A different but similar thing is the last few times I’ve been to the cinema, people just text throughout the film. Last night the girl next to me was texting almost the whole time and another in front was snap chatting the whole time, it was so distracting with phones constantly lighting up. Going to gigs and having people chatting throughout the whole set is another thing that never used to happen to the degree it does now. I know there will be people saying “why didn’t you just say something?” but why do people not just know by default anymore that these behaviours are so inconsiderate?

OP posts:
Fizbosshoes · 13/09/2026 07:49

Thepeopleversuswork · 13/09/2026 07:36

This just isn’t true.

30 years ago there would be the odd person bringing a boombox on a bus or such. But it was a taboo: someone in a position of authority would shut them down.

Nowadays it doesn’t seem to register with people that playing your own audio out loud is rude.

Exactly, and it would be unheard of to have 2 people bringing their loud stereo on the same bus....and yet its quite feasible there might be a couple of people face-timing and some others watching stuff without headphones on the same bus or train carriage.

As an aside im often amazed at how much personal info people are willing to give out, whilst on the phone in a public space. Name, dob, address, medical info, credit card details etc....as well as details on their personal life! On my commute its all overground, but reception is patchy and there are probably 4 or 5 areas where you don't get any reception, or get cut off. The number of conversations ive heard where someone has to repeat something multiple times because the person on the other end didnt hear. And I wonder why the dont simply wait til theyre at their destination and have a reliable connection.

concertinacornflake · 13/09/2026 07:51

Thepeopleversuswork · 13/09/2026 07:36

This just isn’t true.

30 years ago there would be the odd person bringing a boombox on a bus or such. But it was a taboo: someone in a position of authority would shut them down.

Nowadays it doesn’t seem to register with people that playing your own audio out loud is rude.

Being logical you are not comparing like with like.

Everyone has a phone on them all the time. Most people didn't even own a boombux, let alone could be bothered to carry it around on the way to work.

Playing audio out loud was completely abnormal then. But people still did antisocial things - for example smoking on the top deck was very common even when banned by bus companies.

FancyLilacHare · 13/09/2026 07:51

There's a weird dichotomy because on the one hand people are incredibly bad mannered and inconsiderate and individualistic, but on the other hand there's an expectation that people should should be prepared to make allowances for their fellow passenger's anxiety, mental health issues etc.

The two things seem to be directly opposed.

Smokeywater · 13/09/2026 07:55

We surely have the technology to check the speed of cyclists and facial recognition to check who they are -AI will deal with this soon - I notice I seem to be filmed when checking my purchases at Tesco - no one asked me if I’d mind? And the ones checking their purchases aren’t the ones walking out with shoplifted goods -I hope they’re filming them too.

Smokeywater · 13/09/2026 07:59

FancyLilacHare · 13/09/2026 07:51

There's a weird dichotomy because on the one hand people are incredibly bad mannered and inconsiderate and individualistic, but on the other hand there's an expectation that people should should be prepared to make allowances for their fellow passenger's anxiety, mental health issues etc.

The two things seem to be directly opposed.

Possibly the be kind and inclusive instruction is contributing to the ‘I’ll do what I want ‘ mentality ‘ - I know I hate instruction from those who presumably consider themselves superior and better in some way .

concertinacornflake · 13/09/2026 07:59

Smokeywater · 13/09/2026 07:48

Amol Rajan is starting a YouTube which I signed up for and his newsletter was about lack of socialising in communities - i happened to talk to a lady last night who wanted to have a lunch get together once a month for local people in the village hall - it was just impossible you had to have health and safety certs for the kitchen and food prep, problems if the soup was too hot, problems with nut allergies. Cost of heating . We’ve regulated our lives into a corner so people who aren’t already friends can’t just get together
the other thing is cctv it protects the boorish and selfish because anything you do like take their phone off them is assault so they can do what they want - 2 tier justice system
To add -I travel on trains up and down the country several times a year and everyone is pleasant

Edited

Blaming H&S regulation is a red herring. There are reasons people don't gather, but it is not due to improved H&S regulations.

Look at what has been closed in communities - the library, the community centre, the pool, the leisure centre, the adult education courses. Plus the shops now. Where are people conducting business? Online, alone.

