Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU: Is it unreasonable to consider another child when the first is autistic?

124 replies

SameIssue · 06/08/2026 16:36

Would one be unreasonable to want another child if the first born is autistic? Not complex needs autistic but still largely non-verbal (singular words based communication) requiring extra support. Both parents in a stable long term relationship with decent financial condition to support two kids.

(Bearing in mind there being no history of neurodivergence on either side of the family)

OP posts:
SameIssue · 06/08/2026 20:02

please do not think I have posted and disappeared, I am reading every single one of the responses.

extremely grateful to everyone who’s shared their view so far in particular to people who have shared their lived experience

OP posts:
TishHope · 06/08/2026 20:02

I am the younger sister of a high need autistic sibling. Growing up for me was very miserable. I would say don't do it.

Purplecatshopaholic · 06/08/2026 20:06

I wouldn’t. You either cope with two autistic children possibly with very different needs. Or what if your second child is NT and basically playing second fiddle to your elder child their entire childhood. It’s a tricky one op, for sure.

HelloCheekyCat · 06/08/2026 20:11

There was a poster recently who had ND DH and 2 ND kids, she found it incredibly difficult managing everyone's needs because they often conflicted and none of them could see OP's view so she was always bottom of the pile

Someone.said on the thread by a poster.who had learning difficulties that EVERYONE should take having kids more seriously and not just do it cos that's what we do innit or think it'll all be ok because it's a massive commitment

sunshine244 · 06/08/2026 20:15

I have two ND children. I wouldn't change it for the world as I love them both.

But... if I had known I would have 2 autistic children with different needs I'm not sure i would have chosen to have a second.

One thing that hasn't been mentioned is that divorce is enormously higher in these circumstances. I'm also yet to meet a man at an autism support group or that is the one at home due to school issues or that does all the paperwork and fighting for services. I'm sure there must be the odd one but they are very few.and far.between - especially as kids get past the cute baby/toddler stage.

Clydebuilt · 06/08/2026 20:16

I wouldn’t.

Merryoldgoat · 06/08/2026 20:19

I did this. My oldest is verbal, academically able, lower support needs.

Younger is non verbal. Complex needs, special school, high support needs.

We have some peripheral family with possible ASD but no diagnoses.

If I’d known then what I know now I’d have stuck with one.

MadamNoo · 06/08/2026 20:22

i certainly don’t want to contradict the experience of people who are dealing with much more challenging situations than me, but I would say that although the school years were difficult I am very glad my autistic son has two brothers who have helped him learn to socialise, share, show empathy, and made home life feel more fun and normal most of the time. Although I don’t want the to feel burdened, I’m also glad they are likely to look out for him in adult life too.
He was number 2, and not diagnosed although showing a few challenges when we had number 3.

Nomorebullshitnotavailable · 06/08/2026 20:28

Not read all the comments. My eldest is autistic with significant and complex needs. Needs a specialist school and 1:1 care. Youngest is 2 years below. Almost certainly has some extra difficulties, likely ADHD but thus far undiagnosed.

I was 6 months pregnant with second when nursery told me that eldest was likely autistic.

is life difficult sometimes? Yes. But the fun that I see my two having, and the bond that’s grown, is worth every moment. They love each other. And my eldest interacts more with my youngest than any other child around. They play games and music together.

My point being, having another child when your eldest has complex needs is not necessarily to the disadvantage of either child. Kids are kids no matter their needs, and they can find joy in lots of things.

Bringemout · 06/08/2026 20:31

Also know a family member with two autistic children, 1st one with a lot of help and medication has been able to live a relatively normal life. The second one is physically violent, there is very little help and his parents are smaller than him and one of them is also extremely unwell. It’s taken over their lives completely, we have a supportive family but no-one can remove the responsibility from them and they have withdrawn, they are always welcome, including their younger child but their own fears about how he is around others isolates them. Our family would always be understanding and try to accommodate as much as possible, so it’s not a case of disappearing from their lives or stepping back, I think they are worried he will hurt someone as he regularly has to be restrained but he’s over 6ft. It is not easy at all, for him or for them, he’s just so very unhappy a lot of the time, it’s heartbreaking.

