Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think a mini skirt is not appropriate office wear?

91 replies

Andiose · Yesterday 15:46

Afternoon all,
first of all I’d like to state, this isn’t an attack of the woman I’m referencing, I’m genuinely curious and willing to be corrected if I’m wrong.

For context, I’m 42, I have spent most of my professional life in a role which required uniforms, then took years out to raise children and complete a masters degree so I have only been in an office based role for less than one year. I work in a small office and while there are certainly women and young people, there aren’t actually many young women, so this is my first experience of this.

My team has a new employee, she is about 25, and is completing her masters but has been brought in once a week for some training as there will be very little overlap between her joining and her predecessor leaving.
It’s been a few weeks now and I’m genuinely wondering if I have the wrong idea on what appropriate office wear is. One week she wore linen trousers and a nice top, fine that makes sense. But since then she’s worn a skirt which seems to me to be a mini skirt, she is quite tall and has very long legs so it’s hard to tell if it’s intended to be a mini skirt or just appears that way. On one occasion she wore it with sheer brown tights, but on one occasion bare legs, or skin tone tights.

Now I was under the impression this would be seen as immodest in the work place, even if it is, of course that’s not my business and I’m not suggesting it is.

Im simply asking, AIBU to have been under the illusion that a mini skirt with or without tights isn’t appropriate for the work place?

OP posts:
LlynTegid · Yesterday 15:48

The issue to me is if a lot of time is spent changing seating position or sitting awkwardly to preserve modesty. It is probably uncomfortable and hinders work.

FookFookFook · Yesterday 15:49

I think this depends a lot on the workplace and nature of the business - in some places it wouldn’t be appropriate but in others absolutely fine.

TheEarlofButties · Yesterday 15:49

unless you’re in a public facing very professional role there aren’t any rules anymore.

Stopthattrain · Yesterday 15:49

You sound a bit puritanical. Is it really a problem as long as her fanny isn’t hanging out?

Andiose · Yesterday 15:51

Stopthattrain · Yesterday 15:49

You sound a bit puritanical. Is it really a problem as long as her fanny isn’t hanging out?

No I’m not suggesting it’s a problem. I’m wondering if my views which were entirely based on what I believed were social norms rather than my own beliefs were misguided.

OP posts:
DelphiniumBlue · Yesterday 15:52

I find myself wondering this, but then I remind myself that I am old and times have moved on.
My personal issue is with bum-length skirts (no doubt of the mini-ness) and strappy tops in formal settings, but it is none of my business what other people wear unless I am the person whose job it is to enforce the rules. And the rules would have be very specific before I would be doing that.

swqa · Yesterday 15:52

LlynTegid · Yesterday 15:48

The issue to me is if a lot of time is spent changing seating position or sitting awkwardly to preserve modesty. It is probably uncomfortable and hinders work.

She's a grown woman.

I'm sure she knows how to sit appropriately in her choice of clothing.

OP, I think you're living in the past a bit here and also it's bizarre that you've given enough thought to another woman's clothes to start a thread about it on a chat forum.

EverytimeItPours · Yesterday 15:52

A mini skirt means different things to different people, how short is it??

SoScarletItWas · Yesterday 15:53

How short is it?

And would you feel the same if she was 43 and short?

WerewolfOfLoudon · Yesterday 15:55

She's obviously comfortable or she wouldn't wear it. For all you know she has to wear incontinence pads and is self conscious they will be seen wearing trousers. I'm over 30 and any time I wear a skirt/dress it is never below my knees, as I find longer uncomfortable.

geekone · Yesterday 15:56

I am 50. I have been in a professional and often customer facing role for 25 years or more. I often wear short skirts I have been know to also wear a short waistcoat with my wide leg trousers if I had to reach up god forbid someone might see my midriff. I also wear trainers.

QuickPlumLeader · Yesterday 15:56

I wore mini skirts to work in my twenties but only in winter with thick black tights and a jumper or polo neck. I found workwear tricky when I was younger because it can be so stuffy. They all passed the fingertip test but in hindsight they were still too short and I probs wouldn’t wear them now in my mid 30s!