Spaniels4Eva · 13/09/2026 08:01

We went to a concert last year, and for one song, the lead singer actually made everyone put their phones down/away. Said he wanted to see faces and not the back of phones just for 5 minutes.

It struck me as horribly depressing. Why pay over £200 a ticket to not participate in it at all and stand recording it, and you can't tell me that people watch it all the way back in its entirety. It's seriously put me off concerts now, as it's just a sea of phones not humans.

concertinacornflake · 13/09/2026 08:03

Smokeywater · 13/09/2026 07:55

We surely have the technology to check the speed of cyclists and facial recognition to check who they are -AI will deal with this soon - I notice I seem to be filmed when checking my purchases at Tesco - no one asked me if I’d mind? And the ones checking their purchases aren’t the ones walking out with shoplifted goods -I hope they’re filming them too.

Widespread use of facial recognition would be pretty totalitarian. Plus people would wear hats. So you'd have to make that illegal.

Increased surveillance wouldn't make society feel nicer.

Charitythoughts · 13/09/2026 08:10

concertinacornflake · 13/09/2026 07:59

Blaming H&S regulation is a red herring. There are reasons people don't gather, but it is not due to improved H&S regulations.

Look at what has been closed in communities - the library, the community centre, the pool, the leisure centre, the adult education courses. Plus the shops now. Where are people conducting business? Online, alone.

So true. DH works in H&S and it boils his piss the way ppl pretend there are a whole bunch of elf and safety regulations that stop ppl doing things. There really aren't! My local village happily runs a weekly lunch club for the village elders with a group of volunteers. Blaming H&S is as you say a red herring

we have become very anatomised as a society and therefore very individualistic. I commute by public transport a lot and it really is all ages playing stuff out loud on they're phones

threescoops · 13/09/2026 08:11

Totally agree. Quite shaken and exhausted by the ordeal of a long bus journey yesterday. Uncontrolled screaming children downstairs. Upstairs a group of young women lounging with their dirty shoes on the seats. A group of young men swearing loudly. A broken looking tattooed toothless junkie type over the aisle opening and necking bottles of beer. A big crowd of excited young women going got on, shrieking and yelling, shouting to each other, all drinking cans of alcohol. The bus was filthy with sticky trodden in food on the floor and litter. There is simply no longer any concept of standards in public behaviour, no distinction between how people relax at home and behave in public. A general entitlement, daring anyone to challenge them. People don’t seem to have any consideration for others, they’re oblivious. If you don’t like the loud stuff they’re watching on their phone, you have to find another seat. We’ve all felt our heart sink when someone sits in a train seat nearby and unpacks their greasy fast food meal so you have to smell it and watch them eat it with their hands. People in the cinema have conversations as if they are watching TV at home, and unpack and munch noisy snacks. Urgh I’ll have to become a recluse and stay home

MrsMurphyIWish · 13/09/2026 08:12

Greenismyfavouritecolournow · 13/09/2026 04:50

People need to start speaking up. Who cares if they tell you to fuck off? They’re the ones being unsociable. Who cares if they call you a Karen ? If manners means I’m a Karen then I can live with that. In a shared public space we should aim to disturb no one if at all possible. I don’t have a problem speaking up for what I believe in. I love telling badly behaved children off in public too. In front of their parents if at all possible. It’s incredibly satisfying.

Do that where I live and you’ll have a fist in your face, bricks thrown at you etc

IAmInTheHouseSidney · 13/09/2026 08:15

I jist want to point out that food safety and h&s are different kettles of fish by different regulators.
If having to mark allergies stops people socialising, then that's not really issue of regulation tbh.

Dollymylove · 13/09/2026 08:18

Respect and good manners. Its been dying slowly for the past 30 odd years.
Now its dead and buried

itsgettingweird · 13/09/2026 08:22

Everybody is extremely hot on their “rights”

Unfortunately some seem to be lacking any “responsibility”.

It’s not even to close to most lacking it. But there’s enough people who do that it impacts society as a whole.

Smokeywater · 13/09/2026 08:27

They’re hot on their rights because they have those rights - Govs have been overjoyed to appear righteous and bring in this law and that law over the last 20 odd years with no one speaking up for the downsides.