It was ok when he was small, but dealing with a teenager who is bigger than most men who still needs personal care and has zero control over violent outbursts is brutal. At one point it looked like he may have been improving but he regressed to an extreme extent during puberty.

somewhereoverthechipshop · 06/08/2026 20:38

I have a grown up daughter with autism and adhd. I will say that primary school was not difficult to handle and I found it easy to parent my daughter, however the teenage years were a completely different ballgame and were the most challenging years of my whole life. Had I known how hard those years would be and how much my daughter would change with the hormones/secondary school, I would not have considered having more. Sorry to be bleak but just be aware it can get much harder as they get older.

sittingonabeach · 06/08/2026 20:49

Are you time rich?

Could you cope with 2 on your own? Friend has child with complex needs then had second child, no needs identified (yet). Thought she was in a solid relationship. DH walked out, sees DC 2 days a week if she is lucky. No overnights. She is knackered and stressed out. 2 non sleepers. Both on the go all the time. Can’t give them 1:1 time

MerryStork · 06/08/2026 20:54

Do you feel you could parent another child with similar struggles to your first? It often gets harder as they get older!
But on the other side of things we did, and there are a lot of great things about it! Ds2 has traits of autism but not enough for diagnosis at moment, although I’m pretty sure we will at some point! The one big plus is that my eldest struggles with friendships but having a sibling is brilliant for him! He has companionship, and it’s brought his social skills on no end! I love that they have each other!
I wouldn’t have a third but I’m definitely happy I had a second! He’s amazing! They both are.

BoarBrush · 06/08/2026 20:54

Our oldest is autistic, younger dc just 2 and 5 years behind her. She was an amazing wee kiddo then so we had no clue. It all went to shit at high school, the knives literally came out. She's settled a bit now but caused a massive argument a few weeks ago about how us other 5 are close and hate her, she spends so much time in her room or being completely volatile to anyone outwith it that it's just impossible.

Would I? No. Would I have my other 3 no bother, yes!

VoltaireMittyDream · 06/08/2026 20:58

Warning: long post incoming!

I have one autistic child, nearly secondary age. Low support needs, high masking, hyperlexic, high IQ, able to attend school (but only just). He has ARFID and PDA and can’t tie his shoes or dress himself or wipe his own bum or sleep in his own bed or be left in the care of anyone but me and DH.

Things are hard. Really, really fucking hard, a lot of the time. Particularly as he gets bigger and stronger - it can be scary when he lashes out. My life would not be manageable at all if I had a younger child to take care of at the same time.

YMMV of course - every child is different, every family is different. I do know larger ND families where things are just fine - but they generally all have low support needs & decent adaptive function. The sort of cluster of ASD traits where maybe you don’t like crowds or wool jumpers or loud noises but you are uncommonly emotionally stable and can manage perfectly well as long as you’re left alone to enjoy a quiet orderly life with very few other people around.

Having plenty of money and support is certainly a lot better than having neither - but so much depends on what support the child will tolerate, or can be helped by.

And never underestimate how much it costs to raise a child with even a ‘mild’ disability, starting with the almost inevitable, in my experience, loss of one parental income as the child’s needs become more complex. You can’t assume things will get easier when they go to school, or when they become teenagers, like parents of NT kids can. They don’t need you less - their needs often become much more complicated and expensive and mentally and logistically taxing, and involve so much exhausting high-stakes decision-making.

Most families I know with any autistic children have all autistic children - or at least all ND - often with needs that are in direct opposition to one another, and being the main caregiver in that situation is way more than a full-time job, with no respite and no meaningful support (and often a heap of judgement from teachers and professionals, and sometimes your own friends and family).

I went through a broody phase when DC was young, and I am glad I was already too old for more babies by that point. A lot of it was just hormonal, biological broodiness, but I think I was also hoping that if I had another child it might be a redemptive experience where I got to feel (and be treated by others) like an effective parent and a competent human being, able to comfort my child in the usual ways most children can be comforted, and teach them basic life skills and manners in the usual ways and on the usual timescales. And I wouldn’t have to feel like such a puzzling failure all the time.

And in a way, sticking with one has meant that I have had just enough headspace to work through all of that and toughen up and believe in my own competence and accept the reality of our lives, and find a sense of humour about it all - rather than dumping a lot of my own unprocessed shame on my autistic DC in an attempt to avoid having to feel it and sort it out.

That’s just my experience. And I’m not trying to be a downer. But sticking with one has worked best for our family.

Tunnocks34 · 06/08/2026 21:07

VoltaireMittyDream · 06/08/2026 20:58

Warning: long post incoming!

I have one autistic child, nearly secondary age. Low support needs, high masking, hyperlexic, high IQ, able to attend school (but only just). He has ARFID and PDA and can’t tie his shoes or dress himself or wipe his own bum or sleep in his own bed or be left in the care of anyone but me and DH.