Moveoverdarlin · Yesterday 15:56

I’m 46 and would wear a miniskirt. In the winter I would wear it with thick black tights. And in the summer I have bare, quite tanned legs. In the summer I would wear dresses a good four inches above the knee, I wouldn’t wear a tight miniskirt but I wear short dresses yes.

Never in God’s name would I wear natural tights. I’m 46, not 106.

Stopthattrain · Yesterday 15:57

Andiose · Yesterday 15:51

No I’m not suggesting it’s a problem. I’m wondering if my views which were entirely based on what I believed were social norms rather than my own beliefs were misguided.

I think in most industries dress codes have relaxed a lot. I work in finance (not customer facing) and sometimes wear a mini skirt, sometimes jeans, really whatever I feel like. Piercings and tattoos are completely acceptable and I can think of a couple of colleagues with unnatural hair colours that definitely wouldn’t have gone down well in most jobs 10-15 years ago. I used to have to take my nose ring out every morning on the way to work but I think the last time I had to do that was in 2019! I’m glad that most people finally recognise that these things have no bearing on your ability to do a good job.

FeliciaFancybottom · Yesterday 15:57

WerewolfOfLoudon · Yesterday 15:55

She's obviously comfortable or she wouldn't wear it. For all you know she has to wear incontinence pads and is self conscious they will be seen wearing trousers. I'm over 30 and any time I wear a skirt/dress it is never below my knees, as I find longer uncomfortable.

How bizarre to jump to incontinence pads and her being self-conscious.
Maybe she has fabulous legs and wants to wear something to show them off.

FlapperFlamingo · Yesterday 15:59

I worked in the City of London in finance for years and certainly that wouldn’t have been acceptable, but dress codes have relaxed a lot now. I stay conservative because no one can complain about conservative! It really depends on company culture - DH’s office (software engineering) sent an email round recently saying they should wear footwear in the office and bare feet were not acceptable!

WerewolfOfLoudon · Yesterday 16:00

FeliciaFancybottom · Yesterday 15:57

How bizarre to jump to incontinence pads and her being self-conscious.
Maybe she has fabulous legs and wants to wear something to show them off.

It wasn't a jump it was an example as to a reason that is even less of @Andiose's business than how a younger woman chooses to dress.

TheLightSideOfTheMoon · Yesterday 16:01

I spend zero minutes a day noticing what my colleagues are wearing.

It’s hot. Really hot. People should wear whatever they need to get through the day.

Your ‘is this appropriate to wear’ comment has an undercurrent of ‘well, she shouldn’t have been dressed like that, what did she expect?’

I’m not saying it’s the same thing, it just has the same energy.

Avert your eyes and focus on your work.

ScarlettSarah · Yesterday 16:02

How short is short?

Couple of inches above the knee - fine. Showing her knickers - not fine.

Andiose · Yesterday 16:06

ScarlettSarah · Yesterday 16:02

How short is short?

Couple of inches above the knee - fine. Showing her knickers - not fine.

I’d say about 5-6 inches above the knee, and maybe a borderline fingertip test pass, she has very long legs.

OP posts:
MistyGray · Yesterday 16:06

Even though you say you are genuinely curious, I would say that you feel it is unacceptable as you have created a AIBU thread OP.
Are you offended by what she is wearing? What is the dress code in your office?

Sparrowsandbudgies · Yesterday 16:07

I think things have completely changed in the last 20 years when it comes to what’s appropriate office wear. Anything goes now, mostly.

Catza · Yesterday 16:10

It's very simple. Does you office has a dress-code policy and what does it say?
If it says skirts must reach the knees, then she is not dressed appropriately for YOUR workplace. If there is nothing in the policy, then it's appropriate.
There is nothing inherently immodest in a mini skirt unless you can see her butt. 5-6 inches above the knee is basically mid thigh on a tall person which is perfectly fine.

EverytimeItPours · Yesterday 16:10

Andiose · Yesterday 16:06

I’d say about 5-6 inches above the knee, and maybe a borderline fingertip test pass, she has very long legs.

5-6 inches above the knee isn’t actually very short if she has very long legs as you say

Purplecatshopaholic · Yesterday 16:13

Depends entirely on the workplace these days. In my workplace that would be fine. Although I wouldn’t go that short myself.