Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To say my DS cant keep missing school because the school “cant cope”??

660 replies

Jacobator · 11/09/2026 13:19

Sorry this is long and probably doesnt make much sense but i am so fed up and dont really know if im being unreasonable anymore.

I have 2 boys, 12 and 9, both have additional needs although they are very different. DS2 has always been harder in school but usually he manages and we have never had anything like this before. Since going back this September he has apparently been having what they call explosive behaviour and he has now been sent home several times. One day they rang me before lunch and said i needed to collect him because he wasnt able to calm down and they didnt have the staff to keep him safe.

I did collect him because what else can i do, but then its happening again and again. Yesterday they rang and said basically they cant meet his needs at the moment. I said well what does that actually mean because he is supposed to be in school and not sitting at home with me because you dont have enough staff.

They keep saying they are not excluding him and that its a “temporary arrangement” while they look at what support he needs. Sorry but if my child is being told to stay at home because school cant cope with him, what exactly do they think an exclusion is??

I have asked about his support plan and whether they have actually done everything that is in it and i get lots of meetings and people saying they are concerned but nobody seems to actually have an answer. I dont want to keep having arguments with the school because obviously DS has to go there and i dont want things getting worse for him, but i also cant just accept him being kept home every time he has a meltdown.

DH thinks im making this harder than it needs to be and says we should look at specialist provision. I know he might be right but i dont want DS2 being put somewhere just because his current school doesnt want the bother. His brother is at the same school and they are very close, and DS2 already feels different enough without being taken away and told he needs a special school.

And before anyone says we should just pay for extra help, we actually do. Between therapy, assessments, things for school, transport and other bits we are spending over £2,000 a month at the moment. Yes i know thats a lot. We arent sitting on a pile of money, it is coming out of our savings and some of the things are because we have been told to get them privately because waiting lists are ridiculous. Im not saying that means the school owes us anything, just that its frustrating to constantly be told to get more support when we are already trying everything we can.

I am not pretending DS is easy. He can be very difficult when he is overwhelmed and i know the other children need to be safe too. But surely the answer cant just be send him home until he behaves normally? He cant learn how to manage school if he isnt actually allowed to be at school.

DH says im refusing to accept that he needs specialist help and maybe i am. I just feel like once we go down that road thats it, he gets labelled and everyone gives up trying to make mainstream work.

So AIBU to be pushing back on this and saying they cant keep sending him home because they “cant cope”? Or am i the one refusing to accept reality here?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Jacobator · 11/09/2026 18:22

There is a lot to reply to here so sorry if i miss anyone.

He has had SALT before and we have had OT input as well but it isnt currently written into the EHCP in the way people are suggesting. We have paid privately for some of this because waiting lists are so long. The sensory assessment is probably something i should look into properly because he definitely has issues with noise and being overwhelmed by too much going on.

I havent heard of SOS SEN before so i will look at that. I honestly didnt realise there was this much you were supposed to know yourself. I have basically been relying on school telling me what needs doing and obviously that hasnt worked brilliantly.

He doesnt get DLA. We applied a while ago and didnt get it. I dont really want to get into all his diagnoses because im not sure its relevant to the question and people can get very hung up on labels on here.

To the person saying im assuming alternative provision is for the worst of the worst, no i dont think that. I just dont know much about it. I have looked at some different places online but you cant tell what somewhere is actually like from a website. If there is something local that would suit him then obviously i would visit it.

And i am not going to just refuse to pick him up when they say he isnt safe. I know people keep telling me to do that but im not comfortable putting him or anyone else in that situation just to prove a legal point. I can challenge what they are doing without leaving him somewhere when staff are telling me they cant manage the situation.

I do think some of you are right that i have been looking at specialist school as though its a punishment. I probably have. I just keep thinking about DS being told he is going to a different school because he cant behave and that really bothers me. I know people mean it in a positive way when they say it could be somewhere better for him, but i still find it hard.

The person who said he may have been scraping through last year has got me thinking though. He did spend quite a bit of time out of class last year when things got too much. I didnt really see that as him not coping because he was still going in and doing his work, but maybe i have been looking at it differently.

He does have gaps in some of his work and there are things he missed because he was out of class, so maybe the harder work this year is exposing that more.

I am going to ask for the emergency review and DH can start looking properly at alternatives rather than just saying “special school” every time we have an argument.

I still want the school to explain why they think they cant manage him and what they have actually tried. But i will look at other options as well.

I dont think im ready to say specialist is definitely the answer, but i can at least look without agreeing to anything. I suppose visiting somewhere doesnt mean he has to go there.