Things are hard. Really, really fucking hard, a lot of the time. Particularly as he gets bigger and stronger - it can be scary when he lashes out. My life would not be manageable at all if I had a younger child to take care of at the same time.

YMMV of course - every child is different, every family is different. I do know larger ND families where things are just fine - but they generally all have low support needs & decent adaptive function. The sort of cluster of ASD traits where maybe you don’t like crowds or wool jumpers or loud noises but you are uncommonly emotionally stable and can manage perfectly well as long as you’re left alone to enjoy a quiet orderly life with very few other people around.

Having plenty of money and support is certainly a lot better than having neither - but so much depends on what support the child will tolerate, or can be helped by.

And never underestimate how much it costs to raise a child with even a ‘mild’ disability, starting with the almost inevitable, in my experience, loss of one parental income as the child’s needs become more complex. You can’t assume things will get easier when they go to school, or when they become teenagers, like parents of NT kids can. They don’t need you less - their needs often become much more complicated and expensive and mentally and logistically taxing, and involve so much exhausting high-stakes decision-making.

Most families I know with any autistic children have all autistic children - or at least all ND - often with needs that are in direct opposition to one another, and being the main caregiver in that situation is way more than a full-time job, with no respite and no meaningful support (and often a heap of judgement from teachers and professionals, and sometimes your own friends and family).

I went through a broody phase when DC was young, and I am glad I was already too old for more babies by that point. A lot of it was just hormonal, biological broodiness, but I think I was also hoping that if I had another child it might be a redemptive experience where I got to feel (and be treated by others) like an effective parent and a competent human being, able to comfort my child in the usual ways most children can be comforted, and teach them basic life skills and manners in the usual ways and on the usual timescales. And I wouldn’t have to feel like such a puzzling failure all the time.

And in a way, sticking with one has meant that I have had just enough headspace to work through all of that and toughen up and believe in my own competence and accept the reality of our lives, and find a sense of humour about it all - rather than dumping a lot of my own unprocessed shame on my autistic DC in an attempt to avoid having to feel it and sort it out.

That’s just my experience. And I’m not trying to be a downer. But sticking with one has worked best for our family.

Absolutely second this. My son is very high functioning, very able, quite able to ‘blend’ with his peers. BUT it was difficult getting here. Between 7-11 consistent meltdowns, and violent outbursts. We have spent thousands on private therapy for him, family therapy for ourselves, courses for my husband and I to learn how to parent him (and I am a teacher with a masters in SEND) Replacing clothes that he has eaten, buying him different foods, redecorating when he punched holes in walls, paying for things like first class on trains so it is quieter and he is guaranteed a seat. Lots of things that all add up.

We’re extremely lucky, and fortunate we have a decent family income, my husband is amazing and everything is 50/50. We have a supportive family base around us.

ZeroMotivationWithTeens · 06/08/2026 21:17

I think it would depend on how much the neurodiversity impacted the family as a whole eg are trips/lifestyle curtailed/heavily constricted or adapted because of it, would it prevent the new sibling being able to do clubs or have friends over or would they be expected to care for the ND child in the future, if any of those were a yes then i probably wouldnt have a sibling.

Sausagessss · 06/08/2026 21:25

YANBU at all. Yes, we do tend to find life more of a struggle than average, but my DH and I are both autistic, both had a tough time at secondary school (and adolescence in general was hell, though we were undiagnosed so had no support) but now have a great marriage, fulfilling careers, multiple degrees between us, and are the proud parents of brilliant autistic DC. We’ve both had to cut our working hours and prioritise jobs with flexibility over better pay, and we certainly have our ups and downs, but we’re a happy family with friends, interests, hobbies, etc and I wouldn’t change any of it*. Incidentally our older DC is the one with slightly more complex needs; our youngest manages brilliantly with minor adjustments. Not trying to paint a rose-tinted picture but there are plenty of families with neurotypical DC that struggle far more than us for all sorts of reasons. If you want a second child and your relationship is good, I’d go for it.