Its maybe due to a lack of clear thinking by Govs and the ‘something must be done ‘ attitude of the media - and two political parties scoring points over what the other hasn’t done

FirmSnake · 13/09/2026 08:28

Charitythoughts · 13/09/2026 08:10

So true. DH works in H&S and it boils his piss the way ppl pretend there are a whole bunch of elf and safety regulations that stop ppl doing things. There really aren't! My local village happily runs a weekly lunch club for the village elders with a group of volunteers. Blaming H&S is as you say a red herring

we have become very anatomised as a society and therefore very individualistic. I commute by public transport a lot and it really is all ages playing stuff out loud on they're phones

It's not just health and safety that gets in the way, insurance can be hugely restrictive. Between health and safety, and insurance restrictions, I don't think there's anywhere I could host a weekly lunch club near me.
Where does your lunch club meet?

SomeoneIsWrongOnTheInternet · 13/09/2026 08:30

Put more simply, the concept of a public sphere distinct from a private sphere is dead. The res publica is dead.

All there is now is everyone’s individual private sphere and their wants. It is

ArtieChoke · 13/09/2026 08:30

To tell someone they are upsetting others isn’t something they can cope with, they’ve not had confrontation for their actions. There knee jerk is to attack the accuser

people don’t know how to take responsibility for what they do, a simple sorry and turn off the screen doesn’t cross their mind

thepastinsidethepresent · 13/09/2026 08:31

dustabsorber · 12/09/2026 23:28

Mass migration is a factor

Oh FFS.

BunnyLake · 13/09/2026 08:33

VioletsTale · 12/09/2026 22:20

Why do you assume that these behaviours are exhibited by “the young”? They could very well be, but I’ve seen just as many middle aged people behaving in similar ways.

I’ve seen plenty of older people doing these annoying, anti social things too. Maybe they are the parents of the younger culprits. Like begets like.

Smokeywater · 13/09/2026 08:34

Mass migration is a factor -the outdoor cafe seating in the town centre where I live has men smoking and chatting in foreign languages presumably immigrants - I’m sure they’d give you a seat if you asked but no one seems to

ArtieChoke · 13/09/2026 08:37

Smokeywater · 13/09/2026 07:55

We surely have the technology to check the speed of cyclists and facial recognition to check who they are -AI will deal with this soon - I notice I seem to be filmed when checking my purchases at Tesco - no one asked me if I’d mind? And the ones checking their purchases aren’t the ones walking out with shoplifted goods -I hope they’re filming them too.

There isn’t the technology to catch 90% of hit and run drivers who flee https://www.psychreg.org/what-percentage-hit-runs-are-solved/

so I doubt they’d be able to catch other road users fleeing either

What Percentage of Hit and Runs Are Solved?

Unsolved hit and run accidents rising by 60% deny victims compensation and demand stronger public policy for well-being.

https://www.psychreg.org/what-percentage-hit-runs-are-solved/

FirmSnake · 13/09/2026 08:40

Smokeywater · 13/09/2026 08:34

Mass migration is a factor -the outdoor cafe seating in the town centre where I live has men smoking and chatting in foreign languages presumably immigrants - I’m sure they’d give you a seat if you asked but no one seems to

What is antisocial about having a chat at a cafe? You could do the same with your friends if you wanted to.

Charitythoughts · 13/09/2026 08:41

FirmSnake · 13/09/2026 08:28

It's not just health and safety that gets in the way, insurance can be hugely restrictive. Between health and safety, and insurance restrictions, I don't think there's anywhere I could host a weekly lunch club near me.
Where does your lunch club meet?

At the scout hall

i work fir a local CVS, nearly every local authority area has one. It's our job to advise abd support local communities that want to do things like this. In my experience immediately jump to "oh we just can't! All the rules!" without asking for help to discover the reality which is that there are some rules, they're generally not that onerous abd there are organisations like mine that can help

LipglossAndLies · 13/09/2026 08:41

I agree but one day on a bus with someone have a speakerphone conversation I did stop myself thinking how annoying because what difference would it make itnthat person on the other end was sitting next to them having the conversation. Maybe its cos the sound is more irritating over speakerphone as ots more high pitched iyswim. Obviously if the speak phone volume os up too high akin to someone shouting then I tell them to turn the volume down instead.

Cinema one I agree with

Swipe left for the next trending thread