OP posts:
MrMucker · 11/09/2026 18:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Kirbert2 · 11/09/2026 18:23

Zero2ten · 11/09/2026 18:14

He hasn’t been managing in mainstream until now though has he? Or he wouldn’t have an EHCP which is already failing and your DH wouldn’t have suddenly started suggesting special schools just as a result of the last couple of weeks.
DS has been scraping through the best he can but maybe he’s coming to a point where it’s too hard for him to keep doing so in mainstream.

The work is getting harder because he wasn’t always in class last year (you mention jobs away from class and quiet space to calm him down), so now the time he’s missed means he isn’t following the progression of this years learning which will increase outbursts which will increase time out of class and continue to compound the issue in a vicious circle.

Older DS will not be at the same school for much longer so maybe now is a good time to start exploring other options for younger DS. As you said, it takes time to find such placements. He’s soon going to need to cope without his brother regardless of school. Properly looking into alternative provision isn’t the same as committing to it- you can keep him in mainstream if you choose but you may find that once you’ve looked/ visited alternatives that you and DS see that there are places that suit him better.

You sound like you don’t want to consider a special school because of your own perceptions- you say how can I explain to him he is being sent to a different school because he has been bad. Please change that train of thought. He’s not being sent to a different school because he’s been bad. He’s being given an opportunity at a place which can offer him the best chance to learn and develop in an environment that suits him for who he is. He doesn’t sound very happy where he is now and has many years of school ahead of him

EHCP's can help some children manage in mainstream. They aren't only for children who need specialist provision.

HollyMcDolly · 11/09/2026 18:26

Mainstream school isn’t for him, the other students shouldn’t have their education disrupted because of 1 child, I would totally understand & support school decision

Eviebeans · 11/09/2026 18:26

Ask your local authority if there are any schools close to you that have a SEN hub. That may be a more appropriate provision for him.

Theunamedcat · 11/09/2026 18:26

School has a legal process it needs to follow and it isn't doing it this is not helpful to anyone just hoping parents will get fed up and try another school is not an appropriate way of getting a good outcome

roaringdragon · 11/09/2026 18:26

Apply for DLA again and appeal if refused. DS meets the criteria. On their website, Cerebra has a guide you can use to help you complete the form.

If you haven’t heard of SOSSEN, have you heard of IPSEA? Another charity with information on their website.

roaringdragon · 11/09/2026 18:28

He hasn’t been managing in mainstream until now though has he? Or he wouldn’t have an EHCP

Not necessarily, despite what LAs and schools sometimes say, DC do not have to fail/not manage in MS before getting an EHCP. It is actually possible to get an EHCP before even starting.

Lizchapman · 11/09/2026 18:28

Please look carefully at the specialised school as this could be life enhancing for your son

BertieBotts · 11/09/2026 18:29

I think the teacher your DS had last year was probably a very very rare gem, and the teacher he has this year is not necessarily a bad teacher, but is certainly a poor fit for him.

It is exceptionally rare IME for a teacher to be able to spot overwhelm/dysregulation building up and head it off in one pupil while being aware of and in charge of the rest of the class. Exceptionally rare. Expecting this in every class is just not realistic, and if he is constantly getting wound up because the general sound level in the classroom is over what he can manage, and there is a teacher who also has a fairly strict and direct classroom management style, this can be a complete disaster IME because if a child is already on edge because their sensory needs are not being met, then they tend to have more difficult, "on edge" type behaviour, ie, their tone of voice will be blunter and may come across as rude or cheeky, they may be leaning towards being slightly silly, even if not actively disruptive. This is exactly the kind of thing that a strict teacher will often jump on straight away, because in most pupils it would nip it in the bud and prevent the behaviour from escalating. But when you have a child for whom this kind of thing is more of a sign of dysregulation than boundary testing, first of all they are probably not even aware that they are doing this so any kind of correction will come out of the blue for them and be a huge surprise in itself, but secondly, as well as causing their behaviour to be on edge, their ability to cope with various things they find difficult is likely to also be right on the edge. So whereas perhaps normally they could accept being mildly reprimanded and just apologise and keep their head down, if they are already on edge they may experience this as a massive attack and go into a defensive escalation in response. Or whereas normally they might notice something being out of order and know that they are not really supposed to point it out, they may feel that they are unable to ignore it and point it out, which again the teacher may take as them being rude/insolent and so on, or they might misinterpret comments from other pupils as being more derogatory than they were meant which can then look like him overreacting to other pupils.