*ETA: I would absolutely change the meltdowns, anxiety, social difficulties, sensory overwhelm, etc etc - that is all tough AF. But most people have their struggles in life and those are ours, which are totally worth it for having my DC. That’s my two cents FWIW 🤷‍♀️

bringonyourwreckingball · 06/08/2026 21:44

As the sibling of a disabled child (physical not ND) I wouldn’t. I was the first child, it was my sister who has cerebral palsy. I love her to bits, of course I do but my childhood was very restricted because of her needs, I never had much attention it severely affected my self esteem. I am now facing older age as possibly/probably her carer. You really have to think long term, not just the baby/toddler/child years

Doveyouknow · 06/08/2026 21:56

We had ds2 before ds1 was diagnosed. Ds2 is NT and they generally get on really well together. I think that having a sibling has helped ds1 but also ds2 gets a lot from having an older brother. While autism has a genetic element, I know plenty of families where siblings of autistic kids are NT. Obviously there is an increased risk but it's not given.

Whatafustercluck · 06/08/2026 22:17

I love my dd with every fibre of my being, but if I'd had her first I wouldn't have chosen to have another. And she's 'high functioning' (for want of a better term).

gamerchick · 06/08/2026 22:22

It's up to you. My eldest wasn't diagnosed until she was 26. My youngest will never leave home. If I could go back knowing what I know now, I wouldn't have had kids at all. It's different when they're full grown adults and you'll never see them independent.

There will be undiagnosed autism in the families somewhere. We often don't see it because it's all normal to us.

SameIssue · 06/08/2026 22:46

VoltaireMittyDream · 06/08/2026 20:58

Warning: long post incoming!

I have one autistic child, nearly secondary age. Low support needs, high masking, hyperlexic, high IQ, able to attend school (but only just). He has ARFID and PDA and can’t tie his shoes or dress himself or wipe his own bum or sleep in his own bed or be left in the care of anyone but me and DH.

Things are hard. Really, really fucking hard, a lot of the time. Particularly as he gets bigger and stronger - it can be scary when he lashes out. My life would not be manageable at all if I had a younger child to take care of at the same time.

YMMV of course - every child is different, every family is different. I do know larger ND families where things are just fine - but they generally all have low support needs & decent adaptive function. The sort of cluster of ASD traits where maybe you don’t like crowds or wool jumpers or loud noises but you are uncommonly emotionally stable and can manage perfectly well as long as you’re left alone to enjoy a quiet orderly life with very few other people around.

Having plenty of money and support is certainly a lot better than having neither - but so much depends on what support the child will tolerate, or can be helped by.

And never underestimate how much it costs to raise a child with even a ‘mild’ disability, starting with the almost inevitable, in my experience, loss of one parental income as the child’s needs become more complex. You can’t assume things will get easier when they go to school, or when they become teenagers, like parents of NT kids can. They don’t need you less - their needs often become much more complicated and expensive and mentally and logistically taxing, and involve so much exhausting high-stakes decision-making.

Most families I know with any autistic children have all autistic children - or at least all ND - often with needs that are in direct opposition to one another, and being the main caregiver in that situation is way more than a full-time job, with no respite and no meaningful support (and often a heap of judgement from teachers and professionals, and sometimes your own friends and family).

I went through a broody phase when DC was young, and I am glad I was already too old for more babies by that point. A lot of it was just hormonal, biological broodiness, but I think I was also hoping that if I had another child it might be a redemptive experience where I got to feel (and be treated by others) like an effective parent and a competent human being, able to comfort my child in the usual ways most children can be comforted, and teach them basic life skills and manners in the usual ways and on the usual timescales. And I wouldn’t have to feel like such a puzzling failure all the time.

And in a way, sticking with one has meant that I have had just enough headspace to work through all of that and toughen up and believe in my own competence and accept the reality of our lives, and find a sense of humour about it all - rather than dumping a lot of my own unprocessed shame on my autistic DC in an attempt to avoid having to feel it and sort it out.

That’s just my experience. And I’m not trying to be a downer. But sticking with one has worked best for our family.

That third last paragraph has hit particularly hard, thanks for sharing!

OP posts:
Nearly50omg · 06/08/2026 22:52

Just because there’s no official diagnosis’s of ND in the families doesn’t mean there isn’t - where do you think your child got it from? It’s usually genetic from my experiences and if you have another they will be ND even if they aren’t as severe as your current child they WILL be ND!!

x2boys · 06/08/2026 22:53

SameIssue · 06/08/2026 22:46

That third last paragraph has hit particularly hard, thanks for sharing!

Has your child had any genetic testing ?
My son had a microarray test when he was three which picked up a chromosome deletion which they think is the underlying reason for his autism
Whist they can be inherited froma parent tests showed his was de novo
Just a thought it might help .