Sending him to the calm down place when he's already worked up tells me that this teacher is trying to use the tools they have been told to use for this pupil, but does not really understand the purpose of the tool or the time and place to use it. That is not necessarily their fault, and it is highly unlikely to mean they "can't be bothered".

You might be able to manage with an "in between" teacher who is not perhaps as flexible and observant as the previous teacher, but who isn't as rigid and direct as the strict teacher - however, IME, with an in between teacher, you still need a few things to be in place and I don't know from your posts whether they are. Basically he would still need to have support with other sources of stress such as the sensory input, any bullying, needing more time to process certain things etc. And the main one being that he would need to be able and willing to play some part in managing his own regulation level which means that he is able to notice when he is getting to a lower level of dysregulation and be able to communicate this and then go off and use any tools which are available to him. Often this part fails with a strict teacher, because the teacher assumes that the student's attempt to communicate is an attempt to escape or avoid something they don't want to do, or ends up using it as a bargaining chip (which will not work).

Therapies and services outside of school are useful, but unlikely to directly help with school unless the school are working with the therapist, which I've never heard of in a MS school in the UK (possibly if there is a resource "pod" within the school). The support needs to be in place IN school. For my own DS the missing piece of the puzzle was ADHD medication - that seems to bring his capacity for handling the sensory stuff up a bit, enable him not to use absolutely every single brain cell trying to concentrate leaving none to actually do the work, and reduce his emotional volatility/reactiveness so that he wasn't getting to the level of explosive that they needed to call me about it. I'm not personally convinced this is a durable solution, because I suspect it will get to a point again at some point where the demands of the school environment outweigh the support that the medication gives him, and because he was doing much better the school also seem to think that means he doesn't need any support in the classroom any more, which I find quite unlikely and think they are making a mistake expecting him to do without any, but we will see. Unfortunately you get this a lot - it's often a view that a child's needs are just a phase, or a developmental thing they will "grow out of" or their sensory needs are something they will "get used to" and while I'm sure that probably is the case sometimes, I just think they are pushing too fast and misunderstanding the nature of his difficulties.

I do think unfortunately if it's not the case that your DS has a combination of support within the classroom (which could also involve pharmaceutical support ie medication) AND the willingness/ability to manage his dysregulation himself then it might be that a MS school is not the right setting. I don't know whether MS will be right for my DS all the way through. If I knew that there was a setting for him which would offer him the chance to gain the same qualifications and where the classroom support would be there I would grab it in a heartbeat, because it is less important to me that he goes to a "normal" school, than that the school is right for him, but I do want him to have the same opportunities. Where we are, the special schools tend to have different qualifications which take longer to get into standard career routes, so I will keep persisting with MS unless it gets to the point it looks like he would not be likely to achieve the standard qualifications anyway at which point the slower route would matter less.

Blomama · 11/09/2026 18:29

Jacobator · 11/09/2026 13:35

Thanks, yes he does have an EHCP. It is being followed in the sense that they say it is, although i am not convinced everything in it is actually happening all the time. There is meant to be support in class but its not a 1:1 as such and obviously when staff are dealing with other children things can change.

The meltdowns are mostly when he gets overwhelmed or something changes or he thinks something is unfair. He can shout and throw things and sometimes push things over, but he isnt going round attacking children. He does need help to calm down though and apparently that is the problem because they say they dont have the staff available to do it safely.

I dont want him to hurt anybody obviously, and if he was a danger to the other children then i wouldnt be saying just keep him there regardless. But i do think there is a difference between a child being unsafe and a school not having enough adults to support a child who is dysregulated.

Someone asked about attainment, he is actually doing ok academically considering everything. Hes not top of the class or anything but he is not unable to access the work either. His problems are much more around behaviour, communication and coping with the environment.

We have talked about a resource base before but there isnt one particularly close to us and i dont want him travelling for ages every day either. Also this is what i mean about everyone jumping straight to specialist. We havent even managed to get the current school to consistently provide what is in his EHCP and now we are apparently supposed to accept that mainstream isnt suitable.

As for refusing to pick him up, i honestly dont know if i have the nerve to do that. They make it sound like something awful will happen if i dont come and obviously when they ring you saying your child is distressed you arent exactly going to say no sorry he can stay there.

But i am starting to think maybe i have been too cooperative with them. I just dont want DS to end up being punished because adults cant agree what to do with him.

Why do you think it's about a lack of adults? I've only ever seen parents called for support with dysregulated children as an absolute last resort. Sometimes a child can have 3/4 members of staff supporting to try and stop them from hurting another child or wrecking a classroom. I've had my staff peed on, spat at, scratched and kicked by children. When we've tried everything possible to help a child and then parents will be called - not to send a child home but because they can sometimes help. Often their child does this to the parents too at home and it's been tolerated for so long at home that it's difficult to put these boundaries in place at school. It's sounds like you think his behaviour isn't that bad. Have you started accepting quite extreme behaviour as typical? Throwing things is not okay. Shouting and pushing furniture over is not okay. I guarantee you are also using much softer language than what the school will be using. 'Pushing things over' is probably closer to wrecking classrooms and the class having to evacuate. Do you realise the amount of explaining staff are having to do to other children's parents about the disruption and upset your child is causing? Its not fair on the other 29 children in a mainstream school and it's not fair on staff. I urge you to work with the school and LA (lawyer up if you need to) so you can get a specialist placement for your child. It's not fair on him either being in a place where his needs aren't being met. Start now cause the waiting lists are years.

roaringdragon · 11/09/2026 18:31

Therapies and services outside of school are useful, but unlikely to directly help with school unless the school are working with the therapist, which I've never heard of in a MS school in the UK

This can and does happen. It is why improving the EHCP is so important. Not just for direct provision but also indirect provision. Although therapies outside of school can still help.

beautyqueeen · 11/09/2026 18:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Jacobator · 11/09/2026 18:32

I am doing things though, i probably just havent put all of it in the OP because i didnt think i needed to write out our whole home life.

We have talked to DS about what is happening and we talk about it again when he is calm. We have tried to find out what is triggering it and he keeps saying noise, being told off and getting stuck with work. We have also asked school what they have noticed because obviously they see him in a different environment to us.

At home his routine is pretty consistent. He sleeps well most of the time, eats properly although he is fussy, and we dont let him sit on screens all night. He has clubs and does swimming and football when he is able to. We arent just letting him do whatever he wants because he has SEN.

There are consequences at home if he deliberately does something wrong, but i dont give him a sanction for having a meltdown because i dont think that is going to teach him how to regulate himself. If he throws something because hes angry we deal with the behaviour and talk about it afterwards, but im not going to pretend its the same thing as him calmly deciding to break something.

I think the distinction is getting lost on here between parenting him and supporting him in school. Obviously it is our responsibility to teach him right from wrong. But if he has an EHCP and the school has agreed to provide certain things, i do think they have some responsibility for putting those things in place.

I have emailed the SENCO asking for written information about what provision has actually been happening and what they think isnt working. Im also going to request the emergency review rather than just keep having these informal conversations.

I didnt know about SEN hubs so i will look at those as well. There seems to be about 500 different types of provision once you start looking and i honestly find it all very confusing.

And yes ive heard of IPSEA now, thanks. I hadnt realised how much information there was out there until this thread.

I will look at DLA again too although i am not sure he would qualify because we were refused before. I will read the Cerebra guide first and see.

I am not saying school need to know every single thing about him. But if they are saying his needs have changed so much that they cant keep him safely in school, then surely they need to tell me what they are seeing that is different and what they think needs to happen next.

I am happy to do my bit. I just dont think my bit is to make him behave perfectly at home so that school dont have a problem with him. If he is struggling in that environment then we need to work out why and what support actually helps.

OP posts:
Toomanyhats88 · 11/09/2026 18:32

MushMashMunch · 11/09/2026 13:34

It sounds very difficult. I’m not in a place to speak about what the school should or shouldn’t be doing legally and I am sympathetic to your situation however I have been having similar issues since my DS went back. He is also 9 except it’s a classmate that is having uncontrollably “anger” as the children have been told to describe it. When that happens the whole class and teacher have to go elsewhere in the school and two senior teachers step in to help the child in question. This has happened at least 5 times since they returned. My DS is a kind boy and isn’t mean about the child and we’ve spoken at home about how he must have difficulties and it’s not his fault and it’s good the teachers are helping him. It doesn’t take away from the fact that my child (and numerous others) are scared when this happens and nervous of this child having “anger”. My DS talks about it every night at bedtime as he’s clearly anxious about what will happen. They are also missing big chunk a of regular learning and even this week missed their pe lessons as the child broke down within the first 5 minutes and the gym hall was evacuated so no gym for my DS and his class.

I suppose I’m trying to say that whilst I have sympathy for your situation and your need to ensure the best provision for your child I’m aware this is happening all over the country and I wonder why no one is bothered about the other children in the classrooms witnessing this and having to process it all. I wouldn’t work with a colleague who had “anger” yet I’m expecting my DS to go and deal with that every day. The teachers too. I’ve personally witnessed our DHT being kicked and hit with some force in the playground by a child. It was scary for me as an adult walking past to see never mind the playground full of young children.

I don’t know the answer but I wish the other children in the class were also considered when deciding whether mainstream is an appropriate setting.

I feel so much empathy for you and your son reading this. I’m a school leader and can say with certainty in my school ( and I’m sure in others) we care deeply about the other children and are worried and frustrated by what they have to see and hear and the learning they miss when class evacuation is the only way to keep them safe. It’s a really difficult system to work in with finite resources in school and within local authorities. I’m also concerned that the government drive to reduce suspensions and exclusions and keep as many children as possible in mainstream will stretch us even further.

CheesecakeAddict · 11/09/2026 18:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Littlefish · 11/09/2026 18:38

@Jacobatorplease step away from this thread for a while. In spite of some really helpful, knowledgeable comments from a few posters, there are an awful lot of posters on here who clearly don’t understand the education and SEND system and are continuing to post offensive and ableist comments.

I suggest that you post in the Special Needs area of Mumsnet where there are some really well informed parents who can offer you support.

Kirbert2 · 11/09/2026 18:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

It isn't as simple as OP just applying for a special school place. The LA will have to agree to it and they will need evidence that his needs can't be met in mainstream and even then, it may go to tribunal. It often takes years.

It isn't the only other option at all as he's just as entitled to an education as any other child and OP can't be legally forced to keep him at home.

TheLemonLemur · 11/09/2026 18:40

Sorry op its an incredibly difficult situation. I think your dh is correct and you need to change your mindset around specialist provision. You say couldn't stand ds being told he's going there because he can't behave. Thats not the case at all he
would simply be going to a school better able to support him. You also mention none being available close to you and don't want him travelling - yes travelling might not be convenient but surely is preferable to having to collect a dysregulated upset child daily

Livelovebehappy · 11/09/2026 18:42

if he has uncontrollable anger, I’m not sure what the school is expected to do? Obviously it must be very scary for the other children, and their safety is paramount. Sounds like the school have tried, but nothing is working. I’m not sure how anyone, other than a specialist councillor/therapist could help your DS. It’s not fair to expect the school to have to cope with this every day.

Kirbert2 · 11/09/2026 18:42

roaringdragon · 11/09/2026 18:31

Therapies and services outside of school are useful, but unlikely to directly help with school unless the school are working with the therapist, which I've never heard of in a MS school in the UK

This can and does happen. It is why improving the EHCP is so important. Not just for direct provision but also indirect provision. Although therapies outside of school can still help.

Yep.

My son is in mainstream with fairly extensive needs, 2:1 etc and as part of his EHCP, he gets physio and OT input at school.

blackpizza · 11/09/2026 18:50

My son was illegally exited from school as they couldn’t cope. He squarely falls in between main stream not coping (or wanting to cope - definitely dis-regulating on purpose), independents not wanting and Sen schools being unable to provide peers or appropriate education. Welcome to the world of forced home ed. There are actually many of us, I don’t miss the school runs and there is a lot of online help with how to teach. It’s not my chosen career (particularly as it’s unpaid). But my son is very happy and learning well - we don’t have any of the issues the school did as we work how he wants as and when he’s ready, it’s far more productive. I’ve no advice as I never found any help. Don’t believe the Sen schools exist, you might find they won’t have him anyway.

Bushmillsbabe · 11/09/2026 18:52

Phineyj · 11/09/2026 15:25

But why hasn't he got an EHCP? Has school applied? Do the parents know they can apply themselves/appeal a refuse to assess?

I don't know the full details, only that he doesn't have an ehcp. DD says he is bright and articulate, does well in tests. He was much better last year, occasional shouting, but no chair throwing etc, she thinks he is testing this years teacher as she is much softer than the make teacher they had last year. The new female head takes him for a hot chocolate in her office apparently when he does this, whereas last year's male head was nice but strict - so I wonder if it's a male vs female thing. Or that the new teacher allows a lot more chatter which he finds hard.

DontBuyAnotherBook · 11/09/2026 19:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

My autistic son kept pushing another possibly autistic child around in the school nursery. Yes I felt embarrassed but he had a right to attend that preschool like any other child. Leaving him at home wouldn't help him learn to behave the correct way.

DontBuyAnotherBook · 11/09/2026 19:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

My autistic son kept pushing another possibly autistic child around in the school nursery. Yes I felt embarrassed but he had a right to attend that preschool like any other child. Leaving him at home wouldn't help him learn to behave the correct way.